I just can bring myself to it

Joined
May 26, 2011
Messages
704
I don't know what I am missing, I just cant bring myself to spend 100+ on a knife. I keep looking at some of the GEC knives, and they look great, but I cant bring myself to drop the money for one.

I think in part it has to do with money but when I get down to it I think its more about the fact that I can spend half the money on a Case knife and have (in my limited opinion) a knife that is just as functional and looks darn good to boot.

Maybe I'm crazy, but this is just my thought. Anybody else understand this?

-Andrew
 
Andrew.

That is not a big deal and nothing to be concerned about. There have been times in my life when I would not want to be spending 30 bucks on a knife.
Enjoy what you are comfortable with. As soon as you stretch expenses to purchase a knife, even if it is a traditional one :D you can pretty much count on that decision not being a good one. To be honest I get more enjoyment from the friends that have come about from what is a hobby to me than the knives.

I am in a position now where I am able to buy a nice knife now and then, but some of my favorites still are ones given to me by my dad and friends. When it is time to think about more expensive knives, you will know it and even if that time never arrives you are only missing out on a thing. Trust me the people in your life and your future are more important.
 
Andrew, I do understand - as finances have forced this hand on me. However, many GEC or S&M are patterns unavailable at lower price points. Also, they are more robust as a general rule: sometimes that's good, other times it's a liability.
Best,
Steve
 
I'm the same way. Actually, I can hardly bring myself to buy any knives at all. For the past year I've been carrying the same knife, and I just feel content with what I have. I have a collection of 20 or so knives, and just don't feel like I need any more. When I do buy a knife here or there, it's only $30-$40. It's nothing to be concerned about, just do what works for you. There are a couple of knives that I'd like to own like AG Russell's new barlow or a Case yellow large stockman, but I don't see any use in buying them. I have plenty of knives.
 
Perhaps look for an older knife at garage sales, antique fairs, etc. One can still find some gems for relatively little money.
 
Gus,
I really enjoyed your answer. I read it twice for the pure pleasure of it. :)

Andrew,
I do understand you. My most carried knife is an Opinel that satisfies my needs. I decided to limit drastically the number of knives I have, and I'm fine with that.
No one can tell you what you need to be happy (and that's not just about knives). Most people in the world that really use knives daily only own one, until it fails or breaks or gets lost...so why should you feel bad for owning a nice Case (or any other brand) that you like and that works for you? The old questions about "is the X knife worth X usd?" or "is the extra X usd justified by the better quality of the knife?" make no sense, cause we all measure with our own meter.
We share a passion...but not all of us live it in the same way. Some of us are collectors, some are accumulators, some are plain users, some like to have knives, some like to know about knives, or long for them. As long as you feel fine, why should you worry? At the same time, if someone is willing to spend 10K a year on knives, and is happy with that, he should do it regardless of what others think. And if someone is fine for 10 years on a carbon Opinel, why should he spend more?
To make a comparison...I've spent more money on air tickets and travelling in the last 10 years than what most people would consider outrageous in a lifetime or two. But you know what? I don't care. I go around with a nice knife in my pocket, and collect visa stamps :D
So enjoy your knives, no matter how many, how espensive, how fancy, how needed they are. And share your thoughts with us, of course. That's why we're here.

Fausto
:cool:
 
Andrew, nothing wrong with how you feel. I will say is that many/most GECs are under $100 and can go as low as the upper 50s. Occasionally, great deals pop up in the Exchange so keep an eye out there. Maybe it would be best if you handled one at a show to see how you like them. Not everyone does and that's ok.
 
Andrew.

That is not a big deal and nothing to be concerned about. There have been times in my life when I would not want to be spending 30 bucks on a knife.
Enjoy what you are comfortable with. As soon as you stretch expenses to purchase a knife, even if it is a traditional one :D you can pretty much count on that decision not being a good one. To be honest I get more enjoyment from the friends that have come about from what is a hobby to me than the knives.

I am in a position now where I am able to buy a nice knife now and then, but some of my favorites still are ones given to me by my dad and friends. When it is time to think about more expensive knives, you will know it and even if that time never arrives you are only missing out on a thing. Trust me the people in your life and your future are more important.

