I don't have either one right now. I did have a Marine Raider at one time. I do currently have a Kabar Cutlass which has the same handle as the Kabar Heavy Bowie. The Marine Raider handle is better, IMO. As for out of the box cutting, most people do a LOT of work on the Marine Raider blade to make it cut well. It's kind of thick at the edge, and while it's a durable edge, cutting suffers. The Heavy Bowie that I handled in the past seemed to have a thinner edge out of the box, so if you want to open the box and go to work, the Kabar Heavy Bowie would probably be a better choice.