Looking at GEC knives and Wondering

Joined
May 26, 2011
Messages
704
I am trying to determine what my next knife will be and I am seeing a lot of support for GEC.

My question is who has the best fit and finish? and in you guys personal opinion who makes the best traditional knife?

Oh and the only real specifications i am looking for are sub 4 in and i would really like to try a wharncliffe blade.

(final side point) I was looking at the Tidioute Furtaker Trapper and really liked it even though it is a little larger than 4in.
 
The Furtaker is a slick piece.
P1012427.jpg

In my opinion GEC is at the top for every category, but price. Quality will cost though, so I'm with GEC every time. I have a few different patterns and they all seem to be perfect for me. Some I like more than others, but they make a great knife. F&F is part of what they are known for, that and their snap. On some of the smaller knives, like the conductor, the snap is lighter. My favorite pocket knife is the #56 Dogleg. They also have a #57 which is just a reversed frame #56. The main blade is a nice wharncliffe.
GEML570311BH.jpg
 
My first traditional (not that long ago) was a case pocket hunter, but i received a case large trapper for Christmas. I tend to carry the trapper because the pocket hunter is a pretty little thing and I would hate to mess it up :). So it became my Church knife.

Sorry the point of that story was that a 3 1/2 might not be bad after jumping from a sub 3 in to a 4 1/8 knife. Thanks for the info...... and putting up with me rambling :D
 
If you like the little pocket hunter, I'd recommend a single blade barlow (GEC 25 pattern). GECs full size trapper is on their 48 frame is it's just a hair under 4" closed. To try one is to love one.
 
GEC #25 Jack, #53 Furtaker Trappers, #61 Courthouse Whittler, and #72 Lockback. I like the shapes of the #25 and #61 best myself.

IMG_0913-1.jpg

IMG_0433.jpg

IMG_1666.jpg

IMG_1843.jpg
 
Last edited:
GEC is fantastic in all areas except pull. This has been a topic here many times, but some of the knives are so hard to open, like my Ben Hogan,
as to make them uncomfortable to use.
 
GEC is fantastic in all areas except pull. This has been a topic here many times, but some of the knives are so hard to open, like my Ben Hogan,
as to make them uncomfortable to use.

I have a couple GECs that don't get as much pocket time as they really deserve for that reason.
 
Here is my take on GEC.

They make what I have found to be the best production slipjoint. Im not saying others don't make a great one, but for me GEC is the top.

I was told by a friend that I trust that the Case/Bose knives will outshine GEC, BUT I prefer carbon steel. So I stick with GEC.

The fit and finish is above average and has always kept me satisfied.

One thing I really like about GEC is the way they keep the blades thin with a good profile. All of the knives I have are very good cutters.

On the note of nail breakers. I have some experience to share with that. I have pretty strong hands and finger nails from working with them. I don't have any problem with most GEC's. I did receive one 73 blood red that actually bent my thumb nail back when I was first getting it worked in. I finally understood nail breaker (or at least nail bender) :) With that said, all of the newer 73's I have purchased have been buttery smooth with a good firm pull.

I have quite a few larger GEC's that I also feel have good smooth pull. Now, I have some smaller GEC's that are new production and some of which I find to be very light pull. Maybe too light unless you need it.

All I can say is to call or email the dealer and tell them your preferences. The GEC dealer that helps me the most could not be more appreciated by me. Its like I get hands on the knives over the internet.

I have yet to be disappointed. But just know, there are variances with GEC :)
 
I'm coming around to what you said Kevin they're most satisfying production knives. My #73 took some good breaking in, but my other two are similar in pulls to same patterns made by other companies. Most of the time I don't use the long nail pull on my #85 and istead just pinch open it due to how light it is, very user friendly and gives up nothing in toughness!
 
The 56's are hard to beat I'm really quite fond of my #56 Tidioute Dogleg in Ivory bone and have regarded it as one of the most useful slippies in my collection the size is IMO very reasonable and a great compromise.
 
GEC is fantastic in all areas except pull. This has been a topic here many times, but some of the knives are so hard to open, like my Ben Hogan,
as to make them uncomfortable to use.

This is what I love about them!!! A little oil, on the joint, and a lot of opening and closing, and they are just right.

I am no expert, but the other traditional brands I have tried are a are lighter pulls than I like for the most part (the exception was the Grandad Barlow from Queen. Nice solid pull). The other queen I have is a pardue/queen canoe. The pull on that one is way way too light, so much so, that I am afraid of how it will be after years carrying and using it. It might be perfect for some one else, but not for me.

