The problem is that your knife is actually too sharp. Knife knuts love to obsess over how sharp they can get the knife, with polished edges, and high grits. When I got older and lazy, I started to just shapen with a 600 grit diamond hone or even my old Boy Scout pocket carborunum stone, I found that for general use out in the real world, the courser edge really worked better on plastic wrap, plastic blister packages, rope, twine, and cardboard.
The very fine edge just slides on the plastic, while the course edge acts like mini serations and bites into the material being cut. I also find the 600 grit edge lasts longer. It'll never whittle hair, but it works well on a wide amount of stuff you actually have to cut.