Personally (for me)... it's not a GRINDING tool, it's a
finishing tool.
Part of my contrasting thoughts are due to the fact that I
DO like sharp, crisp lines. Part of that, to ME, is having a crisp plunge cut.
Because of that, I did not like the rotary platen at first!
It was because I was trying to get too much grinding out of it though.
My friend and Mastersmith, Mike Vagnino, pointed out to me that it can still be used with knives like ours though. You simply need to get the majority of your work done on the platen and disc sander.
Once I get the plunge cuts ground in to exactly where I want them, and the edge thickness down to about 0.005-0.010" then I will use the rotary platen to feather it down to an edge.
I do not like the "cordorouy" Trizact belts for most things, but because of their make-up, they work very well for finishing out grinds on the rotary platen.
If I have to start sanding with anything more coarse than 320X, I go back to either the disc or the rotary platen.
edited to add this pic of one of those blades completely finished. Working with the method I mentioned, you end up with a very thin edge, and a very smooth, flat appearance to the grind.