Grob said:
"He who is willing to sacrifice a little bit of liberty for a little bit of security deserves niether and will loose both"
Interesting misquote, that. The quote attributed to Franklin is:
"They that can give up
essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty or safety." (Bartlett's, 1919, p. 226; ephasis added)
To form any state is to surrender certain liberties to the state and/or its government. In time of war, liberties are typically curtailed. (Think of rationing, travel bans, and the draft for starters.) Franklin helped draft the Constitution, by which some liberties are curtailed just as others are recognized or created.
The question remains, "What is too much?" or "What liberties are 'essential?'"
During the Clinton Presidency and in the aftermath of the first bombing of the WTC, the Government set up the Echelon Program. Under this program, NSA does a computer screening of all electrical communications in the U.S. and, to the extent possible, elsewhere, looking for certain "key words" linked to terrorism. (The New York Times has recently "discovered" this program and attributed it solely to the Bush Adminstration [Gee, how could that happen?]. Echelon expanded on earlier activities along the same lines.)
Did and does "Echelon" cause a loss of essential liberty? Some thought so to the extent that they began a campaign in the last months of the Clinton Presidency to sabotage the electronic search by deliberately using what they thought were the "key words" on every possible telephone occasion so as to overwelm the NSA personnel who examine the communications identified by the computers (as bearing the "key words").
That action may effectuate a judgment on the part of the actors that it is so important to "liberty" to prevent the detection of terrorists in this way that the detection efforts should be sabotaged and the terrorists be undetected. Or it could simply reflect an habitual opposition to the Government.
The judgment of the families of the next batch of victims killed by terrorism in this nation (It's "when?" not "if.") may differ.
And it obviously isn't just "Islamic" terrorists we need to worry about. We have our own, home-grown, terrorists (e.g. Oklahoma City and the ELF).