Local Custom Makers That Were Hard to Pin Down / Local Customs?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Oct 29, 2013
Messages
763
I picked up a knife a while back that was made in KY, was clearly of a moderate quality, but when I searched online to find the specs or information about the maker I couldn't turn up anything at all. After about a dozen searches I ended up finding an empty Etsy account by the maker, and sent a message through that. A few days ago I got a reply in my e-mail from the maker with some specs, some additional information, and a name, Andy.


I realized afterward that I wanted to make a post with information about the knife in case someone else picked up a similar knife in the future, especially since I it was so hard for me to pin it down only 2 hours away from the maker's physical location. What have been some of the hardest knives you've purchased to locate information, an origin, or even finding another knife from the same maker? Do you guys still buy some of your customs from local makers, even though the Internet has removed the limitations that lead older generations to buy local? I have always enjoyed buying from In State companies and makers, and I think it's because there aren't a lot of great companies in this state. It might not be as nice as some of the customs I have picked up online, but it's extremely nice compared to some of the things other people around here call knives.




This knife is a small hunting and EDC knife made A.J. Fannin of Wallingford KY. That's all the information I could get from the mark. The handles looked to be made of stabilized wood, the hardware is stainless, and smaller details like the tapered tang, red liners, and the clean and symmetrical plunge lines led me to believe that the knife was made of a quality steel - even though I had no way to know. It had sat in a case at an LGS for nearly a year, so I suspected the steel was a high quality stainless since it did not exhibit any signs of staining or rust. The satin finish made me think it could be S30V, ATS-34, or 154 CM. I know so many local makers like to use old files and lawnmower blades though *shudder*, but I was hoping that the other details that subtley hinted quality would carry over to the steel choice. It was worth a small gamble in my opinion.

After hearing from the maker, I found out that he did all the work in house (heat treat, grinding, etc.) and the handles were a stabilized walnut out of his grandpa's wood working stash that he sent off to get stabilized himself. The steel was CPM's CM 154, and he knew everything about the knife without even seeing it.

Specs
Mark: A.J. Fannin , Wallingford Ky.
Blade Length: 4.25" (from top of guard)
Handle Length: 5.25" (from top of guard)
Blade Width:1"
Blade Thickness: 3/16"
Handle Material: Stabilized Walnut w/ Red Liners
Blade Steel: CM 154
Hardware: Stainless pins and guard
Grind: Hollow Grind

Features tapered tang and convexed tip.

Here are some photos

AJ_Fannin-1.jpg


AJ_Fannin-2.jpg


AJ_Fannin-3.jpg


AJ_Fannin-4.jpg


AJ_Fannin-5.jpg


AJ_Fannin-6.jpg


AJ_Fannin-7.jpg


AJ_Fannin-8.jpg
 
I can see no flaws on this knife in your pics, nice design, fine materials, very good leather work. I would be proud to own this knife. Does not look like something made by a tinhorn.
 
Wallingford's about 20 miles away from me. I'm not familiar with this gentleman, but it looks like he's an accomplished craftsman. I'll have to look him up.
 
Thanks guys, I really need to get some more experience with customs to know what to expect and look for. I still seem to prefer production folders for EDC, but I'm starting to prefer custom fixed blades much more than any production fixed blades, with no small influence from this sub forum and the Knifemaker's for sale area.

There was some nit picky things I found, but otherwise it is a great little knife - it's the perfect size for a small hunting knife. The tapered tang helped with balance, especially with the fat handles, and I'm still impressed with his plunge lines. I really couldn't find any information whatsoever before getting ahold of him, which makes me wonder how many awesome makers are out there that don't get their work online.
 
Back in the early 90's I drove a delivery truck for a little wholesale company. I had to travel through Monticello, KY once a week. One day I noticed a sign for a knifemaker named Bobby Neal and I stopped in to see what he did.

He made slipjoint knives and used 0-1 steel exclusively. His fit and finish was outstanding and the highest price on his knives was $125. There are some super knifemakers out there!
 
Bob Neal's one of the best slipjoint makers around. Top notch product from a top notch gentleman.
 
Back in the early 90's I drove a delivery truck for a little wholesale company. I had to travel through Monticello, KY once a week. One day I noticed a sign for a knifemaker named Bobby Neal and I stopped in to see what he did.

He made slipjoint knives and used 0-1 steel exclusively. His fit and finish was outstanding and the highest price on his knives was $125. There are some super knifemakers out there!

"it's a terrible long time [to make a knife], but I don't know exact" - It looks like there was another Knifemaker named Bob Neal from Georgia. Are they the same person?? Do you know if the KY Bob Neal is still working? Here is a video from 2012 with him in his shop - this video from a local KY news channel.


ETA- I found this photo of his "curved knife" - very interesting!! Although I would be more interested in owning a more traditional Stockman, Congress or Trapper

043.JPG


035.JPG
 
Last edited:
I stopped by his shop back in '94-'95. I don't know if he's still active. My slow connection won't allow me to view the video.
 
That looks to me to be a fine knife and a fine sheath. You're right - there are a lot of awesome makers out there, as I am reminded every time I go to Blade. It can actually be a bit overwhelming.
 
Bob Neal is still making incredible knives and is at the Spirit of Steel Voyles show this weekend in Pigeon Forge.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top