I'm Pissed at Codger 64

Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
9
First of all, I was searching for a good Knife; a knife a man could use, and would last for as long as I would have needed it. In my search, I came across a Schrade pattern. The 165; in my ignorance of collectors value and practical knowledge of knife usage, I became innocently obsessed by a blade and handle design that in all practical and aesthetic value was the best choice.
To top this off, I searched the net for information concerning the knife, only to find this man calling himself Codger 64 singing the praises of this knife, its maker and design. So much information was provided by this sportsman that I found myself searching for one myself, as if there were no other knife worth having.
In my search for information, I found such tangents as:
“The Schrade Old Timer 165OT Woodsman is my favorite classic Schrade pattern. The OT version was first introduced in 1967 and produced continuously for twenty-four years, nearly a quarter of a century. It was produced for six years with the Schrade Walden stamp (1967-73), then for eighteen in with the Schrade tang stamp (1974-91). (Schrade moved to Ellenville, New York circa 1958, but the company name and stamp did not change until mid 1973).
The Woodsman has brown saw cut delrin handles held to the full tang by three nickle silver flat head rivets, and a 1 1/8" nickle silver Old Timer shield. A two-piece pinned brass contoured guard seperates the handle from the 4 5/8" saber ground 1095 carbon steel blade. It weighs in at 8.8 ounces, a full half pound without the sheath. A stiff blade, the blade stock is nearly 3/16" thick, and remains nearly full thickness from the butt of the exposed full tang to within 1/2" of the tip, where the saber grind rises to the point.
There are some small distinctions between the Walden knives and the later ones from Ellenville. These are relatively minor engineering changes, but help to distinguish the chronology of production.
Earliest production was not marked with a "PAT. PEND." tang stamp or blades etch, as was the earlier introduced 15OT Deer slayer, at least not that I have seen. Perhaps this led to some complications with production and stocking the 15OT's. The 165's were, however serialized. So far, the earliest serial number I have seen is #9, xxx. The first tang stamps were parallel to the blade on blade left with SCHRADE over WALDEN over 165. The serial number was imprinted on the left tang parallel to the guard.
Sometime after serial #18, xxx, the tang stamp was moved to blade right and then the serial numbers were discontinued. Later Ellenville blades all have the tang stamp on blade right and as far as I have seen, were not serialized. Interestingly, I have never seen the "OT designation added to the "165" on a tang stamp, but the Uncle Henry’s do have the "UH" designation added.
The Walden knives have a slightly convex curved front edge on the lower guard matching the concave curve on the back edge for finger relief. Ellenville knives do not. The front edge is left flat, saving a casting detail, or machining step.
Only four sheath designs have been found so far, not really enough of a sampling to establish an accurate chronology. One used in 1969-70 was a tubular sheath with long belt hanger, sewn with four rivets added. Another is a basket weave tooled sheath, flat sewn. This one could be aftermarket. In addition, an early one, perhaps the earliest, flat sewn with a short belt hanger, and a rivet at each side of the throat. The most common, naturally is the later flat sewn with a third ply added to the center protecting the stitching from the blade. Then the stone pocket sheaths, original issue with the 160OT Mountain Lion (1990-95) and the 153UH (1974-04) appear with the later 165OT's, though these may be replacement sheaths.
Early success of the 165OT inspired Schrade to issue an Uncle Henry version of the knife. The UH version, named the Prospector, made a short two year production run at Walden (1969-70) and was revived in 1994 for a four year run in Ellenville, retiring again after 1997. Later, the pattern was produced for limited editions and private issues from time to time.
The differences between the first and second issue knives are minor. One unique feature does stand out on the Walden issue, besides the obvious tang stamps and serial numbers. The top of the tang has eight thumb rest grooves.
Other than the thumb rest grooves on the first issue, the 165UH bore all of the trademark features of its Old Timer brother with the following exceptions. Staglon replaced the saw cut Delran, the shield was brass with the Uncle Henry signature the handle rivets were brass, and the UH designation was added to the 165 tang stamp.
My own interest in these knives, though discontinued ten years now and made by a company no longer existing, began more than thirty years ago when I purchased one for my hunting and camping adventures. The serpentine handle and heft have become so familiar that it is difficult to use and carry another pattern. The blade sweep is etched in my memory so that I can use it in near total darkness without loosing blood. I will continue my quest to dig out obscure facts and details on the 165's. Not that anyone cares, but I find it personally interesting.”

