Hi! A simple question to all of you, if you would.. :) thanks for taking the time

Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
1
Hi, I stumbled across this forum once before when talking to a friend who has a set of knives and seems to know a lot about them. I got directed to this forum again by a link to a thread discussing SBL wallets. My question: Why is there such an avid interest in knives? How different can they get? The way I see it, there are two parts; the handle and the blade. Also, a second question; what do 'you' (obviously, not everyone is the same, so if you could answer either from your personal perspective or what you know generally, I'd appreciate either!) do with your knives? I know many people will carry a knife as a weapon for defense, and some teens/early 20's will carry flip knives, because it's cool. I don't believe that most of you fall under either of those categories, but I have never had a use for a knife except while in the kitchen. So, what are some practical real uses for it, when do you take it out of your pocket and use it, and for what?

Thank you :)

Tl'dr version: What do you use your knives for, and why is there a whole forum for the discussion of knives?

Edit: Awesome, replies! Thank you, I will start reading now.. and no, this is certainly not a troll post :)
 
Last edited:
We'll assume this is not a troll post and you are sincere.

Let's get this out there. In the portfolio of weapons available to mankind, a knife is a poor choice. You have to get very, very close to the opponent, you have to be highly trained and skilled to be effective, and if engaged in any kind of combat with a knife, you may or may not win...but you will absolutely be cut to ribbons...even if you win. Hundreds and hundreds of stitches, loss of the use if fingers and hands from cut nerves and tendons. No, unless you are in the most dire straits imaginable for a human being to be in, your not going to choose a knife as weapon. Now sure, you could walk up to some unsuspecting schmuck in a nightclub or a library or something and stab him...and yes in that context the knife would be a weapon...but that is a one-sided attack.

If you have to defend yourself better to have a striking weapon of some sort...a bat, an axe handle, an axe, an entrenching tool or (maybe technically a knife, maybe not) a machete. Of course noting beats a gun for self defense.

So that sort of takes using the knife a weapon out of the mix for most of us. There are many military knife collectors but remember, since the advent of firearms, the edged weapon has taken a back seat to guns.

History. Arguably the knife is man's second oldest tool (after the club). Somebody, club in hand found a shiny rock, smashed it presumably, found shards with sharp edges which were very useful and the knife was born. It would be a very long time before the axe or the bow were invented.

Metal. Metal has fascinated people since its use became common in about 3000BC...copper. Then about 1750BC Bronze.
Iron. Meteoric iron has been used for a long time but smelting became common about maybe 1000BC or a little later.
Steel. Steel was presumably not invented but rather discovered as a state of iron. An alloy of iron. I think that a date for real steel has not been pinpointed but sometime before the time of Christ...let's call it 500BC or so and let's call it India...most common best guess.

Steel is a fascinating subject. There is great skill in making it. There is great skill in heat treating it. There is great skill in fashioning it into a tool. There is a tremendous variety of steel that would take a lifetime to learn. With carbides or without, big carbides or small, and the benefits and trade-off to everything. The knife is arguably the most pure object wrought in steel...no moving parts, geometry is key, balance is key, heat treatment is crucial, alloy is key. Minute variations in any of these tremendously effect the performance of the blade.

History again. Just about every culture has a traditional knife. Japanese culture is obvious. Finland has the Puukko. Nepal has the Khukuri. Texas has the bowie knife...the list just goes on and on.

Accessability. There are so many knifes, made in so many configurations it is just fascinating. Some people focus on one, others are all over the place.

Hobby. A whole hobby world surrounds the knife. Making sheaths. Making knives. Putting handles on existing blades. Sharpening knives is a skill, hobby, and trade unto itself.

Function. I don't know how anybody gets by without one. Every try to get the shrink-wrap off a bottle of Lea and Perrin? Ever try to open a CD jewel box? Wouldn't be much of an issue...if you had a knife. You needn't have a big Spyderco Military for such a thing. My grandfather ran a farm and raised a family on nothing more that a little, probably cheap, pocket knife with two tiny blades. Did everything from peel apples to clean fish and game.

So in short, What's not to like about the subject of knives?
 
Welcome to the forum.

I use my knives for cooking and for camping chores. A question like this though is a pretty general one that can be applied to lots of things. Why do people collect coins? Stamps? Bottle caps? Dolls? (Build) high-end computers? Guns? Music? TV shows? Clothes? Animal heads? People can have odd tics, and if they can satisfy them, they'll do it. Why not? Compared to a lot of other hobbies, knives can be a more reasonable, maybe even more mature, interest--there can be art, skill, and soul behind the forging of a blade, and they're practical.
 
I have EDC'ed a knife since I was 7 years old.

I am now turning 65 and carry 3 at all times,except when in the woods.

Then its about 5,a few fixed blaeds for light cutting and one for the batoning stuff.As well as the pocket ones too.

I prefer larger blades and so I always have a LARGE folder and 2 small blades that dont scare the sheeple.

I carry a 4 blades mini Kissing crane and a SAK

The large blades differ as I have many.
 
My interest come from the convenience of them as tools and I admire good craftsmanship

As far as use is concerned it depends what needs to be done and what I have on me

Most my basic cutting is done with my leatherman but if I have to cut harder material like cables or stiff plastic I'll use a harder steel knife like my BM grip

I've even used my CS spartan to cut a cake in a restaurant.
Very barbaric and crude imo, but is was the only sharp knife available
(Kitchen only had blunt meat knives)

As far as Self defense is concerned there are stories of untrained people using knives to defend themselves but one should never take it for granted

There are so many things that can go wrong

Besides being trained with your knife you,
need to learn where the main arteries and muscles are.
Most NB you need to know you state or countries laws regarding knife carry and usage well.

