Help deciding which bm

[baconslimjim]

Just what the title says , I can get either one of these , but I can't decide which one would work best for my needs. I'm wanting a good all around outdoor knife , and for me that means a knife that can clean deer and fish while occasionally serving as a good food prep knife. I just can't decide which blade length would be best to fill all these needs.

Please don't recommend any other knife , because these are the 2 available to me right now.

Thanks

 

[jpm2]

My pick would be the hidden canyon.

 

[BladeCommander]

The longer one.
The short one looks a tad too stubby IMO. Plus the longer one just looks more versatile.

 

[Shooter.762]

I'd get the Saddle Mountain Skinner in G10.
I have held it several times and never buy it because I have a ton of hunting blade even though I love it dearly!
It's a perfect 1 knife to take into the woods for hunting. I'd go that route, the 4" blade is much more usable..