I seem to be down to three

Joined
May 26, 2011
Messages
630
On my quest to be a "one knife guy" like my grandfather, who carried the same knife for over 70 years (not a typo...one knife for 70 years) I seem to be closing in on the goal. These three knives have been getting all of my pocket time of late. When wearing cargo shorts or a jacket, they get paired with an Opinel 8, but they do just fine on their own.

DSCN2966.JPG


Mini-Copperhead in Deep Canyon Bone, Medium Jack in slick black, and CV Peanut in Chestnut Bone.

It's going to be really hard to eliminate two of these to get to the one knife phase...

DSCN2967.JPG


The MCH--I love the wharncliffe blade. It may just be my favorite blade shape. For all the tasks I use a pocket knife for, it works the best and is easy to sharpen and strop. The MCH is the perfect handle length for me as well. I wish Case would make a three inch peanut. That little extra bit of handle makes all the difference in the hand, but very little difference in the pocket. I also like the deep canyon jigging. It gives a fantastic grip and the fact there is no shield glued on makes it even better, in my opinion.
An almost perfect pocket knife.

DSCN2969.JPG


The slick black medium jack is the largest of these small knives. Unlike the others, I do notice when this one is in my pocket, but not in an uncomfortable way. More in a reassuring way. Summer means cargo shorts, and I am always worried my small knives have fallen out of my pockets. This one I know is there, and the stainless as-ground blades make it ideal for hot summer days. I wish case made more knives with the slick black delrin. I never warmed up to "yeller" knives. I understand their usefulness if you drop it in the woods, but black reminds me of Grandpa's knife.

DSCN2968.JPG


I don't need to say anything about the Peanut. A forum search will give a plethora of peanut posts. I have a feeling that, in the end, it's going to be between this little guy and the MCH. I need to weigh my love of CV steel with the way the MCH just fits my hand so perfectly. And the wharnie. That might tip the scales, too...

And, in closing--the knife that got carried every day for 70 years.

DSCN2813.JPG


Thanks for reading. I feel privileged to have such problems as choosing between so many fantastic knives.

Andrew
 
Great post!

I don't have a medium jack, but have seen one in person and there's something about its straightforward simplicity that really appeals. It's longer than 3", yes?

How about, a 3" serpentine jack with a wharncliffe main? ;)

Good luck on your quest. I admire your goal, but for me-- among many other temptations-- the mini wharncliffe copperheads are just too sexy to leave unpocketed for long.... Would that Case would produce one in CV (in something other than yellar-- just occurred to me to make sure my wish was formatted correctly!).

~ P.
 
I regressed, I was a one knife guy for years, when I was younger and traveled a lot throughout the US and Europe it was my old Vic farmer with red alox from the 80's ( I lost it :-( ) or my Vic Rucksack. Now for some reason I'm a three knife guy?
 
Noble goal.

But like P, I don't think I could attain such lofty heights of simplicity. It has been hard enough trying to stick to a stockman all month. I finally broke down and put the Case pen in my pocket along with the small stockman today, but the peanut and mini copperhead are now feeling neglected. Not to mention I almost bought one of those black 22087s last night. Too many choices!

I commend you for your discipline.
 
Pertinux--

The medium jack is 3 and 3/8ths inches. I highly recommend this knife. Fit and finish is excellent. No gaps. Excellent grinds. Feels very solid in the hand. It's a jackknife. A good old fashioned no frills working jackknife. It's the knife that kicked my White Owl out of my pocket. And as I can't get that knife to cut paper without tearing it to shreds, it may keep it out for good.
 
Andrew,
It's very interesting to see yet another knife with many years on it have the main clip blade in great condition while the secondary pen blade shows substantial use. It seems as though many of the "old-timers" preferred their secondary blades over the larger main blade for their daily tasks.
In relation to your post, I was a one knife man for roughly 30 years. I've always had several knives but somehow stuck faithfully with my favorite (a buck 503 for the past 10+ years that looks like it's been chewed up by a badger). Lately my interest in knives has been reignited and I am on a path directly opposite of your quest to be a one-knife-man.
Matt
 
No limits here, I just went through my spreadsheet of knives and counted 26 different pocket knives I carry with some regularity (at least a half dozen times a year). Fifteen of these get the bulk of the duty. My real regulars are 4 two-blade jacks, 5 locking single blades and 6 stockmen.

