heat treatment and regrinding knives on 1x30belt sander!

Joined
Mar 2, 2014
Messages
2,585
Is it possible to regrind knives without screwing up the heat treatment, I have reground few of my knives (slowly and dipping in water) and haven't noticed any difference.What are your experiences on it, and which belts would I need for s30v, s90v or similar.
 
My experience, I haven't noticed a difference, but it's hard to tell between a crappy heat treat and a good one unless you're specifically testing for it.
I had a conversation on this subject recently, it would be best to do all your grinding wet (as in, with an continual supply of water being applied to the knife). That conversation was in regard to grinding a zero edge though, so if you just do the primary bevel with a sander and do the edge by hand you might be able to get away with it.
The problem with grinding the edge bevel is the metal is so thin that you build heat incredibly fast. You could just take off the overheated metal at the edge afterwards to get back to good steel, but then you're back to square 1 if your intentions were to have a really thin edge.
Apparently water cooling an over-heated edge is actually counter-productive as well, I'm guessing it cools too fast. Most modern steel types can actually air quench to a certain extent so it makes sense that such a thin piece of metal would cool rapidly without the rest of the blade being the same temperature.
Again, that's only if you get the edge too hot, if you avoid over-heating the edge in the first place, then using water should be fine (keeping the blade as a whole below 500 degrees F, or whatever the tempering temperature of your steel is).

A few years back I used Blue Zirconia belts for my 1x30 sander and they work well (resist loading and good longevity).
 
Last edited:
That's exactly what im doing, not touching the actual edge , just primary grind.at the end I do few passes on stone to cut off little metal that might have overheated and then sharpen.Performance is through roof.Will just get better belts instead of the cheapest ones.I just reground Kershav groove where the blade was way too thick and grooves were interfering with whatever was cut.Now its full convex and it cuts like crazy, whittles hair with little effort and still is strong enough for all cutting tasks.
 
Back
Top