Knives You've HATED, but Then LOVED....

Joined
Sep 5, 2005
Messages
2,826
This is an inverse to my other thread, Knives That You LOVED, but Then HATED.

I've bought some cheap knives that I hated, but bought only because they were cheap, but looked kind of cool. Perhaps I wanted to practice sharpening them, or I just wanted them in the glove box of my car.

In other words, I've come to respect the capabilities of some of the cheap knives I've bought because they performed much better than others I'd paid more for. A good example is Gerber. I bought a Paraframe, then found out that I couldn't cut hard plastic and that the edge dulled to the point I thought it was a false edge. But other, cheaper, knives at a fraction of the cost cut much better.

When I first got my Spyderco Native, I thought it felt cheap, and the blade was too small. I wrote it off as a Voyager Junior and didn't use it. But as I did use it on occasion I found myself using it more and more. Since then, I've recommended it roundly.

People also recommended the Buck Alaskan from Cabela's. I put off buying it because it was heavy, I didn't like brass bolsters and, okay, I like thumb studs. And it had that stupid leather pouch that electrician geeks loved. But again, once I bought one and used it, I went so far as to buy another. Now I like it so much I tend to baby it, plus I can't figure out why I didn't like it in the beginning. Brass bolsters aren't so bad and the knife is built like a brick outhouse.

How about you?

.
 
Last edited:
I always passed on the chance to own the Leatherman supertool when they first came out, had many chances to have as many as I wanted for free, but I was just not interested, looked like a chinese gimmick,it was Buck's back then, and as it turned out I was finally gifted one, and slowly but surely (very slowly I might add---years) I finally started to really like it. Currently, the supertool been retired and I carry the Charge TTI daily. Go figure!:)
 
Last year I bought a ZT0301. I have never been a fan of the titanium/G-10 construction method, and ended up selling this knife. Now, once again, I have pulled the trigger on a ZT0300, the new model in all black, and will try again to come to terms with the construction of it. So here's hoping I like this arriving ZT0300!!:D:thumbup:
 
It usually works the other way around for me. I might *think* that I like a knife's design quite a bit at first, but then find through use that I actually can't stand it.
 
I'll have to say that I've been through a bunch of different Spyderco's and really didn't like any of them. I finally got a Delica and it's growing on me, but it's not love yet.
 
It usually works the other way around for me. I might *think* that I like a knife's design quite a bit at first, but then find through use that I actually can't stand it.

Agreed. I never bought a knife thinking "Wow, what a piece of junk, I'm gonna hate this." If I thought that, I'd never have bought the knife to begin with. Who buys a knife they hate?

I have however, bought a ton of knives that I thought would be great, until I started using them.

There's a thread in here titled something like "What are some features in a knife turn you off." My post in that thread came directly from experience with knives that I thought would be great, but turned out very different when actually used.
 
My BRKT Bravo-1. Believe it or not I didn't like it at first, the kydex sheath really turned me off, I hated the slippery micarta grip and I was worried about resharpening due to the type of blade grind. After reading posts and suggestions on BF I bought a leather sheath from BRKT, I rubbed the micarta with a little ooo steal wool and I touched up the blade with ceramic sticks with no ill effects (but no serious sharpening yet) My confidence with this knife has grown substantially. I will take to the Maine woods camping next week for the real test.
 
I hated SAKs after I almost cut my finger off as a kid. Now I appreciate what you get for the size and money.
 
Pretty much most Spyderco knives that I saw before actually handling them. Spyderco now is my overall favorite folder production company.
 
Well, it took getting two Millies to realize the three 710's I'd traded off weren't too large for me after all. Now I have three 710's and the Millies are gone. Lesson learned, no more trading those things away! :D
 
how about knives i loved then hated lol?

the rekat sifu is sure one, i loved big folders at one time, and the sifu was my favorite one, then the lock problems started and it went downhill from that point on.
 
The cold steel pocket bushman is one that took me some time to come 'round to. When I first saw it at the SHOT Show I thought the lock was a deathtrap and that the thumb stud was useless. Now after playing with it for a while and figuring it out I bought one of them and it's been following me around on a daily basis performing the dirty work that I wouldn't want to use my nicer blades for.
 
My KaBar Short Heavy bowie. When it got here, it just seemed to big and heavy for anything. At that point in time, I was going small n light. After EDCing my Eagle Talon for a while, I began to appreciate big knives more. The Bowie has grown on me, and I would probably take it camping over the Mora now, because of the ability to chop. It also is very surprisingly sharp for a knife its size.
 
sifu1a said:
how about knives i loved then hated lol?
Here's the link.

The only kind of knife I truly despise is one that either won't lock properly or won't cut. Early in my knife buying days, I stumbled on this little Maxam el cheapo. It had little wood inserts in the handle and the frame lock was/is exceptionally strong. As I realized there were much better knives out there, I threw it in the drawer and there it's remained—until recently. I pulled it out one other day after I had problems cutting through thick plastic with a Gerber. The Gerber had a sharp point, but it just wouldn't cut the plastic. So I tried this, just to see what would happen. To my surprise, it did a decent job poking through the plastic and then cutting a fairly straight line. Wow, I thought, why wouldn't this cheap Paraframe do that?

Was the Maxam a great knife. Nah, but the Gerber was a real piece of garbage. I carry the Maxam when I go downtown. The D.C. government doesn't like people carrying knives and this is something I could just ditch if I wanted to, say, drop into a mueseum. Never know when you'll run into a metal detector. If I'm around the water, I use this honking large Maxam 5-inch bladed folder. Also less than ten bucks, it can cut about everything I need to cut.

People change tastes over the years. I used to not like tantos; now I do. Why? Who knows?
 
Back
Top