I like the lockback.

[fulloflead]

Some Spydercos turn me on more than others and for a while I couldn't figure out what it was, but I think I've figured it out. I like the Spyderco Lockbacks!

I'm usually not a fan of lockbacks, so maybe it's because Spyderco does the lockback really well. I'm sure it also has to do with the opening method. I've always believed that while linerlocks and framelocks were OK with a thumbstud, that when you have the spring resistance of a lockback you really need a hole in the blade for good constant purchase during the entire opening stroke like you do with a Spyderco or SOG Autoclip. The Cold Steel Voyager series always seemed awkward with the thumbstud/lockback combination.

Not that the linerlock/framelock go BADLY with the Spidiehole - that's fine, but the hole-opener combined with the satisfying "click" of the lockback really rings my bell.

I like the Boye Detent and I feel pretty secure with the lock, but there's actually a test I've always wondered about. Suppose you wrapped something around the Boye Detent to hold it in about 1/3rd to 1/2 the way toward unlocking it and then tested the lock in that state? This would simulate what kind of behavior you could expect from the lock should your grip push the lock release in a little. I'd really be interested in knowing about that.

Anyone ever hear about one of these closing on somebody's hand during use?

 

[Ming65]

I said this over on Wilderness forums but it bears repeating here. After enjoying my new (now not so new) Manix for the last few weeks I was wondering what we all would be saying if the Liner/Frame lock had been invented first, followed by the lock back? - We'd all be raving about this amazing new design that is solid and holds the blade sercure when closed etc etc, how it solved so many problems.

Cliff has just done a test on the Chinook over in reviews and testing which shows how strong the lock can be.

 

[Roger Blake]

Me three for the linerlock. It is simplicity itself and has stood the test of time. It meets my needs.

 

[Garlic]

i've favored the lockback since my 1st buck 110 given to me by dear old dad a million years ago. i'd trust it over any other lock in a hard-use situation, including the axis lock.

 

[Machaira]

I also prefer the lockback over the liner lock. I have come to like finger choils too. For me the Calypso, Jr. and the Manix are two great designs.

 

[Clint Simpson]

I prefer lockback too. A bit more metal and I little more lock up without getting in the way as would happen in a liner the same size.

Also I find lockback more reliable when the knife is stressed laterally. Yes, I know one should not stress a knife side to side but it does happen. I fact, I have used lockbacks as temperary handles. You can't do that with a linerlock (framelock seems to work too)

BTW, Most of my lockbacks open just as slick as the linerlocks I've handled (There are exceptions.) And they close just as easy but with an extra step.