Leek 1660cb, bringing the two tone look back

Joined
Apr 14, 2011
Messages
1,029
A few years back, I had given my beloved composite blade Leek to my dad as a gift. I knew I would pick another one up from Kershawguy soon enough. When I did I was a bit taken back when opening up the package and not seeing the two tone blade. I have to admit, I was slightly disappointed with the mono-tone look. As much as I told myself I didn't mind it, I wanted the look of the old one.

After trolling through old threads, I seen references made to using PCB solution (from Radio Shack) to darken the D2. Problem is, PCB can be hazardous so I did a bit more research and found a house hold item to do the trick, vinegar. PCB solution will only take a few dips and done but I didn't want to over do the darkening. Vinegar will take a few hours, three at least.

I don't have a before pic, my bad. (A note to all, don't rely on old media) First clean the knife to remove oils, dirt, etc. I used rubbing alcohol.

Place the knife opened in a slender jar upright and add vinegar to cover D2 cutting edge. I would occasionally swirl the knife in the vinegar to remove any bubbles that would form, about every 30 minutes.
2013-03-26_09-58-43_390_zps519e5f07.jpg


Three hours later the two tone look was back, I can't stop flicking the knife open to ponder upon its glory. If you happen to get vinegar on the pivot, be sure to hit it with a little lube.
2013-03-23_21-39-17_389_zps90fecabb.jpg


On a side note, last summer this knife had formed a spotty patina from gardening. I was able to (mostly) remove the patina with some rubbing compound. As an added bonus, the polishing also removed the bead blasted finish too. Down side is the darkening of the D2 also accentuated the patina I had formerly removed. You can only see it in certain light. If anyone out there wants to re-create this look, its near idiot proof.
 
Looks nice.
Just double checking. You don't need to cover, do something to the sandvick steel, right?
 
Looks nice.
Just double checking. You don't need to cover, do something to the sandvick steel, right?

No need to cover up the sandvick, the stainless steel is not effected by the vinegar for such a short period.
 
If my JYD had that pattern instead of the puzzle-piece style, I probably would have kept it longer. Very nice.
 
Nice trick! Anybody know why this works? Is it reversible?

I was just getting used to the look where the knife is monotone but as you twist it you can see the two-tones. I may have to try this out though.
 
If my JYD had that pattern instead of the puzzle-piece style, I probably would have kept it longer. Very nice.

A composite blade JYD will be my next acquisition from Kershawguy. I will be grinding the blade shape into a reverse tanto and doing this treatment to it.
 
Nice trick! Anybody know why this works? Is it reversible?

Its a patina, I believe caused by a chemical reaction. Using rubbing compound then metal polish, you should be able to remove it, it requires some elbow grease. I've removed some patina/spotting caused by cutting plants. It wasn't perfect but I didn't spend a whole lot of time polishing it either.
 
Its a patina, I believe caused by a chemical reaction.

So the vinegar causes a chemical reaction that creates a patina on the D2, making it darken. The steel in the upper half does not create a patina as quickly as the D2, so you do not see a reaction there.

Am I understanding this correctly?

I wonder what would happen if you left it in the vinegar for a longer period of time, say overnight or a couple days.
 
So the vinegar causes a chemical reaction that creates a patina on the D2, making it darken. The steel in the upper half does not create a patina as quickly as the D2, so you do not see a reaction there.

Am I understanding this correctly?

I wonder what would happen if you left it in the vinegar for a longer period of time, say overnight or a couple days.

A patina is a chemical reaction similar to oxidation or rust. Since stainless is truly not rust proof, not sure what would happen under long term exposure. The immediate effect would be the D2 would continue to darken though. Beyond that, consult a metallurgist:eek:. Im sure someone around here might chime in though:)
 
I just tried this trick with my D2CB Leek. It worked perfectly!
However with the white distilled vinegar that I used it only took about 20 minutes, not 3 hours! Perhaps I didn't want it quite as dark but it certainly made a big difference since before they were basically the same color. The forced patina is completely even. Couldn't be happier with the results.

I also tried this with my Zt0350 ZDP CB, and it did not work. ZDP-189 always has a slightly bronze hue to it and the knife had that coloration before dipping in acid. The vinegar didn't do anything.

Picture kinda sucks. It's actually darker than it looks. But keep in mind there was no contrast before.

20130330_231649_zps8a99b336.jpg
 
Last edited:
Looks good, glad your happy with the results. The longer in the solution the darker it will become, and if you go too far a little metal polish will lighten with ease.

ZDP-189 is a stainless steel, you would need something a lot stronger than vinegar. You would need PCB solution to work. Of course you would be darkening both steels :(
 
Just did this to a Rake. Worked great except that a couple of spots did not get as dark as the rest of the D2. Don't know why but I am happy with the results.
 
Great job! That looks amazing. I always wondered if there was a way to acquire that look. I'm going to try that today!
 
Back
Top