MacTech's leather scrap cut-off competition (A.K.A, my Harpy scares me...)

Joined
Jan 7, 2006
Messages
611
i've been playing around with a small scrap of leather left over from my strop material, doing some impromptu cut tests, and the Harpy's ability to seperate matter is, quite honestly, terrifying....

i took a small fragment of leather (1/8" thick (rough approxamation, don't have a ruler or calipers, your basic standard upholstery leather) and the Harpy, put the point of the blade on the leather and drew back....

using *only the weight of the blade, nothing more*, the Harpy cut clean through the leather, clean, razor sharp edges, no tearing, nothing, it was like the leather *wasn't even there*....

i suppose it shouldn't surprise me, last night i had the Harpy in one hand, and i absentmindedly brushed the side of my index finger against the blade, between the back of the fingernail and first knuckle, didn't feel a thing, didn't even leave a scratch, a minute or so later, that "scratch" started turning red as a few droplets of blood welled up from the cut, i still didn't feel it, only after i dabbed on some "New Skin" liquid bandage did i notice something, the sting of the antiseptic, still, the cut from the Harpy was painless.....

anyway, back to the leather test....

i decided to test my other EDC knives (some non-Spydies, as well as the three Spydies...)

Harpy; clean cut all the way through with just the weight of the knife, no pressure, no resistance, same cutting performance on the smooth side and the rough side of the leather, clean cut either way, no nap tearing

Cricket; the tip of the blade cut about 3/4 of the way through the leather (smoothside) with no pressure, light pressure cut all the way through, light resistance during the cut, the curved belly of the blade cut all the way through with no pressure or resistance though....
roughside cutting was poor, less than 1/4 of the way through, lots of nap tearing using the tip, however, the belly cut equally as well as it did on the smooth side, clean cut, no nap tearing

Native; same as the Harpy, the weight of the knife was sufficient for a clean cut, more resistance than the Harpy, slight nap tearing on a rough-side cut

Kershaw Scallion; 3/4 of the way through, no pressure on the smooth side, 1/4 of the way on the rough side, lots of nap pulling and tearing

Vic. Spartan Lite; (smooth side) small blade only cut halfway, no pressure, large blade 3/4 way through (rough side) small blade, less than 1/4", blade deflected by nap, incomplete cut, large blade the same

Wenger Esquire; (smooth side) blade cut 1/2 of the way through (rough side) less than 1/4 way, deflected by nap, incomplete cut

the clear winner here was the Harpy, it was so good it was *scary*, overall rankings would go as follows, best to worst...

1; Harpy
2; Cricket (the belly of the blade)
3; Native
4; Cricket (the tip of the blade)
5; Kershaw Scallion
6; Vic. Spartan Lite (large blade)
7; Spartan Lite (small blade)
8; Wenger Esquire

the Spydies clearly dominated the top 3....
 
I've only ever seriously cut myself once. First "real" knife was a Harpy I bought about 12-15 years ago. I was cutting something I was holding in my left hand & slipped. Harpy went through the tubing or whatever it was, then my skin starting at the base of my thumb into the muscle, leaving a gash about an inch long & as I recall about a 1/4" deep, bled like crazy. I was at work & a supervisor was close enough to see it happen so I duct tapped it & said nothing (I was piddle-farting around when I shouldn't have been).

Haven't carried or used it since the next "real" knife came along a couple of years later & I thought about selling it but can't bring myself to mainly for sentimental reasons. I used mine to cut up leather to make a couple of sheaths way back, it did a great job.
 
Hollow ground hawkbill = one cutting machine

I agree. Looked at a friends and found it to be a wicked draw cutter.
 
Back
Top