I need a few recommendations....

Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Messages
6
Good morning, everyone. I would like some recommendations, but please be patient with me; not only am I new to this forum, but I am new to knives and the like.

One of the reasons I like my SAK so much is because it has multiple tools, two blades, and is small enough to fit in pocket. However, I recently discovered something I was not aware of; it uses a softer steel alloy. That is kinda discouraging as I am the type of person who wants the best quality of any tool, but it must have multiple uses (personal preference). So, if a SAK is not the best EDC pocket knife, I respectfully ask your opinion for a recommendation.

I am very much into big-game hunting and camping. Therefore, there are a total of four knives (that I know of) that I would like to keep in my collection. Of course, you already know about the EDC pocket knife. Another knife I'd like to keep on me or in my pack is something similar to the Buck 110. My father and I have always used Buck 110 for all our big-game hunts. I think it's a good knife for gutting, skinning, and cutting meat. It would probably be used for other tasks that I'm not aware of. If you believe there is something better than Buck for this kind of work, please let me know.

The third knife of this imaginary collection would be something similar to a Schrade Extreme Survival knife. I want a heavy-duty knife like that, but with a hollow handle and full tang. The handle would be used to store things like a small survival kit, or tools, or whatever else may be necessary. I read somewhere that a large stick or something can be shoved into the handle to make a spear. I'm not very supportive of that idea as it doesn't sound too safe! If there is a better knife out there that can be carried on hunting and camping trips, and that is capable of doing some heavy work, please let me know.

The last of my knives that I'd like to add to my collection is a simple bush-clearing tool, like a machete. I've always thought any simple machete would do for clearing brush, twigs, and small branches. However, my limited experience may prove me wrong.

I thank everyone for your time, and look forward to responses.

Dave
 
Hello and welcome!
I've been lurking here forever, lots of great people on here.
It seems you want a EDC blade, a hunting knife, survival type knife and a machete?

For a EDC, I would recommend the Spyderco Delica or Endura. They can be found for around $60.
Another good company is Benchmade. Check out the Mini Griptillian and the Griptillian. They can be found for $80.
Those options would replace the SAK and the 110 easily.

For a heavy use "Survival" type blade, an ESEE Laser Strike would fit the bill for full tang and hollow handles. It's a very nice blade made in America with a lifetime warranty and it can be had for around $100. It's miles ahead of the Schrade.

A nice machete could be found for around $20. Check out Imcasa.

Good luck.
 
You're doing a pretty good job already, there aren't many pocket knives that can match the usefulness of a SAK, many people on the forum carry a small SAK along with their primary EDC blade. The Buck 110 is also a pretty good hunting knife, and if you don't do anything stupid with it like prying or batoning, it should out last you, and even if it doesn't, Buck offers a lifetime warranty. I don't have much knowledge when it comes to survival knives or machetes so I'll let someone else give their input.
 
I think you could condense it down to 3. Numbers 3 and 4 could probably be combined and a happy medium could be meant. The buck 110 sounds good to keep. The member above me made some great recommendations such as the Delica and endure or even the Griptillian.
 
Hello and welcome!
I've been lurking here forever, lots of great people on here.
It seems you want a EDC blade, a hunting knife, survival type knife and a machete?

For a EDC, I would recommend the Spyderco Delica or Endura. They can be found for around $60.
Another good company is Benchmade. Check out the Mini Griptillian and the Griptillian. They can be found for $80.
Those options would replace the SAK and the 110 easily.

For a heavy use "Survival" type blade, an ESEE Laser Strike would fit the bill for full tang and hollow handles. It's a very nice blade made in America with a lifetime warranty and it can be had for around $100. It's miles ahead of the Schrade.

A nice machete could be found for around $20. Check out Imcasa.

Good luck.

