Looking for a Barlow

Joined
Oct 17, 2010
Messages
462
My small collection does not contain a barlow knife of any kind. I am on a quest to remedy this situation in short order. I have leads on a single blade GEC burnt stag, a german made Russell Green River Works 2 blade in stag, and a german made Boker 492HH 2 blade in stag. Does any one of these or any other brand/vintage of Barlows stand out above the rest? Looking to spend anywhere from $50 - $150.
 
'Real" Barlow is of course 2 blade, personally I have handled a few #25 GEC's recently and have been very impressed, I'm on the hunt for a Easy open in primitive bone, and cant find one anywhere. Other than that I have an older Russell that is pretty good, especiallyf or the price you can sometimes find them on the big auction sites
 
I don't know how you could cover more ground on this subject, see more pictures of different styles and makers, and get more opinions than here:

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php/969198-Traditional-of-the-Month-Barlow

It fits your question perfectly. Find one or three that you like and search for them and their pricing on the net.

Robert

I have gone through the 12 pages of that thread a couple of times. It has some great looking pictures. It has some great stories. It just doesnt say a whole lot about build qualities. It's mainly the "it's a great little knife" or "I like the scales on that one", or "the pen blade is hard to open". Maybe I have just skimmed over it to fast and missed a lot which is definitely possible. As a matter of fact, I think I will go through it again,,,,,:)
 
The GEC does Burnt Stag very well. I have the 2 blade clip point in all steel (steel bolsters, and liners), and absolutely love it!

IMG_4320.jpg


IMG_4318.jpg


IMG_4319.jpg


IMG_4324.jpg



I bought one of the Tideoute in Mexican Bocotte and with the spear point blade for my dad. It is a soft open, and pinchable main.

IMG_4103.jpg

IMG_4095.jpg

IMG_4112.jpg

IMG_4101.jpg



This one may be considered a "jack" because it has the end caps, and smaller bolsters, but it looks like a stellar combo for me.

gec25warncliff.jpg



I also love my big barlows. Single and double.

IMG_4311.jpg


IMG_4308.jpg


IMG_4304.jpg



(the bad pics are my real camera, and the better ones are my cell phone if I remember correctly)





I have gone through the 12 pages of that thread a couple of times. It has some great looking pictures. It has some great stories. It just doesnt say a whole lot about build qualities. It's mainly the "it's a great little knife" or "I like the scales on that one", or "the pen blade is hard to open". Maybe I have just skimmed over it to fast and missed a lot which is definitely possible. As a matter of fact, I think I will go through it again,,,,,:)




Build quality. The little GEC's have been the best of mine (Limited experience).

The S&M File and wire is pretty, and probably one of my favorites. That said, I had to fix it when new. Lots of gaps, and large and small blade wiggle. It was an easy fix for me (leather padded vice, then peen the pins, then sand the bolsters). Since doing the work on it, the gaps are pretty much gone, the wiggle is completely gone, and the thing is solid. I love it. I almost bought another (sold with a wiggle and gap), just to fix, and put away until my son was older (My dad want's mine too).

The Queen (orange bone) is a Burke/Queen collab. It has a very strong spring, and snap. It does have liner gaps, but no wiggle at all. The edge was dull, with a thick grind on the primary. I convexed it to hair popping sharp, but it is still a thicker grind and does not slice as well as the S&M (which had a decent edge, but more importantly, Excellent primary grind on both blades).

The GEC have all been tight, no gaps, lovely pulls (the one I bought for my Father was softer than I like, but would make most on here very happy).

The pull on my all steel with the burnt stag is excellent for me. About a 7 on the main, and 4 on the pen).

Grind is excellent on every single GEC I have held or owned. Great edge geometry, fit and finish all stellar (especially when considering the cost).



Hope this helps a bit.



I hope that GEC comes out with a larger barlow pattern, (maybe with a warncliff secondary blade), and a Grandaddy barlow as well!
 
Last edited:
In case you did not know the German made Russel was manufactured by Boker. I dont own a Russell to compare the two but the Boker is a very fine Barlow.
 
I actually gave away three GEC's and one was a barlow....all were dull as a butterknife. No more GEC's for me....ever. I cannot believe they sold them in that condition.
 
The search is over. With many thanks to all of you for your posts and help I have found and purchased my barlow. (drumroll please) It is a 2008 GEC #25 Inferno. Anyone ever see one of these before? I am not seeing them listed on the GEC website....

Here's the generic pics
Barlow.jpg

Barlowb.jpg


let me know what you all think
 
Congratz, Sir!

That´s a nice beauty. The bone on the pic below looks great. Especially on the bolster side, it looks like a deep red.

Great choice!

Kind regards
Andi
 
I think you just picked up a very sweet GEC knife. :thumbup:

By "generic," do you mean those are the seller's pictures and not your own?

I can't wait to see it in better lighting. :)

~ P.
 
Great looking little Barlow. That is a great pen blade too! I wish my stag/clip version had a pen like that.

All of my GEC's have come with fine edges. Some of the first knives in ages I have left the original profile and geometry alone and just used the knives until the edge needed sharpening. Maintaining them on my strop.

I actually gave away three GEC's and one was a barlow....all were dull as a butterknife. No more GEC's for me....ever. I cannot believe they sold them in that condition.


Always sad to hear some one get an unsatisfactory GEC. Always feel free to pass them my way!

Give them another shot! If you get an edge not up to par, they will fix it, or shoot, I would be willing to sharpen them for you. You might not get them back...........but that I a risk I am willing to take!
 
Last edited:
Great looking little Barlow. That is a great pen blade too! I wish my stag/clip version had a pen like that.

The secondary blade on this one is actually a small clip blade, not a pen.

I know this only because I made the same identification mistake when I got my first 25, the wharncliffe Jack (middle knife) below. I mentioned the cool pen blade in a thread here, and was accurately corrected.

Clip, clip, pen:

IMG_2956.jpg


I love the swoopy shape of the secondary clip blades on the 25s....

~ P.
 
Love the color of the bone and the jigging, great looking Barlow.

I wish I could capture the deep green on my GEC, but all my pics look black. When the light hits it right, it looks dark emerald green.

Also, the two Case Barlows I bought are excellent, especially the Select with snakewood handles. The snakewood has good figure (not as nice as some GEC White Owls but still "snakey") and the finish is top notch. My Case ATS-34 Barlow is also put together well, but it's typical of newer Case red bone fading to light red/white near the edges of the handles.
 
I am not seeing them listed on the GEC website....

According to the 2008 production totals on their site, Tidioute #252208B Inferno Bone: 50 serialized, 27 no serial number.

Congrats on the new knife. I like the clip secondary instead of a pen with the master spear blade. It's nice to have a couple different profiles to choose from.
 
I found a picture of a (the?) prototype:

29568a71ccca9f5033825dba66d5f7c5.jpg


Someone's getting a ve-ry nice knife. :thumbup:

~ P.
 
Thanks all. Pertinux you are correct about the pics. They are indeed the sellers pics. I will get some hopefully better ones up when the knife arrives. I think it's a pretty cool blade configuration as well. As DannyP mentioned there were 50 serialized and 27 not. This one is serialized and is #29. It looks like the bolsters might need a little flitz to clean then up a bit, but I'll probably carry it some. I might just let the blade patina on its own. Something about the old time traditional look of a barlow gets a somewhat elder statesmen kind of look with a nice even patina.
 
Back
Top