So much information about, what was, before 2004, “just another knife”: shows that Codger 64 is possibly a true hunter and American sportsman.
Along these lines of reasoning, I have found no other reason then to continue my pursuit of this Schrade knife in carbon steel and stainless form. My bitch is that you, Codger 64 and possibly I, are contributing what seems to be the ever-increasing value of Schrade 165’s OT and UH on eBay.

I guess this was a different kind of ramble.

Respectfully

doublegun3
 
Wow, I wish everyone who was pi$$ed at me did so with such admiration & respect! :D
 
Hahahahahahahaha!

Doublegun, you are not under the impression that one single 165OT is going to sate your needs, are you? 'Cause it won't. You'll end up with one Mint condition in the box, which Codger will inforum you is too valuable to use. So you'll look for a user, and in doing so, you'll run across a little known variant, which of course Codger will assure you... is too rare to use. You'll get into a bidding war with me over what looks like an average, fairly used 165, which you will win, after I drive the price sky high and then retract my last bid out of spite (getting a nasty email from ebay, but this is WAR!) Alas... you didn't pay any attention to the sheath, did you? Codger will joyfully inform you that the sheath alone, the only known blue-ox-blood special made for Wally Gardiner is easily worth more than the knife... You must have our sheathmaker make you a new one, a replica of the original. After you get the new sheath from Texas, Codger will send you an email... there is a much better 165 on ebay right now! A cheap buy it now price! You must have it! You cannot put that old knife in that beautiful sheath!

Oh yeah, pal... welcome to the club.

Phil

(a little peeved himself)
 
LMAO!!

That last bit by Textoothpk explains why I haven't been able to buy one yet; they just sell too darned high. Fortunately for those of you buying to actually use vs. those of us who are collecting, the prices aren't bad for 165OT knives in used condition. Using the Completed Items search function on eBay, there have been three that sold in the $35-$51 range recently, all used, but would clean up nicely for a user.

And there are those of us who think that will all of the fixed blade knives sold under the OldTimer brand, it doesn't make sense to get too hung up on just one. For looking-at knives, the 15OT, 152OT, 154OT, 156OT, 158OT, and 160OT are just as aesthetically appealing when in a display case. :)

-Bob
 
Lets talk about someone causing the $$ to rise on Frontiers.. Just as Im getting started on them. We are our own worst enemies. :cool:
 
Let's not forget the loser who keeps posting pics of old school open stock knives. :o

We are indeed our own worst enemies...

Glenn
 
I know what you mean db3 , he did it to me too, but I not refering to the 165OT I was already hooked on them , I talking about the 897UH Signiture Premium Stockman. I went from having none last year to owning two NIB,one new in CP and two EDCs, and gave one away for Christmas. I guess sometimes we just need a little shove.
Thanks Rick
 
The market's still open on Tradesman knives and tools.
At least so far. Maybe that'll be Codger's next write-up. :D

-Bob
 
Now , what can I do to make up for it all? Offer a knife you've never seen? Let's see who can find and buy this example first!


XT2ANN
Codger da pusher:cool:
 
There are 2 rumors being spread among the eBay Power Seller's Club:
1. Codger amassed hundreds of these 165's thru the years,then he spread their glory and desirableness all over the world,and is now selling them under various and sundry ebay user names.
The second rumor is that Codger gets a 10% commission on the sale of every 165 and 152 that sells on eBay!
I admit I got suckered in like everybody else.I now have 3 of his Sharpfingers,four 897UH's,and am wasting a lot of time watching the 165's ads.
Has anybody noticed the total number of Schrades listed.Doing searches last month,the count was running about 2100 (total listed at that time).The last couple days,it's been about 2800. Either they're coming out the woodwork or a big shipload from China came in.
Ron
 
However, at a hundred a pop for a nice NIB mint early example, that is still cheap. And prices will be even higher once the movie comes out. I was wanting Steve McQueen to play me, but I hear he is unavailable. And then I thought of Max Baer, but he isn't taking roles since he got to be a bigshot producer. Lloyd Bridges is out too, but Beau Bridges might do it. Can he swim? Maybe Paul Hogan would be better. If he could be coached out of that accent.

