Bridger,
I spend my share of time on the muzzleloader forums as well and have a few other "stains" to try. I wanted to practice on something before finishing a piece of my own that I had a bunch of hours in carving etc,......figured some antique tools was as good as any. As far as majic maple goes I've used it twice and was satisfied with the results both times. Would use it again.
Good luck, -Aaron