I dont understand the difference in these three models... please advise

S

Snarlin Stef

Joined
May 2, 2003
Messages
143
well im narrowing down my selection of my next khuk...

My first khuk is a Chiruwa and I want to get another khuk that is totally different from this one (I want to focus on having different model types b4 I get different sizes)... Since I train in martial arts I am thinking that I would like to get a lighter khuk.

I dont quite understand the different utility purposes of these three blades

1: Sirupati
2: Gelbu Special
3: Cobra

It seems that many people on this forumn regard their GS khuk as one of their best knives. But then again the Sirupti is recomended for "martial artists" (and it looks very similar to the GS i think)... The cobra also looks very similar to me and looks like a great blade as well.

I really could use some advice from some of the more experienced folks here on what your opinions are on these knife models.

thnx in advance
Stef
 
I think the Kobras and sirus are a but slimmer in the linnes, but the slightly broader GS weighs in about the same due to the deep fullers on either side of the blade. all have a relatively acute point for thrusts, (not like the AKs, WWIIs and PenKnife, which have broader tips).

These slimmer blades are easy to manipulate and swing. in the 18 inch versions, you won't really feel the weight. In the 20-22 inch range, they weigh out about as much as an 18" Ak or WWII, but still feel much livelier. At least the 21" GS does.

Keith
 
Hello,

Cobra /King Cobra are special models, pure weapon. They are not meant to be used in other way, and I doubt it's covered with Uncle Bill's unlimited warranty because of its thinness.
Added weight means slower move. Sirupati is thicker, heavier than Cobra. It's the lightest khukuri that Uncle Bill warranties as unbreakablility. Gelbu Spcial can be described as a partially thickened Sirupati at the spine, and the line between the blade bevel and the edge bevel. A GS can also be described as a much thicker khukuri with a very big fuller at the center of blade bevel.
For me and not only me, GS seems a very good deal between speed and added toughness.
Hope this helps.
 
Stef, consider the chitlangi along with the other three models. It's similar to the GS but has double fullers. The larger handle pommel also gives it incredible balance.

Once again, there will be variables between the individual blades that make it difficult to categorize each model as different. Once you decide on a model, you may want to ask Uncle Bill to pick the blade for you based on your needs.

My favorites would be a GS or chitlangi by Bura, a kobra by Kumar or a sirupati by Sher.
 
I have a Bura Chitlangi and I would definately take it into consideration for your martial arts use.
 
Here's how I'd rank 'em"
(topmost - better suited to martial arts)

Chitlangi
Kobra
WWII
GS
Sirupati

Just call it personal preference.
 
Here's a visual comparison of a few models in various lengths:

attachment.php


Top to bottom: 21" chitlangi and GS (both ny Durba); 18" GS (Bura) and kobra (Kumar); 15" sirupati (Bura) and balance(Kumar).

As Pen alluded, it will all boil down to personal preference in the end. Of the six shown above, the 15" Bura feels the most weapon-like to my hands.
 
"Of the six shown above, the 15" Bura feels the most weapon-like to my hands."

A pretty little dancer that could leave some bloody footprints if need be.;)

Sarge
 
but they're at opposite ends of the spectrum. The little 12" by Shanker is super light, very portable and much more knife-like. The two 25" by Sher are monstrous. They are what I would use to defend the castle walls from brigands. I would very much like to get a GS or a Kobra. As it stands now my 18" WWII is the blade I reach for when I'm not sure what's coming up next. Now that I've muddied the waters a bit, good luck choosing the next one. Actually they choose you, so I wouldn't worry about it. The right khuk will find its way to your home.

Frank
 
i just hope the right khuk finds my hands b4 i shell out too much $ ;)

ugh... so now i have yet another blade to consider...

if anyone else has any suggestions please post them ...

thnx for the replies so far :)
 
Originally posted by Snarlin Stef
oh yah... whats a "fuller"
Click to expand...

Hi Snarlin Stef,
It's a wide shallow groove that is forged into the blade to lighten it. Often used in swords to provide lateral stiffness. I've heard it likened to the way an I-beam is light, but strong. Referred to erroneously as a "blood groove" on knives.

My Sirpatis and Kobras have no fullers. My Gelbu Special has 1 wide fuller. My Chitlangi has 2 narrow fullers.

Like somebody else said, resistance is futile. Just save up your money, and buy them all, one at a time. None of them will be a mistake, or wasted.:p

Steve

P.S. Raghorn........you rascal. Posting a picture of a horn handled Chitlangi. :( I've always wanted one! It's gorgeous!
 
Congratulations on ONE THOUSAND POSTS !!!!!!!!!!!!!

(and all the help you've provided.)
 
Thank you, sir! :) For what I have given here, I feel that I have received tenfold.
 
I'd say look for a 18" Gelbu Special, as light as you can find. I have a Bura 18" GS that weighs only 17oz. It feels like a plastic ruler in the hand, barely different from just moving your hand. Whereas the only Sirupati I have must be on the heavy side.
 
I have both a 21" chitlangi and a similar sized Gelbu Special, the GS is by far the heavier and less wieldy of the two. Not to say the GS is unwieldy , but the Chitlangi is in a whole other league when moving quickly. I keep lusting after a Kobra model myself to see what one of the really lightweight models is like, but you really can't go wrong with any of those suggested.
 
I have one 20" HI Chainpuri. Think of chainpuri's as a thinner, narrower, much lighter and faster Sirupati. I also have two village chainpuris. One is a 17" 20 ounce pretty good all around working tool. The other is the same 17" length but wheighs 14 ounces. When you pick it up there is no doubting it's sole purpose is to release souls from their bodies.
 
ok this might sound a little bit gory but bare with me... if the blade is too light... it wont be able to chop through clothes and flesh... technically speaking right?

lol im not psycho im just saying that is lighter necessarily better fora weapon? bcs if it is then the kobra should be the best for martial arts use bcs its tte lightest right? and is the kobra so light that its a "weak" blade?

how come i dont see the Chainpuri on the HI pages.
I think i can rule out the sirupati bcs it seems that the kobra chainpuri and kobra are lighter and faster.... also a small GS is still in consideration as well...

decisions decisions... Uncle Bill help a brother out here ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top