If untrained, what happens if you lash out in SD, strike an artery and kill the attacker.
The cops come and no favorable witness is nearby.

A good read is "Lies about knife fighting" you can find in google.
I don't like how the guy bashes all the Martial art and combat systems, but there are some very good points on the consequences of knife fighting
(Bleeding, damage ....etc)
 
Why do people collect anything? I'd suspect we all have a little BlueJay or Raccoon in us as we, men and women alike, like cool, shiny things.
I remember collecting the card board tops of glass milk bottles when I was a kid. Same for baseball cards, etc.
My dad collected Emmet Kelley figures. I've seen Hummel figure collections. Etc, etc etc.
It is something that makes us happy.

I like how they are made, the craftsmanship, design, materials, shapes, sizes and purpose built specials.
I use the knife/knives I may carry every day for anything a cutting edge is needed. Or in the case of an SAK...whatever needs doing with the purpose built tool included will take care of.

A difference between my small collection and knife collectors in general...for most of us I think...is we use what we collect and revel in using them rather than just displaying them in a cabinet. And sometimes the more wear the better.
 
Try carrying one, and you will be amazed how often you will use it.

Then the sickness will start to take over...:D
 
One of the things that really interests me about knives, and I had no clue about before starting to research them so I could just get "the best" folding knife and not have to worry about getting another one for 20 years or so is that there are 100's of different types of steel (I thought steel was steel) some will stay sharp many times longer than your average kitchen knife or even high end kitchen knives(S110V,10V, Rex121), there are also steels that absolutely won't rust (H1), even if thrown in ocean water for 6 months, and others that are several times stronger than your average steel (S7).
 
They're useful, not too expensive, don't lose their value very quickly, and have an intrinsic mechanical beauty to them. Think about it this way; you may not need a knife very often, but when you or someone else does, not many people carry them. They aren't too difficult to carry, so why deal with things like bubble packages and boxes with just your fingernails?
 
They're just useful, and fun to collect, talk about, use, customize, buy, sell ect...
 
They're useful, not too expensive, don't lose their value very quickly, and have an intrinsic mechanical beauty to them. Think about it this way; you may not need a knife very often, but when you or someone else does, not many people carry them. They aren't too difficult to carry, so why deal with things like bubble packages and boxes with just your fingernails?

I'd add to that to say it is a better question of "why don't you carry one?"

It is really a recent fad in human history that people have stopped carrying knives.
 
I guess people who don't work for a living don't understand. I use my Knife and my Multitool every single day. I could not do my job without them. Anything from slaughtering animals to cutting bailing twine, to cutting steak dinner to marking galvanized pipe.
I came to blade forums because I had just broken my favorite knife and wanted to find a good price on a better knife. And stayed because of my interest in knives/out doors and the community here.

I have learned as much as I'm going to about knives I think. So I just hang out here for the community really.
 
For me it is because they are cheaper and more useful on a daily basis than guns. I love guns but I could buy a handful of really superb knives for the cost of one nice rifle/pistol.
 
Basic, useful tool. That and I'm just drawn to products that are designed well and function just as good. Carry a couple different sizes for different tasks everyday, from opening letters & packages to random tasks on job sites- cutting up tape, notching wood, opening containers, breaking down the occasional cartons, etc. Then, there is the more fun stuff- for camping and hiking purposes.

How different can they get...you'll get an idea if you look through the various galleries here or even visit an online retailer. There seems to be a knife or two or three out there for anyone.

However, if it's not for you, then it's not for you.
 
The knife is mans oldest tool. I look at my knives as a tool first and a weapon last, I pray God forbids that ever being necessary. I challenge you to purchase a $20 knife and carry it for one week. Its amazing how much handier using a knife is for opening things, versus tearing them open. The reason I find knives so interesting is that contrary to thinking there is only two parts to a knife. There are actually many, many parts to a knife.
Many aspects to knives are; design, heat treat, blade steel, blade grind, variables in options to the blade or handle. There is so much to them.
 
Ask anyone why they carry a watch. Most will tell you it's not to tell time. They have a cell phone that does it. It's kind of an identity thing. Many of us that carry knives do so as an extension of how we express ourselves.

It's also better to have a knife and not need it, than to need a knife and not have it. Carry scissors just makes folks look weird.
 
Knives have an old-world charm, due to the fact that they're one of the oldest tools mankind has. They have a sort of dangerous beauty, akin to that of fire or a big storm.

I personally collect and carry knives because they fascinate me. They have their uses, but most of my knives have overlapping uses - I don't technically need most of mine, but I have them because I can.

And as harkamus so aptly put it, it's an identity thing. I carry a pocket watch and a sheath knife - not because I need to (in reality, a pocket watch can be obnoxious and a sheath gets in the way when you try to sit down in the car) - no, I carry them because they make me stand out a bit from every other schmuck out there. They make me unique. I've had dozens of friends say some variation of "That is so cool" when they see one of the knives I carry.

That, and they're just so dang useful... Especially since I work for a book etailer, and I have to open up and break down hundreds of boxes every day :p
 
I carry a knife because it's a force multiplier, I started carrying a handkerchief as well. I keep a multi-tool in my coat, but with spring being here it's going to go on my belt. If I could I'd carry around more stuff, but I'm not that far gone.

Part of it is that I grew up carrying knives and you just never know when you're going to need to cut something.
 
i work in a professional kitchen. my life revolves around cold, hard steel. if you dont have a good blade then your prep will take longer. if your prep takes longer everyone gets behind...and let me tell you, it is no fun having a 5"2' hispanic yelling at the only gringo on the line. from work i realized how useful knives really are. i carry several everyday. i own a few knives, but some of them own me....they say once a blade has cut you, it owns you. These are my knives. There are many more like them, but these are mine.001.jpg
 
Back
Top