Ka-Bar Becker BK2 or Buck 110?

B

boyscout157

Joined
Jul 21, 2010
Messages
69
Now, I realize that these knives are quite different from each other, but they are what I have narrowed my search down to: a camping/general use fixed blade and folder. Does anyone have experience with both of these knives, and any recommendations? Any feedback would be helpful.
 
Last edited:
If weight isn't an issue, go for these two blades, you won't be disappointed. The BK2 is a tank and the 110 is a great slicer with its 420HC steel. I own both knives and just love them, but both are on the heavy side.
 
That's not an easy question, both are great blades in their own right. The BK2 is a workhorse you can chop down trees with and split logs, but if I just need cutting ability I'd go for the 110. So think of what you mainly want to do with your blade and you've got your answer.
 
Both outstanding knives for very different sorts of use. My BK-2 is a sturdy, hardy tank of a belt knife. It works fine for cutting my food, chopping, splitting (within reason - the blade is only so long), bonking things on the head (I hunt rabbits, squirrels, deer, etc.) when needed and so on.

The 110 I used to have (sadly no more) was great for cleaning game (though it needed cleaned quite a bit afterwards), opening packages, cutting my food and fitting in my pocket.

I guess if I was bound and determined to buy one and only one of these two, it would be the BK-2 because I expect it to outlast the Buck and there are things I can do with it I wouldn't try with the Buck (though I can't really carry it in my pocket to work and so forth).
 
I already have a good pocketknife, a CRKT M16-13Z, and a nice hunting knife, a Ka-Bar Little Finn. What I'm looking for is a good, all around camping/hiking/outdoors knife that is within a minuscule budget. Would the BK-2 fit the bill?
 
I'ts the Buck 110 for me. Just so many years of excellent service from a 110. But I have always been a bit partial towards the Buck!
 
since you already have a decent folder, go with the BK2.
it'll take a good enough edge to whittle or carve a spoon, but also can process firewood, be used as a field expedient draw knife, pry & dig.
the only advantage a 110 has over the becker is the ability to drop it in a pocket on the way out the door.
Don't get me wrong, I carried a 110 for 10 years as an EDC, but it did not replace a fixed blade when I went into the woods any time I had a choice. (then I carried both)
 
boyscout157 said:
Now, I realize that these knives are quite different from each other, but they are what I have narrowed my search down to: a camping/general use fixed blade and folder. Does anyone have experience with both of these knives, and any recommendations? Any feedback would be helpful.
Click to expand...

The beater/slicer combo is ideal. The Buck 110 is a great blade-built like a tank. It's very heavy and a good low maintenance high performance slicer. Some people think it's too heavy... I'd take a look at the Buck Paklite Skinner as well. The BK2 is also one of the best camp/survival knives on the market. You won't go wrong with a good ol' Becker. A machete or tomahawk would sweeten the deal for lightweight chopping performance, check out Condor and the Cold Steel Frontier, respectively.
 
If you've got the pocket knife covered, and a small fixed blade as well, then go for the BK-2. It's a very stout knife made with quality steel, a really good performer for the price. I'm into lighter knives, but I've used several of the Ka-Bar Beckers and can't say anything bad about them.

You can always get the 110 later on, it's quite a bit cheaper than the BK-2 (check your local Wal-Mart, they might carry it for under $30).
 
boyscout157 said:
just placed an order for a bk2 on Amazon. Thanks for all the help everyone! :D
Click to expand...

You know you'll have to send us pics of you using it and a review now don't you? :D

The M16 ain't a bad knife but I prefer the LE and Ti versions to the Zytel - none of mine feel as solid as a Buck110 so I think you should keep it in your wish list- nice to know that Buck still makes them like they used to even if they have switched steels. Enjoy and may your Becker be the first of many more
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top