The setting for the movie is a cypress swamp. Our hero is on the run from a nefarious gang of Chicago hitmen. Using his knowledge of the swamp, his wits, and his trusty Woodsman knife, he evades the city slickers, and gains weight on a diet of possum, swamp coon and deer, builds a nice log cabin, and finally carves himself a cypress canoe. Yep, that woodsman is all the knife a man needs. To go along with his Deerslayer, Sharpfinger, and Premium Signature Stockman!!

Tenjewberrymuds,
Codger:)
 
From Codger's previous post:

"The setting for the movie is a cypress swamp. Our hero is on the run from a nefarious gang of Chicago hitmen. Using his knowledge of the swamp, his wits, and his trusty Woodsman knife, he evades the city slickers, and gains weight on a diet of possum, swamp coon and deer, builds a nice log cabin, and finally carves himself a cypress canoe. Yep, that woodsman is all the knife a man needs. To go along with his Deerslayer, Sharpfinger, and Premium Signature Stockman!!"

BAH! Sounds like a pretty lame film to me, everybody here knows even a average swamp rat could do all that stuff with a 104OT penknife and a roll of duct tape.

"We don't need no stink'en Woodsman knives!"

Note: Yes, this is a thinly veiled attempt to badmouth the 165OT in order to push prices back down so I can have a chance at buying more for myself at bargin prices. Is it working yet?
 
Has anybody noticed the total number of Schrades listed.Doing searches last month,the count was running about 2100 (total listed at that time).The last couple days,it's been about 2800. Either they're coming out the woodwork or a big shipload from China came in.
I've noticed quite the opposite, at least with genuine OldTimer knives. Many models haven't been offered at all in several weeks or even months, like the 106OT and 41OT (plus a bunch others). These were never common (nor cheap), but there was always one or two in NIB condition for us to fight over. Now there's none, not even used junkers.

-Bob
 
The offerings seem to run in cycles. Concentrate on what appears to be abundent right now. Prices are reasonable, and the selection is good. If you see ten or fifteen of the same knife, at least one or two of them will go for bargain prices. Trends can be good if you use them to your advantage. Dayum! I sound like a fortune cookie!

It must be the toxic waste from my 165 frame above my desk. Now why would they wanna use depleted uranium for knife blades? Well, at least the display is self-lighting. :eek:

Codger
(shall I delete all the 165 info I've posted?):o
 
I don't care how pissed I am at someone, (or not) I'd never have the inclination hit the keyboard for something that long. :eek: :eek: My poor typing fingers (all 2 of them) would be blistered all to hell. Nope, not worth it. :)
 
I'm posting this purely as a "community" service. It's an effort to change focus, and keep pricing down on all of these FIXED blades...:eek: :eek:

"Step away from the fixed blades and move along, please"...especially the fanatical one known far and wide to all as..... "EL REY del VINYL"...er, Codger.

Bill
 
I like it.
"EL REY del VINYL"
Looked like a couple of toothpicks hiding in your picture.
Wanna show em?
 
Irv...I mean Larry.. one of them is a knife world toothpick; that's how El Lobo and I met, a discussion over that particular knife.

Bill, what is the other toothpick, looks like it has a fancy engraved bolster?

Phil
 
OK, Irv...just for you.

From the bottom on up.....
Fight'n Rooster KnifeWorld in horn (Remember this one Phil?)
Schatt & Morgan root beer bone
Case Barb Wire series bone (yes, scrolled bolsters...good eyes!)
Case jade bone
Schrade Whittlin' Club pin in metal alloy (Forum content)
Real American toothpick in wood...maker unknown.

Maybe, maybe, we can save some of you fixed guys:eek: ...er, I mean...some of you guys who prefer FIXED blades. :D

Bill

EDITED: Hot dam_ , you're fast Phil!!!
 
Back
Top