Help finding a multi blade EDC besides the stockman.

Joined
Jun 6, 2012
Messages
1,670
Nothing against the stockman but I already have several. I know that it is probably a heresy to carry a multi blade EDC besides the stockman but I want something different. What should I get? I want something about 4" closed with at least two blades but no more than four. Clip point main with sheepsfoot would be nice. Wait, that sound like a stockman with out the spey.

Does such a critter exist? Or is there an alternative? How about the muskrat? Let me know what you think!
 
Sure - Whittlers and Congress knives are what you're talking about if you want 3 or 4, otherwise it's Jacks (one or two at the same end) or Canoes, Pens, Muskrats, Conductors, Half-Whittlers, Half-Congress, White Owls, Mooses, Furtakers, and probably a few other names for opposite end single blades.
 
Also have a Boker congress forgot to mention that. I like the looks of the Queen splitback whittler but is that an EDC knife?
 
I don't have any use for the spey blade on the stockman. That and I guess I am unsure of the splitback design. It is new to me and I worry that the mainspring will break more easily than an other style of traditional. Not that I plan to use the splitbacks secondary blades hard. The main blade will be called upon to cut plastic straps (no metal in them), cardboard and, occasionally, my lunch.
 
You looking for something like this?

GEML538210MWC.JPG


Or maybe this?

GEML748212BS.JPG
 
From memory Boker had a 2 blade 4" stockman in their evergreen series with a clip main and sheepsfoot secondary which might float your boat.

Matt
 
I realized that I would also like my edc to have a good stainless or semi stainless blade. Queen has really spoiled me with their D2. That furtaker looks nice with its 440C blades but I wish the wood looked nicer. I will have to keep looking.
 
Sounds like you need 2 blades, one for food, one for packaging.
I like a trapper for this, & keep the spey for food. A full length spey is a different thing to the tiny spey on a stockman.

But from reading this thread, I don't think it is a whittler your after, I think you want 2 full length blades, whatever shape takes your fancy.
 
Take a look at the GEC calf roper. Its a three blade at about three and a half inches. Clip, sheep and small drop I think. The cattle barron might work for you. It's a four blade about four inches. Sheep, clip, spear and HJ. The saddle trapper shown by JC57 might be perfect if you can use the whar blade as the sheep blade. It's right under four inches. You might even be able to find one of the 2012 forum knives!

Good luck!
 
Last edited:
How do you feel about Case knives? They make a '54 pattern Trapper with both Clip and Wharncliffe blades. Decent sturdy knives, and most of them are in their Tru-sharp stainless. It's a bit over 4" closed. The blade is really closer to a lambsfoot, what folks here have been calling a 'lambcliffe.'

The only one in current production that I know about is their SHOT show trapper. It's red jigged bone with a Stars and Stripes shield. Google 'Case 6254w shot show' and you'll find it. Mike Latham has some older versions on his web site, www.collectorknives.net, if you want to look at them.

GEC doesn't seem to like to put out a lot of their patterns in stainless, so you may have more of an issue there. I've got one of their #48 Trappers in 440c and it's a great knife, just under 4", but the secondary blade is a full length spey, which you don't want.
 
Last edited:
Does such a critter exist? Or is there an alternative? How about the muskrat?

Hawbaker muskrat. One "California" clip, one wharncliffe. Unfortunately, not many (if any) are currently being made, but you can find NOS ones in a few places, or just keep trolling eBay. Queen, Schatt and Morgan (by Queen), Robeson (by Queen), Northwoods (under contract by Queen), Canal Street, Bulldog, and Case all made Hawbaker specials. The Queen made ones and the Canal Streets are probably the easiest to acquire. The Case Hawbaker Specials are all vintage (70's and early '80's), and command high prices (and aren't stainless). The cream of the crop is the 2004 Case/Bose muskrat in 154CM, but if/when you find one, it won't be cheap. All are 3 7/8" or 4" depending on the model or who's holding the ruler (the Case/Bose is 3.75").

As others have mentioned, a wharncliffe trapper also offers a clip and a wharncliffe blade. Case makes/made them in mini (3.5") and full (4.25") size (and tiny - but I doubt that interests you). If you've got an extra $450 or so lying around, wait until November for the Case/Bose annual release.

