Is this belt-loop type considered nice to leather sheath "connoisseurs"

[Joe R.]

From my short time here, it is clear that there are things "leather guys" do not like.

Things like using rivets instead of using proper stitching.

I would like to know what you guys think of this type of belt-loop from a Buck 119 sheath (has 3" opening):


It is very comfortable to wear, but looks-wise, I'm not certain.


If properly stitched in place, would such a loop type be deemed acceptable by the "establishment"?

 

[leatherman]

Is the top of the loop secured in some way? If not the low mounting point of the loop will allow the handle to want to droop. Its simple physics, the heavier parts want to point down.

But, I am a function first kinda craftsman.

 

[sheathmaker]

This, of course is just my opinion so take it as such. I think any "add on"" or surface mounted loop tends to degrade the aesthetics of a sheath or holster. Sometimes it may be necessary because of construction considerations. If that is the case then the ends to be sewn on should be taper skived down to zero so that there is not a "step" transition at the base where it is attached.

Secondly, pay close attention to what Dwayne said and secure the top portion of a longer loop as well to avoid flip and flop.

Third, avoid this option altogether if possible.

Once again this is just my personal opinion, and other's may vary considerably.

Paul

 

[Joe R.]

It is riveted at the top and bottom of the loop so it is not floppy at all (sorry, you guys are right, it isn't clear from the picture).


Two things I find makes it comfortable to wear: the first is the 3" large, smooth opening (no "steps" inside), so when worn from a 1.5" belt, the knife has room to pivot with movement (like when you sit down). The second is the extra thickness of the leather angles the cold butt of the knife away from my expanding love-handles.


Tapering is an excellent suggestion, it would make it look less "stapled on".