• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Mann Lewistown PA DB and WC Kelly Perfect

Joined
Aug 7, 2014
Messages
197
i have been meaning to post these two up for a few weeks. found locally, both were on good hafts. both were had for less than $5.00... i always forget to take before pictures, which bothers me quite a bit. i would like to document what these things start out as.

Mann double bit. this ax was in pretty rough shape. fully covered in rust, with slight(IMO) pitting. the haft was in very serviceable shape, but i pulled it anyway. i acquired an old slim, beautiful NOS Wards DB haft at the same place where i found this guy, so i put them together after rehabbing the steel. i scrubbed it starting with 320 paper, and moved up to 400 over the whole thing. then i moved up to 600 on the bevels, then 1500. at this point, i did a very small bit of profiling and putting the edge curve back into shape. needed NO thinning. once i got both bits where i wanted them, i spent some time with the bench buffer with emery compound, and finished with white polishing compound, which is a "medium" cutting compound. it is mirror fine, with a bit of pitting showing through. here are a couple pics, and i will post a couple more in a bit in natural light outside. handles is treated with medium walnut Danish oil, beeswax after cured.






WC Kelly Perfect Michigan. this ax was on a rough,very dry, octagonal haft. the head was very rusty, but with very little pitting. it had been sharpened all to hell, so i did not reprofile this one. used a scrub pad and then 320 and 400g paper, and oiled it. the haft got sanded starting with 100, up to 320. the Ol Lady wanted to use black walnut danish oil on it, i protested heavily and explained how dry the wood was and that it would turn out MUCH darker than any of our others... she insisted, and slathered it on... needless to say, it turned out VERY dark. doesnt look bad at all, and after drying and waxing later, looks pretty darn good! still much darker than i prefer a haft, but good nonetheless. it resides on the wall with the rest of her personal axes.



also picked up another no name hewing hatchet with no haft. have yet to hang this one. very clean, no rust.

 
Last edited:
Sheesh, all of a sudden no-name hewing hatchets are popping up out of the woodwork! I too have a clean one that's never been used in the 35 years after I found it in a central BC Prov Park campsite and my then 'man Friday' (an employee at the time) re-hafted it with an old axe butt end one rainy day while I wasn't looking.
 
Sheesh, all of a sudden no-name hewing hatchets are popping up out of the woodwork! I too have a clean one that's never been used in the 35 years after I found it in a central BC Prov Park campsite and my then 'man Friday' (an employee at the time) re-hafted it with an old axe butt end one rainy day while I wasn't looking.

yes, but i dont get excited about the hewing hatchets so much, unless they are very obviously OLD. this style hatchet is still being produced, in the USA at that! Barco makes them, and they look just like these, so while im sure the new ones arent flying off the shelves to be found in flea markets often, it is possible! i got this particular hewin' head for a measly $3.00 same price as the Kelly!

Very nice work- makes me a little shameful of my steel work ;)

Bill

thanks! although nothing special on that one really. it didnt need much, just an hour or two of forearm burning scrubbing and sanding. the buffing was easy with a bench top buffer with two wheels with different compounds. it was a good specimen for the bit/bevel polishing IMO, i really like the contrast.

She sounds like a keeper to me!

the Kelly or the ol lady?? kidding.. she is! first i have found that enjoys an ax in the hand, and she isnt afraid to really use them either. maybe one day she might give Ms. Vido a run for her money with the barefoot flick splitting. i bet i could get her flicking in no time!!
 
Last edited:
its in absolutely great shape, probably my favorite as of now. the contrast of the bevels and bit really pop, and the handle is exactly what a haft should be, slim, thin, tapered, and with the right type of swell on the end. grain is not perfect, but it is heavy wood, and probably 20 years old NOS..

still looking for a Kelly perfect in good enough shape to make an ax like this one, bits intact, etc.. the hunt continues..
 
I like how you polished the bit way back and left the phantom bevels rough on the Mann DB. I've been wanting to do that too. I'm glad you were able to save the old octagonal handle also.
 
I like how you polished the bit way back and left the phantom bevels rough on the Mann DB. I've been wanting to do that too.

I agree that makes the axe really unique looking. Really sets off the bevels and you just gave me an idea on my latest and first phantom bevel Plumb.

Good finds thanks for sharing!
 
I like how you polished the bit way back and left the phantom bevels rough on the Mann DB. I've been wanting to do that too.

I agree that makes the axe really unique looking. Really sets off the bevels and you just gave me an idea on my latest and first phantom bevel Plumb.

Good finds thanks for sharing!
 
Back
Top