Is this within spec?

B

Brian6244

Joined
Aug 25, 2004
Messages
537
Is this within spec? I'm not really used to having knives with blades that aren't centered (including two other spyderco's and more benchmades than I can count, that I own or have owned in the past) so I'm not sure if this one is flawed or if I have just been lucky to get better than average knives in the past. It functions normally and I know for $110 I shouldn't compain (and I'm not). I think I'm just wondering if it's normal really.

By the way, this (Stretch C90) is a great design. I bought it sight-unseen from knifecenter.com and I am thoroughly pleased with the design. Even if I did replace it, I would no doubt replace it with another knife of the same make/model. I really like it!!!

Thanks!

spec9jr.jpg
 
It would bug me, but it doesn't effect performance in any way. It depends on what kind of person you are, I guess. Don't be afraid to contact Spyderco customer service to ask if they are willing or able to address the issue if you feel it necessary.
 
Doesn't look that bad. If the blade rubs against the scales then there's something wrong, but obviously if you're not happy with it, contact the dealer or Spyderco. No reason to settle for a $100+ knife that doesn't satisfy.

Occasionally the blade can look off-center because of a grind that's slightly asymetrical.
 
A blade that is not centered when locked open is a problem. A blade tip that is a milimeter or two off center when closed is not.

I one wants (near) perfection in a folder then it is necessary pay a lot more for a knife from a skilled custom maker. In my opinion, a slightly off center tip on a closed production knife is not a defect.

David
 
From what I can tell of the pic, that looks like a normal bit of variation. Blades can also warp during heat treatment. In my experience, it’s not uncommon for knives in this price range to have blades that aren’t perfectly centered.
 
Thanks for the info guys. I'm not that familiar with Spyderco's knives, so really didn't know what I could/should expect. I have owned almost every Benchmade folder in existance at one time or another plus a small handfull of CRK knives, but a Manix and a Salt are my only experience with Spyderco. I really like this knife. It's a great design for my EDC needs. It's a keeper for sure.

Thanks....
Brian
 
Spyderco is one of my favorite knives. Grab it first to do most of my cutting. This is a good question and has been brought up before. I work hard for my money. I would like my knives to be as close to perfect as possible. I am also keeping in mind that we all have to pay in the long run for the extra repairs/ replacements. I guess its up to the knife owner to make up his own mind on this issue. I honestly never noticed the blades on many of my knives being off center before I saw a post on here sometime back. I always look when I buy them if possible. If it was a new car ; I would never settle for trim that was not lined up. I am not trying to make a big deal out of this. I think the knife in question will give many years of dependable service to someone.
just my two cents worth.
Jay
 
Jay_Wyatt said:
I work hard for my money. I would like my knives to be as close to perfect as possible.
Click to expand...

Jay

I guess the question here is "Do you expect a $100 production knife to be as close to perfection as a $700 custom knife?"

I have to admit that some $100 knives are closer to perfection than other $100 knives. Heck, some $100 production knives are actually closer to perfection than some $700 customs - but this is probably the exception rather than the rule ;) In my personal opinion, you generally get what you pay for.

David
 
Jay_Wyatt said:
I work hard for my money. I would like my knives to be as close to perfect as possible.
Click to expand...

Jay

I guess the question here is "Do you expect a $100 production knife to be as close to perfection as a $700 custom knife?"

I have to admit that some $100 knives are closer to perfection than other $100 knives. Heck, some $100 production knives are actually closer to perfection than some $700 customs - but this is probably the exception rather than the rule ;) In my personal opinion, you generally get what you pay for.

David
 
Having the blade centered when closed on a fifty dollar knife isn't uncommon. That's one of the main things i look for when checking a knife, it drives me crazy if it's off.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top