Important Thread. What kind of steak do I want?

Joined
Sep 2, 2004
Messages
5,250
Yeah, you heard me. I'm going out to a steak house tonite. Do I want a:

Sirloin, cheap and flavorful, a little tougher and frankly, their sirloins are small.

NY Strip. Always a favorite

Ribeye. a bit fattier I think, very flavorfull. Also offered in Bison, anybody had Bison steak?

Porterhouse. Big and expensive.

Filet: Small and expensive.
 
Delmonico! Very tender and flavorful--I've never ordered it at a restaurant--it may be pricey, but you can't beat the flavor and tenderness IMO:thumbup: You also can't go wrong with Ribeye.
 
Sounds good, but I don't know if a Delmonico is on the menu. Is it sometimes called something different? I'm kind of leaning for the ribeye, at this point!
 
How about tofu?

Ask if they have a tofu steak. Make sure you keep the engine running in your car. :rolleyes: ;)
 
Is it sometimes called something different

This is from Culinary Cafe.com I believe--I've never heard of this site before so I don't know how accurate it is but.... here it is.

Club Steak: Sometimes called Delmonico, after the famed 19th century New York dining club that specialized in this steak, the club steak is triangular, smaller than a T-bone, but with the same large "eye" section. It is cut from the short loin, next to the rib end, and when cut properly, it is a delicious and tender steak. You can tell the quality by looking at the steak's "eye"--the meat should be fine in texture with delicate marbling; avoid cuts that seem coarse or contain fat chunks.

Filet Strip: Filet strips are removed from the short loin before any other steaks are cut. A whole filet strip can be broiled and then cut into individual portions, or covered with pastry and baked, as in Beef Wellington. The tenderloin is the most tender of all steaks. But no matter how delicious and tender, some find the texture too soft.

Porterhouse Steak: This is one of the most popular steak cuts, perhaps because it has a generous section of tenderloin. The porterhouse got its moniker when it was first served in the drinking houses where porter, ale, and stout were featured. A large, flavorful steak cut from the short loin, nearest the sirloin. Fine-grained with a characteristic portion of fat, it is usually cut from 1 1/4" to 3" thick. The tenderloin portion can be removed and served separately as a filet mignon.

Rib Steak: This is similar in appearance to club steak and is sometimes sold as such, even though it is less tender and more fatty. Rib steaks have an excellent flavor and, of course, come from the rib section. This cut is often sold in kosher meat shops.

Shell Steak, or Strip Steak: When the tenderloin strip has been removed from the short loin, the remaining meat is known as a shell steak. Shell steaks are called by a variety of names, such as strip, New York strip and Kansas City strip. Ideal for one person, these steaks can be cut in any thickness you wish, usually from 1 to 2 1/2 inches. Lobel's Prime Meats often remove the bone for their customers so the steak can be easily sliced on the diagonal.

Sirloin Steak: The sirloin is a large steak, which makes it suitable for families or parties. Usually cut from 2 1/2" to 3 1/2" thick, with a small amount of wedge bone. Sirloins vary in shape and bone size. Sirloins come in the pin-bone or hip-bone, flat-bone, and round-bone varieties; the bone adds flavor to the meat. These can be cut from 1" to 3" thick. Any sirloin steak is tender, delicious, and excellent when broiled in the oven or barbecued. The thinner cuts may be pan-broiled. Sirloin Tip Steak or Boneless Sirloin: This cut comes from the bottom tip of the sirloin section. It is less tender than the sirloins with bones, but it has a delicious flavor. Lobel's Prime Meats usually cuts it about 2 inches thick and suggest that it be braised for a half hour.

T-Bone Steak: This steak is easily identified by its T-shape bone. It comes from the center section of the short loin, between the porterhouse and club. Similar to the porterhouse, but with a smaller section of tenderloin and a smaller tail, with a fine-grained shell. Should be cut from 1 to 3 inches thick. Broiling is the best cooking method, pan-broiling for thinner cuts.

Tenderloin Steak or Filet Mignon: The popular name for this steak is filet mignon.
 
Go with the porterhouse. Half filet half NY.
Enjoy the soup/salad then savor the filet.
Take the NY home for steak and eggs the next morning. Bone for the dog.
The filet and ny cook at slightly differing rates. so if you get a medium filet the ny will be more towards the med well side.
 
Go for the Bison...I love it! Very flavorful, tender and delicious.
 
I haven,t had a Boston broil in a while . If you are after a big meal then I wouldn,t go for that cut . Bison is great . If you like your meat well done I wqouldn,t go for that one as it will lose flavour and gain texture . Angus beef is great . I,m having angus beef spaghetti for supper . Let us know how your evening went .

P:S: No fair bringing a Kukuuri to slice your steak with ! L:O:L

P:P:S: I just thought of lamb ! not everyones cup of tea . When it is prepared well it can,t be beat !
 
Porterhouse is my favorite. Baked potato, sour cream, butter, chives. 2 hours of working out the next day...
 
i vote for chateau brion, with a bit of sauce bernais on the side. wunderbar! (best one i ever had was in egypt of all places)
 
I know everyone was dying to know what I had. I had the ribeye. Tasty, but too fatty. NY Strip and marinated sirloin seem to be the house specialites. I had a side of wood grilled shrimp that was great. Between that, garlic mashed potatoes and 3 trips to the huge salad bar, I only had about 2 bites of the steak, so I've got that for lunch! My dogs are happy I got the ribeye instead of the filet mignon because they get the trimmed fat.

Except for the fact that they charged me $4.50 for a Coors Light (a draught no less!)the meal only ran to $50.00 for the two of us (plus 10 for tip), which I didn't think was bad considering I spent $35.00 (plus 7 for tip) to take my sister and her two kids (5 & 3) to Friendly's for lunch on Wednesday.

My wife, a Catholic, had trout almost by default because it was a Friday during lent. She said it was okay, but bland.
 
I'm glad you had a good steak. My old man used to say the fat was neccesary for the flavor.
I'm not hungry anymore. I survived this thread. I had my coffee and toast this morning. The sun is coming up and the wild turkeys are about to settle down again after feeding an hour earlier.


munk
 
I really enjoy fly fishing for trout...never developed a taste for it though since I grew up on the Great Lakes and we always had Yellow Perch and Walleye available.

Funny...the good tasting stuff was as easy to catch as hauling it up while I have to work like crazy (okay, relaxing fun) to catch what I release. Maybe Howard can explain the metaphysics of that to me?
 
Back
Top