Icy snow covered roads = Dangerous travel

Status
Not open for further replies.

Gary W. Graley

“Imagination is more important than knowledge"
Knifemaker / Craftsman / Service Provider
Joined
Mar 2, 1999
Messages
27,445
Well, I've been driving now for well over 50 years now and yesterday I found out what icy road covered by 2" of freshly fallen snow is like. Down in south Williamsport PA there is a McDonalds on rte 15 near the Little League Baseball. It was snowing pretty hard but didn't look like much of any thing to worry about. I had a quick breakfast at McDonalds and to exit that McDonalds you go around and up a small hill to a road that takes you back to rte 15. Well, that small road is also on a hill going down to the highway and had not had any traffic on it since the snow started falling. I pulled onto it and applied my brakes very early before I was anywhere near the highway and with the motion of the car, a Subaru Forester, the car just started sliding down the hill, I tried to brake harder and NOTHING was happening! I was headed straight onto two lanes of traffic !!! As I swung onto the road I saw cars swerving horns blaring and very nearly needed some fresh underwear myself as one large SUV was coming right at me and I saw no way that it wasn't running right into my drivers door!
But at the very last second, we missed each other, a miracle if ever I had witnessed one. Got under control again and the highway surface was such that I was able to get moving up the hill. Still snowing hard out and the rest of my drive south I was SUPER cautious but once you hit ice, there isn't much that you can do and on the rest of the trip there were 4 cars, trucks that had spun off the road and were being pulled out of the ditches, it was a very bad morning for a lot of folks!

As I was driving on, I am pretty sure the person that just missed me was still behind me and at one red light I saw her holding up her phone and pointing it at the back of my car, no doubt getting a photo of the license plate of the idiot that just blatantly pulled into traffic without any care about other people. If I could have been able to stop and talk with her I would have thanked her profusely for saving both of our lives as it was super close!

SO, yeah icy road, fresh snow, bad combination! I only ever remember driving on black ice in Houston early morning flight home, pulled out of the hotel driveway onto the road and I was doing donuts down the road! fortunately it was very early and I was alone at the time, that too was scary as you don't have any clue it was that slippery.

My car is a 2022 with less than 2k miles so the tires were pretty close to new, not heavy snow tires but all year round type but on ice, I don't know of anything other than studded tires that might have made a difference.

G2
 
1717faf8f1dca11280521608cc073c7a.jpeg
 
That's sounds pretty scary. We usually have winter only tires on another set of wheels for Halloween thru Spring Break here in CO. They do much better on ice than all seasons, but studded are even better. We typically don't do studded since 1993. This year my wife is on brand new Michelin Cross Climate 2 3-peak tires with her Subaru Ascent, and they're doing well in the winter snows.

Even though she has some Yokahama Ice Guard on some 18" wheels sitting in the garage, she says at 5/32 tread they are not as good as the brand new all seasons. I however AM on my Yokahama Ice Guard with the Forester XT, but I'm at 9/32 tread.

Up in NY, I don't think I would risk it on all seasons in the winter. As you know, AWD is good for accelerating on slippery surfaces or steering and/or pulling out of a slide, but doesn't help with braking.
 
Last edited:
"All season" tires are not that great in snow, usually the rubber is too hard and gets harder with cold. Of course no tire sticks to ice, you're lucky to have made out without crashing! Good seeing you at the show!
 
Well, I've been driving now for well over 50 years now and yesterday I found out what icy road covered by 2" of freshly fallen snow is like. Down in south Williamsport PA there is a McDonalds on rte 15 near the Little League Baseball. It was snowing pretty hard but didn't look like much of any thing to worry about. I had a quick breakfast at McDonalds and to exit that McDonalds you go around and up a small hill to a road that takes you back to rte 15. Well, that small road is also on a hill going down to the highway and had not had any traffic on it since the snow started falling. I pulled onto it and applied my brakes very early before I was anywhere near the highway and with the motion of the car, a Subaru Forester, the car just started sliding down the hill, I tried to brake harder and NOTHING was happening! I was headed straight onto two lanes of traffic !!! As I swung onto the road I saw cars swerving horns blaring and very nearly needed some fresh underwear myself as one large SUV was coming right at me and I saw no way that it wasn't running right into my drivers door!
But at the very last second, we missed each other, a miracle if ever I had witnessed one. Got under control again and the highway surface was such that I was able to get moving up the hill. Still snowing hard out and the rest of my drive south I was SUPER cautious but once you hit ice, there isn't much that you can do and on the rest of the trip there were 4 cars, trucks that had spun off the road and were being pulled out of the ditches, it was a very bad morning for a lot of folks!

As I was driving on, I am pretty sure the person that just missed me was still behind me and at one red light I saw her holding up her phone and pointing it at the back of my car, no doubt getting a photo of the license plate of the idiot that just blatantly pulled into traffic without any care about other people. If I could have been able to stop and talk with her I would have thanked her profusely for saving both of our lives as it was super close!

SO, yeah icy road, fresh snow, bad combination! I only ever remember driving on black ice in Houston early morning flight home, pulled out of the hotel driveway onto the road and I was doing donuts down the road! fortunately it was very early and I was alone at the time, that too was scary as you don't have any clue it was that slippery.

My car is a 2022 with less than 2k miles so the tires were pretty close to new, not heavy snow tires but all year round type but on ice, I don't know of anything other than studded tires that might have made a difference.

G2

Same condition when we drove from WY to CA early this month, when passing into CA, from Reno over Donner pass. Took us (wife and two large dogs) forever, after already having driven 800 miles.

Besides the road being dangerous, Caltrans forced trucks and 2-wheel passenger cars to put on chains. In addition to super slow traffic, several chain checkpoints, etc., jams were introduced by (1) trucks loosing chains (sometimes breaking the truck), and (2) kids returning from their snow-boarding week-end in their 2-wheel hybrids having to adjust their chains, over and over again, obviously never having used them before.

My dogs don't like chain controls. Kind of funny in the dark some guy approaching your car to talk to you and having a Rottweiler responding to him :)

Anybody carry chains: please test them before you leave home ....
 
Glad to hear that you’re safe, Gary.

I run Toyo GSI-5’s on all my vehicles. They have crushed up walnut shell in them to help with traction. I’m no stranger to icy road conditions.
 
take it from a Canadian - winter tires are 100% worth it - the michelin x-ice have proven themselves in my experience, and still stack up well in tests & reviews



... also a trick up here is to do donuts in empty parking lots before you get onto snowy roads.... to familiarize yourself with handling & just how easy it is to slide while braking and turning
 
take it from a Canadian - winter tires are 100% worth it - the michelin x-ice have proven themselves in my experience, and still stack up well in tests & reviews



... also a trick up here is to do donuts in empty parking lots before you get onto snowy roads.... to familiarize yourself with handling & just how easy it is to slide while braking and turning
The Michelin X-ice Xi3 on my WRX were the best STUDLESS snow tires I have used so far, and they last a long time too. Plus on warmer winter days they don't get to greasy or slippery.

I have a set of those for my Forester XT 18" wheels, but want to use up my Yokahama Ice Guard on my 17" rims since they're older with plenty of tread. These are just as great on snow, but not quite as good on ice as the Michelin.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top