Ken Cox .. JRR Tolkien?

Joined
Mar 7, 2001
Messages
4,608
Ken,

Question, from which book this quote is taken:
There is only one hero. He has a thousand faces. One of them is yours. J.R.R. Tolkien?
 
The Last Confederate said:
I believe it's from "The Lord Of The Rings:The Fellowship of The Ring", the first book.

Really? I don't remember reading that... I was thinking maybe the Silmarillion or some footnotes somewhere or maybe even the Uncompleted tales...
 
I've read the Hobbit, all three books of the Lord of the Rings, the Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales and the first Book of Lost Tales. That quote doesn't sound familiar, I always thought it was an offhand quote made by Tolkein. He was a professor of mythology at Oxford, and was a philologist, maybe he was a professor of philology as well. He may have made that quote in any number of letters he sent his sons, wife, friends etc. I'd like to know where Ken got that too.
 
I thought it was part of a speach from Gandalf to Frodo, but It's been awhile since I read them.

UPDATED: Well, I sent this quote to a friend of mine who is a walking Tolkien encyclopedia, I've seen this guy quote verbatim the elvish text from the books, and he says this isn't a Tolkien quote at all. He says it comes from Joseph Cambell, the author of several books on Mythology and Spirituallity.
 
The Last Confederate said:
I thought it was part of a speach from Gandalf to Frodo, but It's been awhile since I read them.

UPDATED: Well, I sent this quote to a friend of mine who is a walking Tolkien encyclopedia, I've seen this guy quote verbatim the elvish text from the books, and he says this isn't a Tolkien quote at all. He says it comes from Joseph Cambell, the author of several books on Mythology and Spirituallity.

Interesting. It's a cool quote wherever it came from.
 
I'm embarassed, I should've known that, I did a report on mythology for my anthropology class, and used that quote.
 
Well, Campbell did write a difinitive book on the mythological tale called 'The Hero With A Thousand Faces.' The idea was that there is One mythological tale that is, in Jungian terms, archetypical in all human societies. It involves a variety of phases and travails that the Hero must go through in order to complete his Heroic Journey. This tale is told in many different ways, but is pervasive throughout human history and in most, if not all cultures.

There are three main twentieth century mythological stories that utilize or objectify the Hero's Journey. They are The Star Wars Trilogy, The Matrix Trilogy and Tolkien's Lord of The Rings trilogy. Supposedly, the reason for the immense success of all three of these tales, great movie making/bookwriting notwithstanding, is that they utilize this archetypical storyline and all people identify with it on a deep psycho-spiritual level.

Tolkien's LOR Trilogy was published just a few short years after Campbell's Hero book was published. Although Tolkien had been working on LOR for many years prior to publication, it is still possible that he borrowed from Campbell for certain elements of his books. But I'm not sure that's the case, because Tolkien and C. S. Lewis were founders of a group called 'The Inklings' which met at a local pub in Cambridge, England, I believe, on Tuesday evenings for a number of years, and they used to discuss mythology amongst themselves, as well as a variety of other topics.

As for the quote noted at the beginning of this thread, it is familiar, but I don't know how to identify it.
 
Tolkien and Lewis met in Oxford, at the King's Arms (I believe--so many pubs, so little time). The booth in which they sat is markjed with a plaque. A must-see for anyone visiting that sceptered isle.
 
shaldag said:
Tolkien and Lewis met in Oxford, at the King's Arms (I believe--so many pubs, so little time). The booth in which they sat is markjed with a plaque. A must-see for anyone visiting that sceptered isle.

I stand happily corrected. Thankyou!
 
To all,
thanks for sharing. Yup I know Campbell wrote the book on Hero, but exactly I was trying to see if Tolkien borrows from Campbell or the other way ..

Anyway, it's not that important by itself, the message on myth and it's effect on us is more important :)
 
Back
Top