I much prefer a very strong pull to a so so pull. I can sit and work the action and get the pull to loosen up, but I sure have no idea how to firm up the pull on knives with too weak of a pull.

I recently bought a Tideoute barlow for my father (pattern #25). The pull was too light for me. I bought another (the all steel and stag barlow) for my self, and the pull is much firmer, and perfect.

All the GEC I have held have been tops for fit and finish!

Some one mentioned, the blade geometry on the GEC are spot on! They slice! Exactly what I want in traditional. Even Stout models like the Sunfish have a nice keen edge. They also use a decent angle to sharpen. The two Queen I have came with an super obtuse edges. The Schatt and Morgan edges were not bad. And seem to be ground thinner behind the edges than the Queen (which I found a bit odd, because the same company makes them).

I would like to see GEC keep making "firm" pulls, but not every one is in my boat.


For full disclosure, I have a large two bladed Scharade pioneer (made by GEC, #23 pattern), which did have what I consider to be an manufacturing defect. The clip blade was proud of the handle by a tiny bit at the tip. I have cut and poked my finger a bit on that blade (enough to draw blood on more than one occasion) by sticking my hand in my pocket to fish it out. I hit the kick with my sander a bit, and a bit more by hand to address this. For me, it is not a difficult fix, so on a user I am not bothered by it (the other three Scharade I bought in the same pattern do not have this same issue). But that is one of my favorite knives. The bone scales are great, the fit to the bolsters is great. The liners have no gaps at all, and the blades are both tight and snappy (tight side to side also, which is very important).

In short, I can't say enough good things about all the GEC I have owned and held!

(I can't say the same for Queen, or Schatt and Morgan.....as the three I have have issues, but I still like them overall).


Some one else mentioned the Case/Bose collaboration knives. I had a chance to hold and play with several, and the fit and finish were excellent! I feel they were worth the money, especially considering premium stainless steels (I always like variety). I would not hesitate to buy them for my self. The only thing that has stopped me so far, is the fact that I don't own all the patterns I want from GEC, and I can buy two GEC for the price of some of the Bose/Case models.



The Ben Hogan might just be next on my list.

The Furtaker also looks excellent.

I also really would like the Cattle Barron. The Stamped bolster 1/2 congress is stellar looking to my eye, and I hope they release a brown bone version, or stag.
 
Last edited:
Haha Big T your as hooked as I was at first :)

What you say all makes sense to me from wat I have experienced.
 
In terms of "best" traditional folder...it's really going to be preference and perspective.

Some folks might be content with a $5 Rough Rider while others will only settle for a boutique brand folder and pay $200 and probably more.

There is no best. It's just what works for you and what you like.

Me personally, I like Case and GEC. They have knives that suit my needs.
 
In terms of "best" traditional folder...it's really going to be preference and perspective.

Some folks might be content with a $5 Rough Rider while others will only settle for a boutique brand folder and pay $200 and probably more.

There is no best. It's just what works for you and what you like.

Me personally, I like Case and GEC. They have knives that suit my needs.

I was looking to see what feedback i could get about GEC and actually (to be honest) I was hoping for some pics to give me ideas of what patterns other people like from them. I have a few Case knives and love them but I've only handled one GEC (a northfield) and liked it. just kinda looking and window shopping though here.
 
I was looking to see what feedback i could get about GEC and actually (to be honest) I was hoping for some pics to give me ideas of what patterns other people like from them. I have a few Case knives and love them but I've only handled one GEC (a northfield) and liked it. just kinda looking and window shopping though here.

In that case. Here's all I have, it's two Tidioute Barlows and one Northfield Barlow. GEC makes very good quality knives. My only gripe with them is the billboard they put on most of their blades. I could do without that. I like my blades plain, which was a big seller for me on the first two barlows.

P1020166.jpg



P1020171.jpg



P1020167.jpg
 
Do they make a wharncliffe barlow?

I believe they have made one. But like everything GEC makes, nothing that I know of is in continual production. Pretty much everything is made in limited numbers and then they move on to a new knife pattern. They're usually working on just a few patterns at a time. As to whether they'll offer one again, I couldn't say.

Check out their website though and you can get a run down of everything they've produced for a given year. They generally give you a heads up too as to what's coming over the next couple months from them.
 
Back
Top