Looking for 4 knives for my brother and 3 sons...

Joined
Apr 7, 2006
Messages
5,213
My brother is in the process of adopting 3 awesome little guys soon (twin 3 year old boys and a six month (or so) old baby boy who was born very premature and has been on oxygen/feeding tubes since day one). The official day is coming up and I’ve been pondering the idea of getting them 4 knives that are nearly identical. I would give them all to my brother who would then give them to the kids as they come of age. My brother is my main hiking and hunting companion and the kids will be raised with an appreciation/respect for the outdoors.

I’m looking for knives that:
1. Are easy to open, I can’t risk ordering 4 knives and getting any nail breakers. They should be around 3-4 on the pull scale.
2. Medium sized. I’m thinking 3.5” long as my starting point.
3. Come in multiple cover options. Preferably 4 unique bone styles.
4. Relatively inexpensive (less than $50 each, even less would be great).

I would love to get them 4 GEC knives as they are my Muse, but that would be far too expensive for me right now. I am familiar with Case’s lineup but would love some recommendations there. Queen has been too hit-or-miss for me lately to expect 4 good knives. I have honestly toyed with going with 4 Rough Rider knives as I have purchased 3 of them and been extremely impressed with their quality, factory edges, and excellent (easy pull but with snap) Walk and Talk.

For a pure hiking knife, I thought about getting them 4 matching Victorinox Alox Farmers and having them engraved. On the other hand I think a more traditional pattern would be able to (hopefully) be EDC’d easier day-to-day. A traditional idea I had was 4 Case Mini Trappers which I would round over the "point" on the spey blade on and perhaps the knives could be given to the kids in a few years to be used under supervision with the spey and later the kids could use both of the blades.

Any suggestions?
 
Hello! Wonderful idea! I think you brother would be pleased with such gift.
What about special "My first" knives for kids? Victorinox and Opinel produce them. I like this Opinels very much. And I would buy one for my son definitly. You can find various colors easily. And for your brother you can buy #7 Opinel with classic blade and coloured handle.
 
Buck folders consistently have the lightest pulls in my experience. Four different covers might be a problem, though. Alox cadets have been commonly available in silver, red, black and green lately, so they might work.
 
Case Peanut in stainless. They seem to have a light pull and would be a great starter knife.
 
Case 6318 Medium Stockman - one of their most popular patterns, available in an endless variety of handles and two steel options (most handles in stainless). The basic one's are pretty cheaply available on the world wide web. Another option would be the Buck 303 Cadet, stainless steel, but far fewer handle options than Case offers. Easy to find either well under $50.00. OH

image1167.jpg


Buck_303_-_2013.JPG
 
All good suggestions. Another consideration at a good price would be Case Sodbuster Jr's.
 
In a totally different situation, I'm about to buy 4 knives as gifts as well...so I will offer you the same choice I'm making: alox cadets or pioneers or farmers.

Fausto
:cool:
 
Have you considered the Boy Scout camp/utility knife?
I know Rough Rider makes one (not "Official BSA" though) and used "Official BSA" Ulsters are fairly inexpensive on the secondary market. Another with the same blade selections is the US marked Camillus Army utility. Marbles is making a very high quality copy of it, and I think Ontario Knife has some original Camillus knives for sale on their website. (Mods, if Ontario is a no-no to mention, I'm sorry. I know they maintain a subforum in the manufacturers section, so thought it would be safe to mention them by name.)
 
Vic alox hands down. Cheap, easy maintenance, and will last a life time. I would go with 3 cadets and a pioneer, or 4 different color pioneers. Farmers are a good option too. Also maybe have them engraved with the date they all came together as a family. Good luck and great gift.
 
Vic alox hands down. Cheap, easy maintenance, and will last a life time. I would go with 3 cadets and a pioneer, or 4 different color pioneers. Farmers are a good option too. Also maybe have them engraved with the date they all came together as a family. Good luck and great gift.

This plus10^^^^^^

The Vic cadet will give them a versatile pocket knife with a very socially acceptable platform that is strong on the 'tool' front. The alox scales can be engraved, and memorialize the date. When they get older, the farmer can be introduced and it will already be a familiar format.
 
When my 5-year-old grandson showed an interest in whittling, I gave him the No. 7 Opinel I carry in my bus bag. I followed that with a Marttiini Little Classic for his sixth birthday.

I think Opinels make wonderful gifts and excellent starter knives. Not too much tech, just a blade, a rudimentary handle, and the simplest imaginable lock. Not too hard on the pocketbook when you are buying multiples. Nicely made, and nice to own, but not so dear you'd have to cry over losing one or buggering it up.

SAKs are a good suggestion, too. In any event, let the kids see a knife first as a tool to be used and cared for, and only second as an objet.
 
Thanks for all the help guys. I have researched each idea extensively and ordered a set of the "My First Opinel" knives. You can get them professionally engraved right from the manufacturer in some really cool fonts. I decided to put their name on them instead of the adoption dates. I figure that'll raise less questions as they whittle in front of their friends.

I'm pretty excited for the kids to get to use these for the first time... In a few years.

MON_PREMIER_OPI_BLEU.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top