This is perhaps the most eloquent explanation I've ever heard, and put so beautifully.

It's true, the people in your life are so much more precious than things. I had a nice collection of Randall's, Ralph Bone, Don Hastings, and other custom knife makers of the 60's. When I was young and single I had great disposable income. Then I met this cute little gal on a pistol range. Over the next few years I learned about everything in life I didn't know. This tiny little person arrived, then another, and a third one after that. My knife collection days came to an end, and I wrapped up my knives and stored them away. I stored them because they had for a while actually lost my interest. My time and income went to raising these little people, and it was a fascinating trip. My family became my entire world, and reason for being. When the time came, I introduced my kids to camping, and hiking, and the outdoors. When they were old enough, I unwrapped the collection and they handled them, and it was fun to see who reacted to which ones. Only one child took to knives in the same way I had been. The others were 'meh'. My oldest boy turned out to be a SAK fan, and my daughter is a borderline SAK person.

When I did my great downsize, I gave them all a chance to have anything they wanted. They told me to go and sell the custom collection and take a second honeymoon trip with Karen. So I sold off all the expensive customs I had collected before I had met Karen, and I didn't miss any of them. They had long ceased to have any importance to me, because my wife and kids had far surpassed my interest in knives. Or guns. The knives that did have special meaning to me was the run of the mill knives of moderate cost I had accumulated as a family man. When my grown daughter Jessica saw the yellow sodbuster I used to carry, she got misty eyed over the memory of the two of us sitting in the woods on a camping trip, and I making peanut butter and jelly sandwiches while sung the 'banana knife' as she called it when she was a little girl. I gave it to her. My youngest son, Matt, was not interested at all in the custom fixed blades, but cherishes the boy scout knife I gave him when he joined the scouts.

So there you have it, some of the best knives you have may well be the moderate to low priced ones because of the memories you build into it with your family. Your kids may never appreciate the GEC that you collect and never use, but that Case jackknife that you make them the perfect hot dog stick with will become a family treasure. Don't feel like you have to have an expensive knife, after all, the knife will become what you make of it with the people that really matter in your life.

Carl.
 
Good advice all around, thanks. For now I am happy with my case knives, I still look and toss around the idea of a new one from time to time, but for now I am happy. I am still a fairly young individual (22) and I (the good Lord willing) have many years ahead of me. I think Carl hit it on the head with his description of meeting his wife though. I was married at 19 (our third anniversary is in October). I think that shortly after becoming more of a knife nut I discovered something more important. Now, we had a little disposable income and I still gained a few knives here and there, but we are talking about kids now and I realize two things. 1. My knife money is going to disappear when it comes time to take care of my future son or daughter. and 2. I absolutely don't care because I want to start building my family.

Thanks again for the advice guy, I think I post on hear knowing some of these answers, but I just like to either share or hear the advice of others.
 
Last edited:
Nothing wrong with that.

I have found, as I have collected, that my "Woah" price has just gone up and up.

The first time you use a 1000k knife, the cut off price of "woah" goes up.


But, it does not matter, because I still "covet" cheaper knives. I see a $30 slip joint and think "ooh, I need that one!"

This happens constantly!
 
Last edited:
Hmmm i dont know that I will ever have a woah price any where near 1000 dollars but I do understand what you mean. I used to think it was crazy to spend more than 20 bucks on a knife let alone one of those "old fashion"(traditional) things. However anymore Ill gladly play closer to 50 and always for an old "fashion knife".
 
Carl,
I don't mean to hijack Andrew's thread, but your definition of your daughter as a "borderline SAK person" almost got me choke :D
Andrew,
I will share with you something that I may be doing shortly. I can't see myself spending a big part of my money on knives, but I've come to think that I might just decide to put away the spare change and build a small fund. Like, everytime I get home with a 1 Euro coin, I put it in a tin box until I have enough to buy that certain knife (custom or production) that I like but costs too much for me (at that particular time). No matter how long it takes...it would feel like getting it for free (I know it's not, but human mind is weird on perception).

