This post is a stream-of-conciousness answer to a difficult-to-pin-down question.
Working knives: comfortable handle and useful blade grind, usually with some belly (curves).
Not tantos in general. Except for Bob Lum's stuff, cause his Tanto's have style, curves in the transitions.
Art or collector pieces: subtle blend ... can be a bit angular like a Ditmar Kressler knife, very Germanic and precise and angular, and yet integral and classic with enough subtle curves (Loveless!) to make it work. Classic designs. Or it can be the flowing artwork of David Broadwell... Dave's got his right brain working overtime, and yet his craftsmanship is super.
Fighters: curves again, double ground, recurved blades, comfortable looking handles that are ergonomic.
No mirror finishes! Almost without exception, mirror finish just doesn't do it. Satin/brushed finishes for me (except for damascus of course). Even if it's a satin finish courtesy of Tony Bose to 800 or 1000 grit (nearly mirror), that subtle dull sheen is SO much better. Mirrored finishes in general remind me of chrome plating, and that looks cheap usually.
It's a subtle Bauhaus thing for me, where design should be utilitarian. Loveless stuff, almost ALL of it, is minimalist and functional but subtly sexy, as you stated, the suggestion of a curve is all you need sometimes.
You know, I can walk through a knife show and pass 2 or 3 tables with quick glances...I've seen enough ... I'm scanning for eye catching designs where I should stop, and scanning for ordinary old-style mirror polish with wood handles to just pass right on by.
Scagel: the guy had curves.
I will stop for great wood though... at least briefly. Ironwood, cocobolo, birch, burls in general. G10 and micarta are getting old.
I will stop for mastodon, mokume, walrus... but if design is mediocre or fit/finish/action is mediocre, I'm gone quickly with a polite smile and thanks.
Anodizing: it has to be tasteful and restrained..... lots of purple and other colors and I'm thinking "pimp" or "Hawg".
Michael Walker is great, Hawg ain't.
------------------
rdangerer@home.com
[This message has been edited by rdangerer (edited 07-28-2000).]