I'm looking for a list of SUPERKNIVES.

Walking Man

BANNED
Joined
May 28, 2003
Messages
9,606
I just saw an ad for the newest Johanning SUPERKNIFE.
I read here that this knife is as tough as the other SUPERKNIFES!
So who else makes the toughest of the tough?
We've got
Strider
Busse
Swamprat
And there have got to be others.
(Cold Steel doesn't count, and neither does Becker)
 
Good point, about the high Carbon steel.
I don't know, it just seems that certain knives companies
are held in very regard in these forums and other aren't.
Are those that are (Busse, Strider) better than the others?
From what I understand they are supposed to be.
 
You can definitely add Fehrman knives to this list. From what I have seen of the Extrema Ratio knives, they would fit into this group as well.

Even though some may disagree, Mad Dog makes some pretty darn tough knives as well.
 
(Camillus/) Becker does too count! (BK-9 Combat Bowie).
Cold Steel does too count! (Trailmaster).
SOG (Tigershark and Trident).
The old Gerber BMF was also pretty tough.
 
Among the toughest production/semi-production fixed knives right now:

Fehrman
Busse
Swamp Rat
Strider
MMHW (Mineral Mountain Hatchet Works)
Mad Dog

Johanning Tac 10 and 11 knives are pretty damn tough, maybe tougher than anything else. But they are custom made, as far as I know.

HI khukuris are about as tough a chopper made, but they are handmade and too big to be a "knife."

The Fallkniven A1 is an extremely bomb-proof knife, especially for its price. It is also extensively tested.
 
Do not forget the Gryphons. The 6 inch fighter they make can be bent, but the handle is TOUGH and no element except fire will injure this knife.
 
I agree with all of the ones listed so far, and I'd have to add TOPS knives. Lots of custom makers produce incredibly tough knives: Trace Rinaldi, Newt Livesay, John Greco, Ted Frizzel, etc...


and Cold Steel and Becker DO count! They are excellent knives for the price.
 
Victorinox
Al Mar
Leatherman
You will get more work done with these superknives than those big pry bars. Yes I have some of those too!
 
I have a knife from a maker named Dawson. (that's what it says on the blade, I checked out his website about 2 years ago, but I don't remember much)
It supposed to be as tough as the others, although I've never had an occasion to abuse it
 
i have to contradict the Al Mar recommendation (from my experiences anyway), while the craftsmanship ,fit and finish set new standards for production knives in the 80's and early 90's, i experienced a number of critical failures during moderate to hard use:
1: Al Mar Warrior blade snapped clean across the guard area during striking drills
2: Al Mar SF-10 handle failure during chopping
3: Al Mar SF-10(my second one) warpage of cutting edge during chopping

In fairness TO AMK, i did not have any failures from the SERE fixed blade, Pathfinder machete, Shugoto(?)II tanto,ROWE commemerative combat or A-F fighter.

....but it did seem like too many failures considering the price and reputation of AMK. These were actually one of the driving forces behind me becoming a custom knifemaker.
Regards
76225013tbnQBX_fs.jpg
 
Johannings knives are both very strong and tough due to the geometry (sabre grind on decently thick stock) and high impact toughness inherent in the choice of steel. He uses A8 which is a shock resistant tool steel, and one of the toughest currently used in cutlery. To put it in perspective, Johanning doesn't think A2 is tough enough for his knives.

Striders knives are strong due to the high hardness and stock thickness, but are not very tough and will crack at low angles and suffer fracture propogation easily.

The Becker Knives are no where near as durabile as the Swamp Rat, the steel simply isn't very flexible, and breaks easily under low angles. However it is decently tough, not as tough as the differential temper makes the Swamp Rats, but far tougher than the "high carbon stainless" knives.

Mission Knives, MPK-Ti has a high impact toughness and resists fracture from hard contacts and holds up to prying very well, however the edge is soft (~47 HRC) compared to cutlery steels and thus will suffer more impaction (but little fracture) if whacked against something hard.

Burke and Fowler both restrict their knives against cutting bone, a restriction that blades like Swamp Rat and others do not have. They are however very flexible.

In general, most of the high quality forgers make blades that are very durable in respect to bending and hitting the spine with a hammer, but the edges are a lot more acute (~10-12 degrees per side) than most of the knives mentioned in the above and thus will not handle hard impacts as well. Generally though fracture will be minimal, just impaction. Of course you could request a custom with similar edge angles, 15-20 degrees per side.

The HI khukuris are tremendously strong because of the stock thickness, and very tough because of the differential temper. The only weak point is the handle, it can not take the heavy amounts of abuse that some of the above can.

-Cliff
 
Back
Top