Input wanted... design ?

Joined
Jun 11, 2014
Messages
10
new guy here... wanted to ask the experts what they thought before I did any cutting on my steel... kitchen boning/filet style knife..

thoughts?

thanks for looking!
20141030_203850.jpg
[/IMG]
 
That is a good pattern. I make a virtually identical one which I call my small fillet blade. This is a very popular seller to fishermen as a bait and small fish fillet knife. It works very well in 1/16" stock. I would not go thicker than .09". Simplest way is to profile the blade, HT, then grind the bevels after tempering. Keep cool when you grind by dunking in water every pass. I particularly like CPM-S35VN for these, but any keen edge knife steel will work.

The same pattern blade is available from most suppliers:
http://www.knifemaking.com/product-p/ss920.htm
 
I like the blade height at the heel, and the rise of the handle. It helps add a bit of knuckle clearance which enhances utility, no?

Without implying any need to festoon this simple and classic pattern- where do y'all stand on a wee fob/lanyard hole? Tiny one. Just in case the user wants to add something- such things can come in handy during use in aquatic environments ;)
 
Well that sucks..It just wouldn't be right to use someone elses design like that would it..perhaps I could change somethings up
 
It's a fairly universal design. I don't think Stacy was trying to imply that you should change it.

The second design looks like a much less useful filet knife, but maybe a decent small chefs knife.
 
I wouldn't toss your design just because the general shape has been done. Every maker seems to have their own style that comes thru. Look at how many standard pattern chefs knives there are out there.
 
Well that sucks..It just wouldn't be right to use someone elses design like that would it..perhaps I could change somethings up

No, I was saying the opposite....that it is a good design, and fairly well respected. By all means, make it. No one owns this pattern, it is almost universal.




As to your second knife design, I assume it will be a kitchen knife. If that is so, the very finely pointed tip is OK, but if it will be used for outdoor use, it might snap off at the very tip.
In a kitchen knife, handle rise above the counter is important. If in the drawing, you angled the handle up a bit more in line with the spine of the blade, it would give more knuckle clearance. This would require a wider piece of steel that you drew. Remember that the steel is usually only a small part part of the final cost of a knife. Scrimping here is not wise. The final product can be much more valuable and much more useful by getting the steel size you need.

A comment in general:
Buying steel by the bar is the normal way....and works most of the time. If you plan on making a fair number of knives from a particular type of steel, buying the steel in a wider sheet is a really good idea. Whether 6" or 12", or only 3"....wider stock allows you to draw and cut out exactly what you need. The waste is very low on the sheet if you place blade profiles carefully. Cut only what you need for a few knives, and set the sheet up against the wall or on a shelf until you have another knife design to cut out. I usually buy 6X24 and 12X24 sheets for kitchen blades. On blade shapes that I know will be more straight and fit into a specific rectangle, I use bar stock of the needed width.
 
Back
Top