From left: Tidioute jack, Bulldog trapper, Northfield harness jack and Tidioute big jack
EDCjacks.jpg


From left: Silver Knight, Northfield LL and lockback, Queen LL and Kershaw lockback
EDClockers.jpg


From left: Calf Roper, RR stockman and sowbelly stockman, MM stockman, Queen stockman and Tidioute Cuban
EDCstockmen.jpg
 
Hi Andrew!

It seems, you found your rotation! Must be glad to know what you carry ... just 33.33 % of chance taking the right knife for the day. Not that 5 % some of us have to chose ;)

I tend to carry my EDC for some months (even years) always in rotation with many others.

Actually it´s the #66 Serpentine Jack and a Case Peanut, which hardly leaves my pocket. A Stockman (Case or Buck) is also often in the rotation... :)

Kind regards
Andi
 
Pertinux--

The medium jack is 3 and 3/8ths inches. I highly recommend this knife. Fit and finish is excellent. No gaps. Excellent grinds. Feels very solid in the hand. It's a jackknife. A good old fashioned no frills working jackknife. It's the knife that kicked my White Owl out of my pocket. And as I can't get that knife to cut paper without tearing it to shreds, it may keep it out for good.

No arguments on the medium jack, it is a fine design and you have a very nice one there. I've always thought Case jacks are proportioned and styled almost perfectly.

Sorry to hear about your White Owl though. My ebony/clip owl has become my new EDC and takes a wonderful edge. After handling it one of my friends said just looking at it cut his finger, lol. Is it just too soft to shed the burr or is it just not producing a burr at all? Might have a screwed up heat treat or something... a rare thing to hear that their 1095 won't cut well, that's a real drag.

Will
 
DrPenguin--

I have the same ebony clip white owl. I love the design of this knife but mine arrived in the dullest state of any knife I have ever bought. My sharpening skills are novice and I use a sharpmaker. I am uncertain if the problem is the heat treatment. I tend to think it was just a poorly done edge. Sharpie test on the sharpmaker shows I am hitting the edge, but it won't get sharp. It's sitting in a drawer while I make up my mind whether or not to send it back to GEC.

Thinking about that knife frustrates me.
 
I know that I will most likely never get to be a one knife man like my dad was. The closest thing I've got to it is the three or four I have in rotation now. My peanut and Victorinox classic are my every day in and day out carry. They do 95% of my cutting. When I carry something else, it's to agent the peanut, like an Opinel for the longer blade to deal with food. I do this especially when I go over my sister in laws. I love my SIL, but she won't have a sharp knife in her kitchen, so when I know I have some cooking to do, I take an Opinel with me to slice and dice.

Carl.
 
Sorry to hear that SubSpace. I can't honestly tell you what kind of edge my owl came with as it only lasted as long as it took me to get it out of the tube and onto the table where I put a new edge on it. :)

I hope you can figure out the problem and get it sharpened up buddy. I hate to see a guy put down good money for a knife that won't cut, that's bad jojo.

Will
 
I'm kind of down to two,Case Damascus Peanut,and my Chestnut bone and CV bladed Swayback Jack.I love both of those knives and can't seem to pick a favorite.The Swaback is getting a good patina fram cutting steak and jalapenos.You gotta love that CV steel!:thumbup:
 
I can't understand how anyone who loves traditional slipjoints can only be a one-knife person. Honestly, the only thing that would make any sense is that a one-knife person may like knives, but do they really feel a warm glow down deep inside for carrying and using a knife like we do??? My guess is that they don't. IDK, maybe I am wrong about this. What would be wrong with saying, "I'm a one-knife guy. I have one Vic, one Case, one custom, etc. etc." :-) Personally, I just can't see myself ever getting to the point that I would have and carry just one knife, no matter what kind it was. You could give me a Loveless or the finest Buster Warenski ever made and I would still have just as much love and desire to carry my peanut, or that GEC that has a lot of patina on it, or even that old Robeson that has a bent liner in it, but which has character and a blade with a ton of life left in it that just keeps cutting. And that doesn't make me better or worse than a one-knife person or even a no-knife person; just different.
 
