The people who taunt others about what is too heavy and what is not are also the same ones who preach "hike your own hike". I used to carry a SAK with a three inch blade, but after some time discovered the thing was too short for peanut butter jars, some cans and the like. so I went to the four inch. Then after more hiking experience, discovered I never used any of the tools in the knife, and went with a four inch fixed blade, which was not only stronger, but easier to keep clean. yes, it was a little heavier, but for me the trade off was great enough to compensate the difference. I have had people sit and lecture me about saving weight on the trail while using their laptops.
Their are many amusing people out there. So enjoy and hike your own hike. there have been people who have hiked the trail with all kinds of wierd to others things. from umbrellas and plastic flamingos to funerary urns and television sets. It is very trendy now to take almost nothing with you and "yogi" (beg) from others. I basically go with simular gear to when I started hiking years ago, but get lighter stuff as things wear out, or I learn new tricks to the trade. Try some, take some, leave some. Don't have a worry or a care as to what other people say about what you carry. they probably have a teddy bear in a stuff sack they use as a pillow. Keep your feet happy! Having ranted all that, the bark river mini Canadian seems like a solid choice to me! actually, might be a better choice than the swamp rat I carry. See? Once again I am learnin' from the young'uns. At least it gives me a reason to check out some other knives.