Recommendation? Light-weight, pretty, tough and stainless chef's knife or santoku?

TB2

Joined
Apr 22, 2020
Messages
2
Hi,

I'm in the market for a chef's knife or santoku. I'm currently in Japan so I thought I'd go Japanese but I discovered that the local market is actually quite different from what they sell abroad...

I used to have a Global G-2 chef's knife until I had to part with it involuntarily. It seems that Global knives spark some controversy, but I personally loved it primarily because it felt nimble and light in my hand. I had no problem with it slipping. It kept its edge reasonably well. I used a DICK MICRO honing rod every couple of days and sharpened the blade on stones maybe once a year. I was thinking of just getting a fancier Global knife (like a G-78), but as it turns out, Global (Yoshikin) doesn't sell most of their knives in Japan, only a select few, the rest is for export.

Now I'm certainly not set on a Global. I'm sure many feel like there are better options. The only thing I'd like to carry over is the nimble/light feel of using the knife. I don't want a heavy handle or a thick blade. I held a fancy, expensive Shun and it felt way too bulky for me. The lady at the local kitchen store said that Japanese professionals love Misono, but the blade I held also felt a bit heavy.

So to summarize, I'd like a recommendation for the following criteria:
  • Light weight
  • 18-20mm chef or santoku
  • Elegant handle without sharp edges
  • Thinner blade preferred
  • Fluted or hammered blade preferred
  • Bolsterless preferred
  • Wear-resistance is important
  • More difficult but less frequent sharpening preferred
  • If it's pretty (e.g. damascus, wooden handle etc.), that's a nice bonus, I'd love a good looking knife, but performance is more important than looks.
  • Japanese with availability in Japan preferred
  • Price doesn't matter as long as it's good value and worth the cost
Thanks!
 
Last edited:
Thanks for replying ^^

I'm in Okinawa.

In a pinch, I actually went ahead and bought a Kai Sekimagoroku Wakatake at the supermarket for the ridiculous price of about 16$.

XOentlL.jpg


I'd say it's actually pretty decent value for the price. Of course it's a very cheap construction with a flimsy plastic handle and the blade is about as basic as they get. But it's sharp and gets the job done, at least for the moment. And it's light, so it even ticks one of my boxes...

But I'm still in the market for a more proper knife :) Can't hurt having this one as a backup for crude work or careless visitors to my kitchen ;-)
 
Last edited:
I use to have a Seki Magoroku yanagi/deba/kodeba set decades ago. They are exactly that, cheap but gets the job done in a pinch. I eventually replaced my fish set with Masamoto. About 20 years ago Kai's Seki Magoroku was the same as their Shuns. But they upped the Shun line with an eye for export 2002-2005.

If you are in Yonabaru there is Saito Hamono.
https://www.saitouhamono.jp/knife/
In Ginowan there is Zenryu Hamono Center. But they don't have a website.
But you may do well by ordering online from a mainland site based on suggestions from members here.
I've ordered from https://japanesechefsknife.com/ countless times for delivery both in the U.S. and within Japan.
Koki will take care of you in English if needed.
 
Back
Top