Chris, that's just how I see it. Once I got beyond the fear factor of carrying an expensive folder, I've wanted to carry and use more and more different knives to see what each one has to offer. I have found enjoyment in knives from $10 to $500, and from 3-1/4" to 5". I've tried dozens of different steels, handle materials, frame patterns and blade configurations-- the fun part is experiencing the differences through use, not just by eyeing them or fondling them. I'm to the point now that, except for patterns I collect and get multiple different handle materials, I carry almost every new knife I get for at least a couple days to check it out. Of course I have favorites, but I could NEVER do with only a dozen, much less three or one.
 
Pertinux--

The medium jack is 3 and 3/8ths inches. I highly recommend this knife.

Right, because the best way to simplify one's knife carry choices is to ADD ONE MORE-- THE NEXT ONE COULD BE IT !

Ahem, where was I?

Fit and finish is excellent. No gaps. Excellent grinds. Feels very solid in the hand. It's a jackknife. A good old fashioned no frills working jackknife.

I love the straightforward design of this one, which evokes exactly the descriptive you offer above, even from afar. This is promising!

Unfortunately, the only one I've been able to see in person so far (which I vaguely remembered as more than 3", but wasn't sure) had a clip blade that didn't seem to open all the way. Or, didn't look opened all the way even when it was. It wasn't jammed, but maybe simply had a slightly miscut blade-end? A stag medium jack had a similar slant to its opened main blade, but not to the same degree. Is this typical of this pattern?

It's the knife that kicked my White Owl out of my pocket.

Hey, now.

;)

~ P.
 
The one knife quest is just that--a quest. A goal. A zen/Jeff Bridges as the Dude kind of journey. I have no doubt I'm not through buying knives. Trying different brands. Different patterns. It's just that for me, these trials have a purpose. To find "the one."

Right now, at this point in time, the three mentioned above are closest to it.

It may just be how I justify buying more knives. A form of self delusion. "This one may be THE ONE that stops the madness."

However, the peanut has been in my pocket more often than not since December 2010.

I just got the MCH in May. But it might go just as long...

I realize that, as I am now 38, there will never be a knife I've carried for 70 years.

But I could possibly carry one for 40 or 50...

It's the romantic in me, I suppose.
 
Don't get me wrong, I love the idea. I'm also fortunate to have more than one knife.

(I was going to add, "...that I really love," but I wonder how much we've romanticized previous generations' lack of choice and/or discretionary funds?)

Still, I like to keep things simple, and love the idea of one knife (or a few) being with me through all the whatever-comes-next, better yet if they're higher in carbon content and can reflect our time together.

I also hear you on the age thing. I've seldom felt older than when I got the best guitar I'll ever have, at 40, and regretted not having years 20-40 with it as well!

For me personally, it's far more realistic to accept that I'm currently at "White Owl and ________" than a single-knife carrier, with that second spot open for some choice every day. But I certainly understand (and envy) the goal. Not that I'm not enjoying right now very much!

Beyond that, I want to to try to add only CV, or mediterranean blue, or another right GEC, or....

Where was I?

Case's black medium jack has beckoned to me since I first saw it. I'm just not sure where it fits, if I want to stay within the above.

For now. ;)

~ P.
 
But I could possibly carry one for 40 or 50...

It's the romantic in me, I suppose.

When you get right down to it, isn't that the thing for a lot of us?

The romantic image of a gray haired old man with a well worn and weathered old shotgun and an equally aged barlow in his pocket? Or a fondly remembered uncle or grandfather who seemed to be so complete, and do so much with so very little, including an old well worn pocket knife that he'd carried since "the war."

It's the draw of the one gun man. The man who doesn't need a lot because he's so darn good with what he has. Like the Duke with his ivory handle Colt. He didn't need a two gun rig, or other guns stuck in his belt. One was good enough for the Duke.

Most of us will never see the end of our quest. But we'll have a lot of fun along the way trying all those knives to see if one of them is "the one!"

Maybe that's all there is to it, pilgrim.

Carl.
 
Back
Top