I like the looks of the Queen splitback whittler but is that an EDC knife?
.
.
.
That and I guess I am unsure of the splitback design. It is new to me and I worry that the mainspring will break more easily than an other style of traditional. Not that I plan to use the splitbacks secondary blades hard. The main blade will be called upon to cut plastic straps (no metal in them), cardboard and, occasionally, my lunch.

The Queen whittler is a fine EDC knife. No need to worry about strength/durability. The coping blade won't be quite as stout as a stockman's sheepsfoot, but it's by no means fragile. It's a very pocket friendly EDC, but quite a bit smaller than the 4" knife you're looking for.

Or you could just stick with a stockman. They're not as common, but there's stockmans out there with pen or short clip blades instead of the spey. Most common is the Case 63032. And its predecessor, the 6332, as well as the 6318HE, but those two will only be found in carbon steel (not stainless).

Camillus had their 72 "carpenter's whittler" patter, which is a tapered swell center with a large clip, coping, and short clip arranged like a stockman (not a whittler as we define it). 3 5/8"closed.

Queen made some stockmans with a long California clip, sheepsfoot, and short clip under the Robeson Mastercraft name. 3 7/8" or 4" closed...I can't remember exactly.

Then there's the daddy of all those stockmans, the Queen/Schatt and Morgan File and Wire stockman. ATS-34 main blade with sheepsfoot and short clip (those are 420HC). A bit hard to find though. 3 7/8" closed.
 
Last edited:
We seem to have much in common.
I carried nothing but stockman knives for years,
now have a fair number of stockman knives.
and have been branching out to try other patterns.
And I like Queen D2.

I've been surprisingly impressed with the Queen canoe. I don't normally care for spear points. But, I like this one. You might like one, also.
 
I totally missed the size on the whittler. I must have been to busy admiring it.

Let me rephrase my criteria:
#1: Multi blade
#2: No spey (IDK about long spey but for the time being I am going to say no.)
#3: Can be almost any combo of main and secondary blades, as long as the knife meets my "no spey" requirement.
#4: Stainless blades
#5: About 4" closed. Give or take an 1/8th of an inch. (I have a Case stockman that is 4 and 1/4" closed. I have found this just too heavy for pocket carry.)
#6: About $100 or less

These criteria have knocked out two of my favorite contenders on the basis of being to large: Schatt and Morgan Barlow and an English Jack. The canoe is a little small, unfortunately. Other than that a nice pattern but not what I am looking for today.

To the gentleman who suggested the Case wharncliff trapper, hats off to you sir. I just looked it up and I think that you have found the knife I was looking for in my original post.

Now to find a gentleman's carry...
 
Case Copperhead is 3 7/8" long and has a main clip blade and a secondary relatively long pen blade. It is currently produced in stainless steel for a bit under $50.

Here is a pic of one I own (you don't have to get a blue one)



Here is a pic of several others, including a couple of Mini Copperheads:



The ones with a lambcliffe main are not currently in production.
 
Queen Half Congress
4" of goodness on a single spring
D2 is as near to stainless as you need
Light in the pocket

And you can get the same Congress with four blades
A much more substantial knife to hold and carry
The redundancy meant your knife will be sharp for ever in the field

attachment.php


Queen Muskrat in D2 4" on a single spring
A very slim disappear in your pocket knife
I sharpen the two blades very differently. one very acute and the other obtuse

attachment.php
 
Last edited:
I would vote for either the Tidioute #74 Saddle Trapper or the Case Wharncliffe Copperhead.

CHA_saddletrapper1_zpsaa0ef410.jpg~original


6249W_SS_zpsb4db0843.jpg~original


Both are just a hair under 4" closed, with both straight edged and bellied blades for maximum versatility.
 
Thanks for all the great suggestions!

I have decided to get the Case Trapper with lambscliffe secondary. I think this will go well with the Queen Mountainman and slimline trapper that I had already picked out.
 
The GEC 79 Workhorse Whittler gets my vote. Three very handy blades, master spear, secondary clip and sheepfoot/wharncliffe make it exceptionally useful and all blades run on their own spring. Springs are not too stiff and the blades take an extreme edge. Here's mine along side a pre '80 Case 6392:



 
Back
Top