Leatherman pocket knives

Joined
Dec 31, 2005
Messages
92
Has anyone tried any of the new leatherman pocket knives? They seem to be well built, however I haven`t actually handled one yet. Several have blades of cm154 steel, while the rest have 420 stainless blades. In the big picture is this 420 steel on par with the aus8 steel, are is it a little better.:)
 
I have a friend who bought one with the screwdriver bit adapter. 154 CM steel. He likes it a lot. Personally, I prefer my new model Wave. Also the Leatherman products seem to be quite expensive, considering that they are now largely made out of both foreign and domestic parts. I think he paid something like $80 for the knife.
 
I have a Leatherman E304X, with 154CM steel. The 'X' stands for 154CM; all the others have 420HC. All the odd-numbered models are half-serrated while the even-numbered ones are plain edge.

The E304X has a fold-out carabiner which doubles as a bottle opener, but no bit holder or other tools. It also has the "blade launcher" flipper, which works very well as long as you keep the pivot properly oiled. This being my first flipper-assisted folder, I was quite impressed by the speed with which the blade comes flying out. You need to operate the flipper with sufficient force, otherwise the blade won't come out all the way and the liner lock won't engage. But after only a little practice, the result is very impressive.

Overall, I really like the knife. It looks great; the aluminium frame around the black inserts gives it a high-quality, classy-yet-modern look. There's no blade play and the liner lock seems solid enough. It seems sturdy enough for the tasks for which you'd use a smallish knife like this, although fans of "tactical" or heavy-duty folders will want to look elsewhere.

The carabiner plus bottle opener is a useful addition, yet almost invisible when closed. This really is a knife first and a (limited) multi-tool second, as opposed to most multitools and SAKs where the main design goal is to cram as much stuff as possible into a small package and the knife blade is just one of the available tools.

However, there are some rather big disappointments, too. The biggest one for me is that the thumbstud is right-handed only (I'm a lefty). This makes the knife a lot less useful for me. The flipper is ambidextrous, of course, but there are many situations where you don't want to make people think you're walking around with a "stiletto". With a double-sided thumbstud, this knife may well have become a permanent member of my EDC rotation; now it's just a curiosity in my collection.

Another disappointment is that the blade was very dull when I received it NIB. Now, most of my other knives are Spyderco and Benchmade so I may be spoiled in this regard, but even my other Leatherman multi-tool blades were sharper than this. It took a lot of time on the Shapmaker to get an acceptable edge on it. Other than that however, the machining and finish are excellent.

Finally, it's pretty bulky for such a small (2.8" blade) knife. Not only is the handle thicker than on many comparable knives, but there's a lot of room between handle and blade, in the closed position. I assume this was done to leave room for the gadgetry, but it seems that it could have been made a good bit thinner. The result is a knife which takes up a lot of pocket space, without feeling sturdier than a Delica or Mini Griptilian, for example. Fortunately, despite its bulk, it is very lightweight.

All in all, I think it's a great concept and I would probably buy an E306X and/or a K502X as well, if only Leatherman would stop discriminating against us lefties..
 
Great review! Welcome to the forums!

I wish Leatherman well with this venture, but I think they'd be better sticking to multitools. I do agree with you on dual thumbstuds. I'm righty, but a lot of times I wonder why I can't grab a knife with my left hand and open it, being pretty ambidextrous otherwise. If they can't use dual thumbstuds, they should use an opening hole.

By the way, just in case you want to modify a knife for dual studs, there is a way. Remove the single stud and screw on a Bandit. Go to www.eknifeworks.com and do a search for "Bandit". They have one for up to 1/8" and 3/8" thick blades.
 
I bought the Model C 303 today at TARGET for $32.99. Not a bad knife, but I would not strongly recommend it to anyone. The flipper works but as stated above it has to be done correctly or it will not open fully. The fit and finish are good, but not great. I do not see this being a great line for them......we will see.....

Tom
 
Esav Benyamin said:
Great review! Welcome to the forums!

I wish Leatherman well with this venture, but I think they'd be better sticking to multitools.
Thanks!

Actually, I really want this venture of theirs to become a success. I think it has the potential to be a very exciting new market niche: something which can hold its own against the competition when judged strictly as a modern locking folder, while at the same time having most of the extra features for which you'd otherwise carry a SAK or multitool. I'm sure I'm not the only member of this forum who currently carries a Juice in one pocket and a "real" knife in the other, but who'd love to have the best of both combined into a single device.

Leatherman isn't quite there yet with its current line-up, but let's give 'em some time to listen to the market and perfect their product. After all, if you were to compare a Charge Ti to the original PST model, you wouldn't guess they were made by the same company either.

If it wasn't for that stupid thumbstud, the current product might already be pretty high on my list of EDC favorites. It's not yet up there with the best that Spyderco or Benchmade has to offer, but it's certainly a more than worthy alternative to a SAK. I bet there have been a few emergency meetings at Victorinox about this..

By the way, about that thumbstud: I've already contacted someone about putting a "native-looking" lefty stud on the blade. On my E304X, that shouldn't be too difficult. Unfortunately, on the models with bit holder, that is not an option because then the bit holder can no longer be opened. :grumpy: So while there are certainly make-do solutions available, the real solution is for Leatherman to realize that they can increase their market by about ten percent..
 
Back
Top