Ankerson certainly wasn't saying that D2 doesn't perform so much as he was comparing D2 to the Killer V steels like S110V, and CPM 10V at high hardness levels, and custom grinds with thin behind the edge blades that make custom and semi custom knives perform so well. Those thin edges are one of the reasons Doziers perform as well as they do. There is nothing magic about Dozier D2. It is very consistent though, coming out at an average of 60.5. I know Jim has had doziers in the past, and still might. He speaks well of it but tells it like it is on why they perform as they do, and where they stand in relation to a custom, full hardness, Phil Wilson CPM 10V ( Crucibles version of A11). That is vanadium carbides ( over 9%) at a blade hardness of rc 64-65.
I know what he's talking about as I have a Dozier, and a Phil Wilson custom at full hardness in S110V. The Chrome and iron carbides really don't keep up in the long run with the bigger and harder vanadium carbides as well as the higher hardness steel holding those carbides.
I do really like my Dozier too and wouldn't sell it. They are just different animals. Hopefully I helped decipher Jim's statement about D2. It is a very good steel and it tested well, but he couldn't put it up against production D2 blades due to the difference in grinds that make the cutting and slicing so much easier. Likewise any of the other customs. He got such huge differences he didn't want to release the custom vs. production. They are a separate category and yes, that includes the Dozier D2's.
Joe