Help?

Joined
Dec 8, 2006
Messages
1,156
I'm hellbent on getting a new benchmade. I only have a mini-grip and at one point in time I hade a 940 and let it go (stupid). Anyway, I narrowed down the models and I would love to hear your opinion on them and see if you guys will help me make a decision. As of now, I'm kind of leaning toward the 710 but I'm not sure.

580 Barrage
940
943
710
950-1
BMHK14210
 
I'm inclined toward the 710, having recently bought one myself (my first Benchmade).

The pluses are:

1. It's a long blade, a tad under 4" per the mfr. The blade is also strong, being a saber grind with a thick spine. It's heavy duty for a folder IMO.

2. It's size efficient, meaning that the size of the handle is only a tad longer than the blade. Compared to a Spyderco Military or Skirmish or a Rukus, it's much smaller even though the blade is the same size or a 1/4" shorter. It's fairly flat and fits in the pocket easily.

3. D2 steel is a good steel.

4. Axis lock, though that might not distinguish it from the other BMs.

5. The G10 scales, while not tacky, give a better grip than any metal scales (unless they are checkered ;)). The scales have some channels and are textured. I feel that you could grip it well if the knife were wet.

6. The handle flares out toward the blade, providing the equivalent of a handguard. There is jimping on the front of the handle to provide additional purchase. The way the handle fits in my hand, I can rest the butt of the handle in my palm to provide further protection against slippage if the blade hits something solid while piercing the subject matter.

Minuses

1. Other blades with a full flat grind might be better for slicing, though they would not be as sturdy.

2. You might prefer other steels.

3. Some people don't like recurve blades because they view them as difficult to sharpen. I have a Sharpmaker, and it is reported to be easy to sharpen on that. I haven't had a need to test that out yet.

4. A 4" blade might be too big for what you want.

5. Some people don't like how close the thumbstuds are to the handle, making it hard for them to open the blade. But that can be overcome by the proper technique. I now find it easier than my Spyderco Delica, though that is still a bit stiff since that's really new.

All in all, if you want a large blade, the 710 is the best choice IMO.:thumbup:
 
Gasp! I thought you were caught in the Spyder web! Now you're going back to the butterfly? :)

No I'm fine in the web :) I just am dying for a tactical Axis lock. I really think the 710 is great, the only problem I have with it is that the ergonomics look off, almost like youre holding a pointy stick, and from what I've heard, the g10 is smooth.
 
I have been looking at the 940s for a while now. I really like their blade shape. Of all the ones on your list, I would pick up the 940.

That being said I picked up a 930 Kulgera the other day. It like its look and feel. I would easily recommend the 930 to friends.

Hope it helps,
STICF
 
Not sure what you mean by holding a pointy stick. I like the ergonomics of the 710 better than the Delica 4, but that's because the 710 is thicker and the finger bumps on the D4 are in the wrong place for me. The 710 doesn't have finger bumps, and my fingers can wrap where they like. But the knife you choose has to feel right in your hand, not mine or anyone else's.

The G10 is not smooth. You may have misinterpreted comments that it's not as grippy as people would like. It's not rubbery or "grippy." But it most certainly is not smooth. It's textured (in addition to having 2 large and 4 small channels on each side).

The Kulgera is excellent IMO. That was the one that I was going to buy before I switched to the 710. Ultimately what made me switch was that I wanted a large folder and for that, I wanted a longer, more heavy duty blade. The Kulgera is more refined looking.
 
No I'm fine in the web :) I just am dying for a tactical Axis lock. I really think the 710 is great, the only problem I have with it is that the ergonomics look off, almost like youre holding a pointy stick, and from what I've heard, the g10 is smooth.

The 710 is a much larger knife than the 940. And yes, the G10 is fairly smooth feeling (almost like hard plastic), but it is textured and fairly grippy (but less so than Spyderco's G10).

I've not yet handled the 580, so I have no idea how the assisted AXIS lock works.

The 14210 is kinda small, but it fit my hand better than the 705/706 despite being the same dimensions.

The 930 Kulgera is a very sexy knife, but personally, its ergos didn't fit my hand.

If you liked the 940, just get another, or get a 943 if you like that blade style better (otherwise, it's the same knife). My 940D2CF is one of my favorite EDCs. I basically quit carrying my 710HS entirely after getting my 940.
 
710. I have moved on to Sebs, but I still have my Morpho, and Ritter and mini Ritter. However, I have had a 154CM 710 and a D2 710, and wouldn't mind having one again, for a user.
 
I'm not real fond of the 710 as I think there are better AXIS lock knives.

I really like the 950 rift. It is my favorite BM that I have had. I also really like the 14210. This knife has a thicker blade than the 950 and is super smooth. And I'm not sure I would say it is small. It is shorter than a 710 but about the same size as the 950 and quite a bit bigger feeling than a mini-grip. I would go with one of these 2 myself but cant comment on the others in your list.
 
The 710 is a much larger knife than the 940. And yes, the G10 is fairly smooth feeling (almost like hard plastic), but it is textured and fairly grippy (but less so than Spyderco's G10).

I've not yet handled the 580, so I have no idea how the assisted AXIS lock works.

The 14210 is kinda small, but it fit my hand better than the 705/706 despite being the same dimensions.

The 930 Kulgera is a very sexy knife, but personally, its ergos didn't fit my hand.

If you liked the 940, just get another, or get a 943 if you like that blade style better (otherwise, it's the same knife). My 940D2CF is one of my favorite EDCs. I basically quit carrying my 710HS entirely after getting my 940.

I always wondered how the Assisted Axis is. Now that you say that about the size of the 710, I might hold off on it. It IS a pretty big knife. Maybe I'll just get another 940 or a 943 with the black on black.
 
No I'm fine in the web :) I just am dying for a tactical Axis lock. I really think the 710 is great, the only problem I have with it is that the ergonomics look off, almost like youre holding a pointy stick, and from what I've heard, the g10 is smooth.

In that case, get the BM 520. Its a TANK!
 
The 710 is one of my all time favorites, but I recently got a Rift and it's got some very strong points too.

Judging from the 710-801 I just got, Benchmade at some point started putting more of a matte finish on the G-10 -- definitely grippier than the older versions I've had.
 
I really like the 940. Nice size blade in a small package! GOOD LUCK! Benchmades are top notch so any of those will serve you well! Kevin :thumbup:
 
I have been looking at the 940s for a while now. I really like their blade shape. Of all the ones on your list, I would pick up the 940.

That being said I picked up a 930 Kulgera the other day. It like its look and feel. I would easily recommend the 930 to friends.

Hope it helps,
STICF
Hey Sticf, what knife is that in your avatar?
It looks like a Gerber Harvey Air Ranger except it's not.
 
Can't decide whether to get the black coated blade on the 940 or not...

I like the satin finish. I have handled a few at the local knife shop, The ones with coating seem a bit "stiffer" to flick open. The owner of the shop assures me that they "break in" fine, but I cannot say for sure.

the kid,
I do not want to hi-jack the thread, you can find more info the knife here:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=635247

Hope it helps,
STICF
 
Back
Top