Koster Knives - Pikal Parer Review

Joined
Jul 20, 2004
Messages
482
First...what is P'kal or Pikal?

"Pikal" is a word that comes from the Visayan dialect in the Phillipines and means "to rip". It is a martial arts genre accomplished by holding the knife in reverse grip with the sharpened edge facing inward toward the user. Look into Kali Silat for more information.

Directly from Wikipedia...

The following are variations of the forward grip:

1. hammer grip - hand is wrapped around the handle as if making a fist
2. saber grip - thumb is placed on the top of the handle
3. modified saber grip - thumb is placed on the flat of the blade
4. palm reinforced grip - pommel rests against the palm of the hand, index finger is placed on top of the handle or blade spine
5. Filipino grip - hammer grip, but the thumb is along the spine, either floating above the spine, or in contact with it (Janich's modified Filipino)
6. Forward grip edge up - similar to a sabre grip, but with the knife handle rotated along the axis of the forearm, so the edge is facing upwards.

The following are variations of the reverse grip:

1. "regular" reverse grip - more specifically, "reverse grip edge out" or RGEO, where hand is wrapped around the handle as if making a fist with the thumb capping the pommel, edge facing away from the forearm
2. icepick grip - more specifically, "reverse grip edge in" or RGEI, but with the edge facing the forearm. Also called pikal (or pakal) grip.

P'Kal Youtube Demo

They say a picture is worth a thousand words..well, a demo is even better. :D

Obtain a DVD from Shivworks for some of the most comprehensive presentations on the techniques involved. A PDF explaining many of the key points.

Shivworks PDF

Now, when I first saw Dan Koster's Pikal Parer my first reaction was to grin.....BIG. I have used a variety of trainers over the years but have yet to pull a trigger on a P'Kal style blade. Looking at the price for Dan's offering made it more then attractive and practical. Being extremely busy with travel, I kept putting ordering one off....well, Dan made it easy. He recently put up a Bladeshow Blow Out thread where he offered two Pikal Parer and I immediately snapped one up. First impressions were good and I immediately began to test weight, grip and function using a variety of techniques on a wood practice stand in my backyard using quarter speed seeing we are talking about a live blade here.

My first thoughts were on ways to improve texture for retention. With the micarta the blade came with, I feel it might prove difficult to retain due to sweaty palms etc. At first I wasn't too sure about the handle length but it actually proved to be near perfect for the way I like to wrap my thumb over the butt for power jabs. I have a pretty medium hand size so it worked well. As you can tell, the knife has already seen a sharpening due to a lot of cardboard tubes used for practicing hook and pull techniques. Somewhere a person mentioned wanting a more acute angle but I feel the slight curve is perfect for the very P'Kal techniques this knife was designed for IMO.

I'd recommend this knife for anyone seeking a nice P'Kal blade at a great price point. Presently I plan on ordering another in the future with a textured G-10 handle if possible.

From a design perspective I'd add or change:

- Slightly thicker blade
- Model with Ring at end of pommel or butt (retaining present length or close to it, offset like the Dankura Koster Knife)


That...and maybe offering a knife and trainer set! :)

100_2658.jpg

100_2659.jpg

100_2660.jpg

100_2661.jpg
 
Last edited:
Any pics of the handle? Blade looks excellent.


Sure...let me take a few real quick. Ok....not the best photos in the world but hopefully it captures what you are looking for. As you can probably tell from the second to the last picture, the handle was getting a little slick with sweat performing the little workout I was using it for.

100_2662.jpg

100_2668.jpg

100_2669.jpg

100_2663.jpg

100_2667.jpg
 
Last edited:
Very nice, not too tactical, though IMO the handle doesn't look like it would "lock into" the hand as well as a more ergonomically specific handle. Nonetheless, I expect it performs very well for such a minimalistic design. BTW, really like the blade shape :D.

So how does the tip work for thrusting? Does it require semi-circular motion (blade is angled "upwards" slightly) or does it fit in well with straight motions (thrusting line along handle axis)? Have you tried FGEU/FGEI?
 
Very nice, not too tactical, though IMO the handle doesn't look like it would "lock into" the hand as well as a more ergonomically specific handle. Nonetheless, I expect it performs very well for such a minimalistic design. BTW, really like the blade shape :D.

So how does the tip work for thrusting? Does it require semi-circular motion (blade is angled "upwards" slightly) or does it fit in well with straight motions (thrusting line along handle axis)? Have you tried FGEU/FGEI?

The tip works well and has just enough hook to also work well. I have actually no complaints with the blade at all and would actually make the statement...I find it perfect. A model with a slightly longer blade would be nice model too. Straight thrust motion strikes were impacting fine and really no difference then any other blade I practice with. I believe a slightly thicker blade would assist in "punching" through a variety of barriers that one could come up against. I agree with your comment on "locking into the hand" and is a large part of my thought that a heavily textured handle would assist with retention, not drastically effect cost and still keep the knife a minimalist design. A ring at the butt of course would address that significantly but would alter the original design a bit beyond what Dan Koster envisioned.
 
sweet review - pics, comments and all. :thumbup:
(just got back in town)



Yes, I did intend to make this as a paring knife at first....but after making a prototype....couldn't help myself wanting to try out some pikal stuff with it too. Works great for me (also makes an excellent bug-out or back-up knife). Lightweight, easy to carry, etc.

Which is why I have hesitated to make mods on this one. The straight handle allows more grip options...the shorter blade is deep enough to cause trouble...and the overall "look" is not something fear-inducing to sheeple. Know what I mean? Longer blade, thicker steel, finger ring, more curve, more handle ergos....all these things would start screaming "weapon". For me, anyway...I like that I can safely carry this and if I have to...refer to it as a harmless paring knife. :thumbup:

That said...there might be a variant "in the works" that would suit you guys more...:D...and no, I ain't sayin' no more. :p

Thanks again for the comments and review!

Dan
 
Very nice, not too tactical, though IMO the handle doesn't look like it would "lock into" the hand as well as a more ergonomically specific handle. Nonetheless, I expect it performs very well for such a minimalistic design. BTW, really like the blade shape :D.

So how does the tip work for thrusting? Does it require semi-circular motion (blade is angled "upwards" slightly) or does it fit in well with straight motions (thrusting line along handle axis)? Have you tried FGEU/FGEI?

I just realized I never responded to this question above. I did try the knife in both FGEU/FGEI and it performs as to be expected, well. :D The thumb ridge along the spine gives it that added advantage for downward pressure strikes with it in the FGEI position. (hence a great paring knife) Push cuts come to mind. I'm going to have to shoot Dan an email soon and inquire as to the possibility of a G-10 "checkered" handle comparable to slabs on a 1911. Heck, if he could mimic the texture on the Nighthawk Custom G10 grips I'd be.....well........hopping on one foot happy. LOL
 
I'm definitely looking into the possibility of getting these mass produced....which would let me get 3D milled handles. :thumbup:

Checkering by hand would add a good bit of money...better to just sandblast the crap out of it...:D

Dan
 
Back
Top