Knives for Bug Out Bag

Joined
Oct 1, 2013
Messages
104
Hi guys, alright, so I have been driving my self crazy with this question, "What knives should I keep in my bob?". I currently have a Gerber LMF Infrantry 2, a SOG Demo 2.0, a Gerber Suspension and a Spyderco Resilience. I'm thinking about replacing the Resilience with a ZT 0350. All in all, I was wondering would this be a good selection to have in my bob? I need opinions bad haha.

Thanks Guys, GTK.
 
What sharpening equipment do you have in there? I ask because if it's a sharpmaker it wouldn't be an issue but if its a flat stone I would be very hesitant to replace the spyderco with a knife that has such an aggressive recurve as the 0350. Just another aspect to keep in mind.
 
Here's my take - on a knife forum you're going to get 'knife biased' advice.
on a gun forum, you're going to get 'gun biased' advice.

WTF are you going to do with all those knives? BM griptilian in my pocket and a mora & leatherman blast in the bag. MAYBE a folding saw, maybe.

Back WAY up though. Where are you bugging out to? Do you have a BOL? If not, you'll be a really prepared homeless person but guess what, homeless people are used to living outside, are you?
What are your triggers for "bugging out"? What are your triggers for going home since this isn't an INCH bag.
Go put those 4 knives on a postal scale and I bet it's 2.5# easy. That's another liter of water or a ton of mountain house meals. Ounces are pounds and you know the rest.
I know these threads turn into mental masturbation about using our badass knives when the zombies take over the world but seriously, you're not thinking this through. Your tools need to have tasks and be able to accomplish things. If it doesn't fit a role and if another knife can't do the same thing to 90% complete then it doesn't belong.

Care to do a bug out bag dump and photo and post it up for critique?
Good luck

ETA: no way I'd waste space or weight on sharpening items. YMMV
 
That's too many knives in a bag. How many would you be carrying on your person in addition to those four? If one blade has a defensive role, you should be wearing it. If one is for cutting your way through or out of some sort of obstacle, you should probably be wearing it as well or at least have it attached to the bag rather than in it. The only knife I'd have *in* a BOB is one that is only needed for less immediate tasks such as food prep, firewood/tinder/kindling prep, etc.

At the moment, my wife and I each have a BOB with virtually identical contents except for clothing. That includes Ontario/King Black TAC folders, which are cheap but sturdy. In a scenario where we have time to pack other equipment, dedicated task-specific knives would probably get included, but between the one knife per BOB and our individual EDC knives, that's enough to get other things situated.
 
Well, I keep the Sog mainly as a backup. I most likely going to take that out. I picked these mainly because I could strap the Gerber to my leg and the Sog on my belt. Then Id have the ZT for smaller tasks.
 
Yeah, you guys are right. Wayy to many knives. I don't know what I was thinking. Ill keep the Gerber because of the serrations on the spine of the Sog. Then my multitool. And a small knife for smaller tasks. Thatll give me alot more room. Thanks guys, I wouldve kept those in there without you guys opinions haha. I had a feeling that was way ti many fixed blades.
 
Yeah, you guys are right. Wayy to many knives. I don't know what I was thinking. Ill keep the Gerber because of the serrations on the spine of the Sog. Then my multitool. And a small knife for smaller tasks. Thatll give me alot more room. Thanks guys, I wouldve kept those in there without you guys opinions haha. I had a feeling that was way ti many fixed blades.

cut more weight. does the multitool not have a 2" blade?
I can only assume you'll have your normal EDC too, right...?
None of my other thoughts got addressed either...
 
Yup. Living unsupported in the woods using the "guy and a backpack model" is a fantasy. Therefore bugging out is also a fantasy unless by bugging out you mean heading off to crash with family and friends when your house burns down.

It does not matter how many cool knives you have. To survive cold weather you need proper shelter. After you have gotten past the immediate need to shelter from the elements the next necessity is food and water. In a wilderness setting you will run out of food and water before your knives break or they get dull. In an urban setting extra socks and long johns will do you more good.

Here is an article about a dude who spent a few winters trapping in Alaska. In it you will find 3 revisions of his supply list for 5-6 month trips. The toilet paper alone would fill most backpacks to capacity. Then there is the 1000 lbs of other "stuff".
http://www.survivalblog.com/2009/09/letter_re_grub_and_gearlessons.html
 
This isn't the place for the right or wrong of a BOB. The guy already made his mind up about having a BOB so the topic is really about the knives in it.

