- Joined
- Jun 24, 2015
- Messages
- 1,869
You dont hear much about these knives. Does anybody own one? Thoughts, use, etc?
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
Kiku first arrived on the market touting an indestructible kitchen type knife, and his product took off after being talked up by his distributor, and stories from SWAT use. I have purchased 3 of his knives, the DB in D2 and two Shinobi's in OU31. I gingerly began using the Shinobi for work - gingerly because these are expensive but after some months I am not holding back from normal use because I want to see how the steel really rates when used. Kiku has been a masterful salesman but not much real information has come down. You can find the scripted talking points about OU31, and stories of Kiku's legendary grinding mastery but there are few reports from real users. The SWAT article I felt was pathetic as they beat the dickens out of a knife to where it was just a beat up knife that they needed to regrind - a fan shaft would have fared as well. I watched his You Tube presentation on sharpening and thought it too was a serious underachievement. (In contrast, if you want a first rate video on sharpening check out Murray Carter's video, and I am no fan of his knives).
So what have we got? I feel that Kiku has pushed image over substance and I find these things about OU31. It is Hard, 64rc they say and in order to effectively sharpen it you must deal with 2 things. You need courser stones to sharpen them and you must deal with the needlessly thick grind lines... more metal must be removed to get back to the edge you craft on the knife. Simply running with his Moran Edge over and over sounds respectful and nice but it is not practical, you need to put your own grind on it 18 or 21 degrees, or what works for that knife.
So, when the first runs of knives were sold the next came out new and improved - but these were simply thicker and beefier, and just as hard.
When I use a knife I quickly respect the steel type for what it will do, its characteristics of sharpening, and its ability to work for me. The Kiku knives need to be touched up every day just like my others, it is just a little harder to do. The answer to improving a knife is not to make it harder, or beefier but rather to adjust steel content, manufacturing processes, and/or heat treatment.
I believe OU31 would perform just as well at 62rc as it does at 64rc. The extra hardness is simply part of the mystique, and a knife that has not yet delivered superior performance. Use still quickly dulls the edge and produces micro chipping. Soon I'll see if it holds up to light prying but I am no out there to subvert my knives, they are tools but I prefer it when they really perform. Cutting into car bodies isn't performance, nor is chopping down doors, opening stuck windows, or other abusive stuff Cops do with knives, it is the ability for an knife to maintain some sort of an edge and neither roll nor chip when really used. For this I will offer a tip of the hat to Steve Brooks, his hunting knives were the best. If you have one, cherish it.