You're doing a pretty good job already, there aren't many pocket knives that can match the usefulness of a SAK, many people on the forum carry a small SAK along with their primary EDC blade. The Buck 110 is also a pretty good hunting knife, and if you don't do anything stupid with it like prying or batoning, it should out last you, and even if it doesn't, Buck offers a lifetime warranty. I don't have much knowledge when it comes to survival knives or machetes so I'll let someone else give their input.

Thank y'all so much for the responses! I just googled that ESEE Laser Strike. Wow! That thing really got my attention!
 

I meant one piece. I want a fix knife, but with a hollow handle so that stuff can be stored inside handle. However, I know that sometimes those hollow handle knives are of very poor quality. I wanted one that, the blade and handle is one solid piece. Schrade Extreme Survival is the best example I can think of, but I know nothing of Schrade's quality.
 
The only thing I'd want stored inside a hollow handle is a spear shaft, but that's just me.
 
For #3 I recommend a BK 7 or 9 with an Altoid tin and pouch attached to the sheath

For #4 I recommend looking at the Condor line of machetes.

Good luck brotha....
 
Avoid hollow handled "survival" knives at all costs. They are weak handled - obviously - and any I have seen are Rambo wannabee mall ninja junk. Far better to get a knife with a full tang and solid construction.

As for machetes, I would suggest you look at Condor Knife & Tool.

Good luck.
 
I'd replace the buck 110 with something with better steel like the ZT550 or 560, the esee light machete has about the most comfortable handle on one I've ever used. For a hollow handle knife, not all are junk some of the customs are very well made and tough. The shrade is ok but made of poor steel its a straight knock off of the CR with cheap steel. The Chris Reeve models are great and good steel and many of the custom makers do a fine job too.

1904261_10203796858748379_203126281_n.jpg

These aren't going to break, I've used a couple of them hard. S35vn steel, great heat treat.
 
Last edited:
They are customs from Martin knives of texas, very well built and very tough.

The large one is the surv9 in s35vn 9inch blade, the middle is the mce2 s35vn 7inch blade and the last is the apparo 7inch blade

1509040_10203790795756808_408236573_n.jpg


1689240_10203642388206712_259139478_n.jpg
 
Last edited:
SAK's are good knives I don't think anyone will argue that. Just because it's a soft steel doesn't mean it's bad, a lot of traditional slip joints would probably fall under this category. In fact it's one of it's strong suits with how easy it is to sharpen it takes very little effort so even a small pocket stone can bring the blade back to life in a short amount of time. A small strip of sandpaper in the wallet will keep it quite happy and sharp if you don't have a stone handy too.

If you want a more modern steel you can go the exact opposite and pick up something like a Spyderco in ZDP-189, just know you better have diamond stones or silicon carbide and have your sharpening technique down as it may take awhile to sharpen with how wear resistant it is.

If you like the dual blades of a SAK but want a more wear resistant steel you can look at Queen knives they have D2 in a lot of their knives. Off hand the one that is most like a SAK would be the Canoe but their main blade of their Canoe is quite thick and Queen is known for having obtuse angles on their blades so you may have to reprofile them when you get it. A few other traditional slip joint manufacturers make knives in more wear resistant steels but for the life of me I can't remember right now.

Buck 110 is a good knife but if you want a modern steel again you can pick up a Buck 110 in S30V which I hear good things about.

Though if you want you may be able to supplement your hunting knife with your EDC knife. Something like a Stockman and Copperhead pattern knife comes to mind. Stockmans are generally 3 blade knives that come in various sizes and are quite popular. Copperheads aren't as popular but are generally 2 blade knives but single blade variants do exist.
 
I'll chime in.....

I am more "bang for the buck" than most.
The Buck 110 is a keeper, but if you want too get a new knife maybe a RAT 1 or Byrd.

For a big bruiser- take a look at the Ontario RD series. The RD4 is a beast.

I have owned the Schrade SCHF3 (I think) and it was okay. For a few more $$ you can get an Ontario or Becker and a nice warranty
 
Back
Top