I won't Google all the knives you own as I don't believe the names and models are important, what is important is that YOU like them and that they meet YOUR needs.

As to how many knives, I think every pocket deserves a pocket knife, IE your folder should be your first knife on you EDC so it is there BOB or not. Then a fixed blade, that goes on your belt when you have the BOB on but in your BOB until you have occasion to need to use the bag. If your pocket knife is not a Swiss Army Knife, you might want to also carry a quality plier based multi-tool on your belt (if you carry a multi-tool, ditch the SAK and carry a good sturdy locking folder as your EDC knife).

So knives:
-Solid folder
-Multi-tool
-Medium fixed 5"-6"blade (if you want to carry two, then a small 3" skinner/carver type knife and a 9"+ chopper)

Don't carry more than 1 type of knife if both knives serve the same purpose. IE two lock blade folders.
 
This isn't the place for the right or wrong of a BOB. The guy already made his mind up about having a BOB so the topic is really about the knives in it.

Is this not the helpful place?
If he's a little sideways on his knife choices, what else may be ill-thought out?
We're trying to help but I guess unsolicited advice is a no-go around here.
carry on
 
The concept of a BOB means different things to different people. For some, it is more of a get-home (GHB) role, in which case it might mean starting out someplace where you can't have weapons visible on your person, such as for the purpose of getting home from work in an emergency. Personally, I absolutely can't carry a firearm at work and presumably can't open-carry a large fixed blade, so anything larger than an EDC folder is stowed in my GHB, which is locked either in my vehicle or a file cabinet. However, I take GotThemKnives' intent to be a traditional BOB, regardless of where he's bugging out to. That being the case, distributing the weight/bulk between bag and on-person carry is a good starting point.

The rest tends to become more philosophical in nature. There are forums dedicated entirely to that sort of thing, and a lot of users on said forums put knives very low on the list of essential equipment. People have obviously survived a lot worse conditions than most of us can imagine, with a lot fewer resources available to them, so one modestly priced knife of decent quality could probably cover most requirements.
 
I wasn't necessarily saying don't have a BOB. More suggesting the OP think it through as to what he's going to do with that bag. The list was to drive hime the point of just how much "stuff" a person neds. I assumed like BP26 that with the very heavy emphasis on cutting tools some other critcal things might have been overlooked. A bug out is no time to be hunting/ gathering food, improvising shelter, or purifying water with fire. It is also no time to be feeding the knife obsession at the cost of other vital gear. Ideally a bug out involves heading over to the nearest friendly settlement. Friends, family or preplanned Bug out locations.

For what it's worth bugging out in my vocabulary refers to leaving your home. Getting home goes under the GHB name.
 
besides the obvious meds, orientation, light, shelter, fire, food a
-Leatherman ST300 as a TOOL
(the blade is a joke imo, so i dumped it),
-Busse SJ-variant (for serious blade business..) and a
-Chris Reeve Professional Soldier (every day concealed carry)
all in all somewhere around 5kg for 3 days is where i'm at now, civillian unobtrusiveness incuded. Fits right in a maxpedition sitka. If SHTF i won't bug out anyway, i'm first row for aftermath (mid/heavy USAR-Team)
 
I have now learned that what I have always referred to as my BOB is more accurately called a GHB. That makes a lot more sense considering what I keep in it and the fact that it lives in my car trunk.
 
I don't know...maybe it's just me...but I'd say first go with something with breadth like a Vic OHT, and then add a knife that's more specific to your environment. So if you're living in a woodsy area maybe add a chopper. If you live in an arid environment maybe add a something like a Becker Necker (BK11).
 
"For what it's worth, bugging out in ALL HUMAN vocabulary refers to leaving your home AND THEN RETURNING AFTER A BRIEF ABSENCE, commonly, 72hrs. Getting home goes under the GHB name."
fixed it for ya
You might be surprised at how many different bug out definitions there are floating around out there. I've seen the BOB term used to cover everything from GHB kits to INCH kits. Regardless of what you call it though the main thing is that it fits YOUR needs i.e. climate and intended duration. :)

Oh yeah and information security is not something people talk about nearly enough when it comes to bugging out. If you don't have copies of important documents** when you come home after a tornado or fire rips through your house you will be in for a very difficult ride.

** http://modernsurvivalblog.com/survival-kit/bug-out-bag-papers-and-documents/
 
Multitool or Swiss Army knife--put either in the bag and call it good. Odds are, either will be of more use than an extra tactical blade.
 
Back
Top