Fausto
:cool:
 
This seems like a good idea, perhaps I will start up again and see how it goes. In the past it seems to always slipped away into gas money or the like but I cant build if I don't start.
 
Great thread, guys!
I have been all over the place with folders and the folder I'm carrying now is a Case Sodbuster. I carried one as a boy and it never failed me. I just love it and I only paid $30. dollars!
 
Carl,
I don't mean to hijack Andrew's thread, but your definition of your daughter as a "borderline SAK person" almost got me choke :D
Andrew,
I will share with you something that I may be doing shortly. I can't see myself spending a big part of my money on knives, but I've come to think that I might just decide to put away the spare change and build a small fund. Like, everytime I get home with a 1 Euro coin, I put it in a tin box until I have enough to buy that certain knife (custom or production) that I like but costs too much for me (at that particular time). No matter how long it takes...it would feel like getting it for free (I know it's not, but human mind is weird on perception).

Fausto
:cool:

Sorry Fausto, I didn't mean it in a bad way. Jessica is like Karen in that to her mind a pocketknife, or in her case, purse knife, should have at least a scissors and nail file, and any other little tools that come in handy. And as long as she has a sak, she doesn't see the need for a knife-knife that is just a cutting tool except for hiking or camping trips. But she did latch onto the banana knife for sentimental reasons.

Carl.
 
There's plenty of high quality knives out there without hitting $100. Check out some of AG Russells folders or Queen.... good stuff. Nothing wrong with Case either.

When I was 22 , I was content with ordering a few closeout knives from the Smoky Mountain KW Catalogue. I don't think I ever spent more than $30 - $35 and I got some good deals. I was just looking at a Camilus Yellow Jacket knife I bought out of a SMKW catalog in the early 80's , paid about $15 for it and it's still a heck of a knife.
 
Carl,
I don't mean to hijack Andrew's thread, but your definition of your daughter as a "borderline SAK person" almost got me choke :D
Andrew,
I will share with you something that I may be doing shortly. I can't see myself spending a big part of my money on knives, but I've come to think that I might just decide to put away the spare change and build a small fund. Like, everytime I get home with a 1 Euro coin, I put it in a tin box until I have enough to buy that certain knife (custom or production) that I like but costs too much for me (at that particular time). No matter how long it takes...it would feel like getting it for free (I know it's not, but human mind is weird on perception).

Fausto
:cool:

This is exactly what I do. Not for all of my knife money, just as a savings account for knives, so to speak. I almost never use loose change. If something costs 75 cents I will use bills to pay for it even though I might have the change in my pocket. If it's $3.01 I pay with a five or ten dollar bill and the loose coins all go in a jar at home at the end of each day.

It's a pretty good size jar and it takes me about 10 months to fill it up but it's worth it. Like Fausto said, it's like getting a few free knives. Or even just one expensive one.

It's a good way to save a little money even if you don't use it for knives.
 
This is exactly what I do. Not for all of my knife money, just as a savings account for knives, so to speak. I almost never use loose change. If something costs 75 cents I will use bills to pay for it even though I might have the change in my pocket. If it's $3.01 I pay with a five or ten dollar bill and the loose coins all go in a jar at home at the end of each day.

It's a pretty good size jar and it takes me about 10 months to fill it up but it's worth it. Like Fausto said, it's like getting a few free knives. Or even just one expensive one.

It's a good way to save a little money even if you don't use it for knives.

That's exactly what I do too, Rick. Works great, ya never miss the money, and pretty soon you've got a nice lil' fund going! :thumbup:
 
There are lots of GEC's out there under 100 bucks, both brand new from dealers, and in the Exchange.

Some members would like a custom Tony Bose, I know I would, but I can't afford it. I'm not going to get one just because another member has one. I can swing for a Case collaboration, so that's what I get. If I couldn't, I would probably still try, but that's just me.

Lots of nice old slipjoints out there in junk malls too. Junk malls, antique stores, flea markets etc. Some need a little TLC, and you can learn a lot doing that too.
 
Back
Top