Hunting Men

Joined
Dec 20, 1998
Messages
540
I was listening to the radio this morning and there was a soldier recently returned from Operation Anaconda commenting that he had missed hunting season and that he didn`t fill his deer tag but had filled it in other ways.

This led to a conversation between some of my co-workers and myself where the question was asked if hunting men could ruin the hunting of animals for some people.We are of the opinion that it could.

What are your thoughts.
 
The public record on this subject offers great evidence it does for some.

Reasons vary. The one I've heard most often is that many soldiers who participate in war and either directly take human life, or see it taken / destroyed, come away with a greater emphasis on the value of all life.

Killing animals for sport becomes almost profane in many of their minds.

I believe WW2 Medal of Honor winner Audie Murphy, while out hunting upon his return to civilian life, recounted having a flashback of his experiences killing Germans and during the course of the event killed an animal out of sheer instinct when he heard it moving in the woods (thought it was an enemy soldier). When he realized what the war had done to him he broke down and cried right there in the woods. Powerful story.

Others, however, come back to enjoy hunting with no attachment whatsoever to their war experiences. My sense is that the experience is a very personal one, one way or the other.
 
when I returned home after two year's in Vietnam and I had previous combat duty, had to have firearm's around ,but did not go hunting for almost 20 year's . As soon as I was in the field and armed with a rifle I reverted to my old combat mode. My friend's comented on this.The guy I was teamed up with had no combat experiance[ smokeing ,snorting general noise].Split and went solo met up with another combat vet. teamed up.Got 8 pointer opening day
 
my father was a forward artillery observer in the 88th inf in italy in WW2, and while he took me hunting many times, he RARELY did, example, we used to dove hunt around a stock pond, and sure, he took his shotgun, but, while i hunted, he had 2 fishing lines going, and usually caught more catfish than i killed doves lol, and took me deer hunting every year, and could gut/clean a deer faster than any man i have ever seen, but i never saw him kill a deer - he never talked about the war (except funny stuff) to me untill the last 3 or 4 yrs of his life, and he told me that hunting never held the allure it had before, he always wanted me to be able to experience it if i wanted, but he just didnt enjoy it anymore, would hunt if he needed to eat of course, but not for fun/sport anymore- - he told me a lot of stories about the war (bad ones) but only in the last few yrs....when he passed away i wrote the obituary, mentioning he was in WW2, FO, 88th in italy, etc and most of my friends told me they didnt know he had been in the war, this is after countless hunting/camping trips, he was one of those rare father who takes a whole passel of kids out every weekend hunting/fishing, literally, we went almost every weekend , a helluva role model imho

2 days before he passed, he told me not to worry, he'd had one helluva life, and had resigned himself to the fact that he probably wouldnt live thru the war, so all those yrs he had between WW2 and '93 were a bonus, which at one time he never expected to have, and he had tried to live them, every day, to the fullest - made me cry, not him - a few yrs before he died i got all his medals from the Dept of Army ( a helluva feat initself) and an old 88th inf patch, and put it on like a picture frame, w/sgts stripes, artillery badge, all medals, etc and gave it to him for his birthday, almost saw a tear in his eye that day though

he was a helluva man

sifu
 
Back
Top