I highly recommend Akivory. I do not have his email adddress handy but a search here on that handle name will produce it. He (Chuck Leake) specializes in what you ask about. I have gotten ivory and other materials from him and am very happy for doing so.
Ancient material will most often have natural cracks, which add to their beauty. Working such material requires different approaches than used on woods and others that are consistant in composition throughout. Ivory, for example, is best ground to thickness from the back side (the side not to be seen). Ancient ivory will also have a bark, as it is called, caused my mineraliztion over the many years setting dormant. It is okay and necessary to work away the profile area of these type handle scales but the face is best left as intact as allowed. The bark is harder and usually more attractive. A try or two working it will instill great confidence. It seems more difficult than actual.
In grinding ivory or any ancient material I recommend not cooling in water. It is best to quench warm ivory on cool steel, aluminium, or other dry heat sinking surface. It is also recommended to grind slowly, more slowly than accustomed. These type materials do not tolerate rapid change well. Just a little more time than usual at the grinder (what ever machine used) will produce good results.
I see you are in Pittsburgh. How about those Steelers!! Let's get the Eagles this Sunday.