• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Machax vs. 4" Oak - Chopping and Batoning

Joined
Apr 28, 2012
Messages
30
I had a chance to take the Machax out and do some work with it. I wanted to see what it is capable of and what its/my limits are in playing with these things. My first task was I decided to walk over to the brushpile and find a good branch to chop on. I picked out this 4" or so oak because it was already off the ground and held on both ends making it easy to chop and I didn't have to move a lot of brush to get to this section.

image1-1.jpg


After having selected the victim, I proceeded to use my years of woods experience and knowledge to make carefully selected cuts...;) Actually I just started wailing on it like an idiot who just found a copperhead at his feet. I did make some attempts to alternate the direction (left/right) to make a v-cut. Despite my utter lack of skill in chopping with a knife (and not much more with a hatchet), after 40 hits, I had this:

image2-1.jpg


At this point, I realized I had screwed up in choosing my victim. I wanted to rotate the limb to come at it from the other side; but unfortunately the bend of the limb I picked and the rest of the brushpile didn't allow that without moving a lot of wood. So I decided to do it the hard way and just keep on chopping all the way through until the V was deep enough to break it. After 100 hits (give or take) I had this:

image3-1.jpg


During this process, I noticed a few problems. One is that due to my poor technique, I tended to have bad chops. Instead of hitting the limb with the belly of just behind the belly where the sweet spot for power chopping is, I kept hitting just the tip of the blade against the limb. The result was a lot of wear on the tip of the blade and worse chopping than I should have seen. I think with better technique and rotating the limb to do V=cuts on both sides, I probably could have been through it in aaround 60-70 hits. The second problem was I had made myself a long lanyard with a sliding cordlock to adjust the usable lanyard length and a cordlock/whistle on the end. My thinking was that I wanted to have a little extra cordage in the lanyard that I could use if I needed to. However, the spare cordage and extra cordlock was swinging all around and awkward in actual use. While having extra cordage is nice, I think I'll end up shortening this up some. The final problem was that I raised a blister on the inside base of my pinky. Again, the wailing away like an idiot didn't help here; but now I'm curious if the smoother grivory would have served me better. I like the feel of the micarta - it feels more secure in my grip; but I am thinking the extra friction comes with a price.

Here is a picture of the tip of the blade after I finished chopping. When I started it was mirror-smooth.... the tip took the brunt of the damage due to my sloppy technique. The belly and remainder of the blade still look good and is quite sharp; but the tip is going to need some sharpening work before it will be doing any paper slicing.

image5.jpg


Finally, after cuting the limb in half, I rotated a big L-shaped section and decided to try with-grain batoning and cross-grain batoning. I chopped off another 3/4" limb to be my baton and went to work. The with-grain batoning was ridiculously easy... it took about 4 hits to get this far.

image4.jpg


I pulled out the Machax after this picture and tried cross-grain batoning. That went nowhere fast... the baton just didn't have enough mass to make any progress on the oak. I didn't get the blade deep enough to even stick it in the limb. I think the Machax is probably capable; but I lack the knowledge of the proper technique to make it work and needed a bigger baton.

I imagine a lot of this is probably old news to several of the posters here; but I thought I would share my experience in case someone else new came along. All in all, I'm very pleased with the Machax. It exceeded my expectations on both batoning and chopping and was a very usable tool.
 
Sweet!
Looks like another day well spent If you ask me.
 
That was a hell of a job for a knife. Looks like it worked just fine. Excellent work.
 
That is an impressive test of will and tool! Thanks for the link as I missed it first time around and thanks for the welcome. Curious how your edge held up to that task and whether you think the Grivory handles made a difference in the lack of blisters?

Honestly any chopping is a great test of will and steel. I wasn't trying to show you up, but just showing how much more you're machax will take. Someone will be along soon to chop a sequoia with one. The edge on mine held up great. Not shaving sharp, but still a great field edge. As far as blister, I didn't win any, but I think that was because my hands are conditioned a bit. I'm not a fan of the new handles, but its because they feel a bit thin in my hand.
 
No worries I didn't take it that way. I am glad to see it will handle more than I hope to ever need to try. I touched up the edge today and it looked worse than it actually was, although somewhere along the way I did put two very tiny chips in the tip. It looks almost like a tiny little recurved wave that isn't even a millimeter deep. About the only reason I can notice it is the edge is high polished again. I may have hit some rocks in the ground with the tip as I got deep - I don't think that was the wood anyway.
 
excellent outing :)

we all lurve the machax, do we not? :)
 
Back
Top