Let's hear your opinions on A2 and 3V

[lunumbra]

So, I called CRK to order a Nkonka, but they don't have any in Camo Kalguard. (I'll see if I can wait long enough for the next batch . . .I doubt it, but I'm gonna try.)

But, They do have them in both steels. I know that The A2 was chosen for the edge retention and shock absorption. 3V is supposed to be tough.

Edge retention is probably the quality that I would hold highest for this knife, with rust resistance next. So, with those qualities in mind, which steel should I get?

Opinions? Especially you guys that already have Nkonkas!

Lunumbra

 

[FWO]

I have carried a small Warlock that Bailey Bradshaw made for me in 3V.
The blade is .090 thick and about 3" long, in a Wharncliffe format. This is some real chain saw steel. It is exceptionally tough and wear resistance is even better then some of the CPM steels with high S/S content. I have carried it for over a year every day, it is amazing. Have not seen any rust ,and it only has 7 + % of chromium . Carbon is high ,and Vanidium is a bit less then 30V. I am back to a small Sebenza in BG-42 I am doing a different project and like the blade shape a bit better. A-2 will still do a fine job in the black knives, but if you have that Xtra c - note, I would buy 3V. I also have a 3.5" locker that also acts like a much larger blade in 3V.

Floyd

 

[dylan_d]

I'd go with the 3V if you have the extra $$$. I believe that it has better edge holding than A2 and I actually think it's even tougher. The stain resistance of 3V is also better than that of A2.

 

[alan aragon]

3V's toughness stats are friggin amazing. it's not as rust resistant as some other stainless steels like S30V (3V has a "pitting" corrosion pattern), but who cares, there's tuff cloth & marine tuff cloth if you're really concerned with rust. 3V's edge-holding? ask jerry hossom.. he'll tell you it's more than you'd ever need for most tasks.