Mechanical Watches

LEGION 12

Gold Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
62,439
I have seen some really great watches here but not much on ones that you have to wind . I thought that i was done wearing one but i find myself missing having one . I have mostly owned diving watches in the past i have sold all of them off . Looking to go real simple this time i am aware of the Marathon Military field watch . Is there something similar out there without the higher price ? Would like but dont have to have the luminuos feature water resistant is fine . Not a fan of steel bands and would like not to spend more than $ 100.00. Does a watch like this exist ?
 
Last edited:
Seiko SNK805

51qFpUHlEZL._SX385_.jpg


Runs about 65 bucks. Automatic movement, decent lume, looks awesome on a NATO or ZULU strap.
 
I have seen some really great watches here but not much on ones that you have to wind . I thought that i was done wearing one but i find myself missing having one . I have mostly owned diving watches in the past i have sold all of them off . Looking to go real simple this time i am aware of the Marathon Military field watch . Is there something similar out there without the higher price ? Would like but dont have to have the luminuos feature water resistant is fine . Not a fan of steel bands and would like not to spend more than $ 100.00. Does a watch like this exist ?

There is a big range of mechanical watches out there and people get just as fanatical about collecting watches as they do collecting knives.

You can get plenty of good mechanical watches with some water resistance for under $100. You might not want to actually dive with them but you could probably swim with them or wear them while washing your car without much risk.

First of all there are mechanical watches that you wind, called "hand wind", and there are watches that wind themselves while you wear them due to the inertia of a little weight inside of the watch, these are called "automatics". Most inexpensive watches will have a power reserve capacity of around 40 hours so with an automatic you have to wear it frequently or it runs down. You can even buy electric powered winders that you set the watch on when you aren't wearing it and the rotation of the winder keeps the watch wound.

Second, just like with knives, you have to buy your watches the right way. If you walk into the mall jewelry store you will pay a lot for a watch. If you find internet sellers you will do better, but for best prices you either buy used or you buy from asian sellers on online auctions. And there are plenty of used watches being sold every day among enthusiasts because watch enthusiasts are even more fickle than knife enthusiasts and they trade frequently.

Third, there are a few brands that use tritium tubes on their dials. Luminox is one of the most popular. I'm not aware of any very inexpensive mechanical watches with tritium tubes but there may be some. I have a couple of Luminox watches that I really like. Most dive watches use a luminous paint that absorbs light and then glows in the dark for some time. Good luminous paint will glow much brighter than tritium tubes, at least for an hour or two. Tritium tubes will glow the same for years.

Fourth, many watches come with metal bracelets but the watches that most watch enthusiasts go for have the ability to use a variety of bracelets or straps. Straps are available in various leathers, rubber and nylon. Rubber and nylon are suitable for diving and outdoor activities. The better nylon straps are the NATO and ZULU styles, James Bond was wearing his Rolex dive watch on a NATO strap in one of the early 007 movies. There are some watch styles that come with integrated bracelets and the bracelets can't be switched out for something else. These types of watches are the ones that you find mostly at department stores and jewelry stores. I don't see very many inexpensive watches with integrated bracelets that watch enthusiasts are interested in but there are a few.

For inexpensive automatic watches I would recommend Seiko, Citizen and Orient. You can find good models from them for $100 if you search carefully. The better Seikos are more expensive but the Seiko 5 line is a very good value and many of them are priced under $100.

There are a lot of good online watch forums- pmwf.com, seiko-citizen watch forum, timezone.com, watch you seek, etc.

At one time I had a collection of 6 or 8 mechanical watches, none of which cost more than about $110. I've moved to a few more expensive watches now.

Here is a variety:

DSC_6318b.jpg
 
I collect watches as well as other things including knives, all I will say is you get what you pay for. If losing over a minute accuracy per day is not a problem for you then yes, you can find an auto for around 100.00 but if accuracy means anything, you have to be extremely lucky to find something for $100.00 on the used market. Good luck in your Quest friend.
 
Far to many choices LOL ! Im not a collector far from it i have enough problems trying to stop buying knives . I have had a few expensive watches just not for me i like to be able to wear one anywhere anytime . Without having to worry about the inevitable when the time comes when i destroy it and i will . Many of the expensive watches i have owned never got worn much just for that reason . So to me keeping it simple and not spending to much money makes a lot more sense at least to me .
 
I'm about to get the seiko snk809. Or the 805. Can't decide. Black or green? But it seems to be one of the best reliable mechanical watches at that price.
 
I collect watches as well as other things including knives, all I will say is you get what you pay for. If losing over a minute accuracy per day is not a problem for you then yes, you can find an auto for around 100.00 but if accuracy means anything, you have to be extremely lucky to find something for $100.00 on the used market. Good luck in your Quest friend.

A minute a day is a big of an exaggeration, no? I've never had anything like that happen with Seiko, much less Invicta... I have cheap chinese mechanicals that are equally accurate as well.
 
A minute a day is a big of an exaggeration, no? I've never had anything like that happen with Seiko, much less Invicta... I have cheap chinese mechanicals that are equally accurate as well.

It is not out of the question. I've bought watches with Japanese Miyota movements that were off by 2 minutes per day.

I've had about a dozen watches with the Seiko 7s26 movement and the ones that I had were all around 20-30 seconds off per day even though many people report them being within 15 sec per day. I managed to regulate my Miyota movements to be much better but they would still vary quite a bit from day to day. The Seiko 7s26 movements can be regulated as well but I have not tried to regulate one. I have read that they are extremely touchy to regulate. I have not owned an Orient mechanical movement yet. I've owned a number of ETA 2824 movements and they typically run very well, near COSC levels.

As a watch enthusiast I don't find that accuracy is a requirement for everyday wear because I seldom wear a watch for more than about 5 days in a row. A lot of people are the same way with their EDC knives, they switch from one to another frequently.
 
I'm about to get the seiko snk809. Or the 805. Can't decide. Black or green? But it seems to be one of the best reliable mechanical watches at that price.

I think that's the way I'm gonna go it looks like it's got everything im looking for. I have overlooked the Seiko brand if i remember right a Seiko was the first dive watch i ever owned. Thanks everyone
 
I'm a fan of the Orient Mako watch,which can be had for $100.00. I've had mine for over a year now. I've never actually dived with it,but I have gone swimming in it multiple times and it was fine.
 
Question for some of the youth challenged people. Does anyone remember the dive watch Sears used to sell that was packed in a clear plastic tube filled with water?
 
I don't think that's it this was in the 1970s i think it was a Seiko can't remember for sure .
 
Question for some of the youth challenged people. Does anyone remember the dive watch Sears used to sell that was packed in a clear plastic tube filled with water?

I would love to see a picture of that one. Here's the oldest diver in my collection with my favorite little folder.

P1170036.jpg
 
My one mechanical watch is an unbadged Parnis (China). The quality is surprisingly good for a cheap watch, and I am quite happy with it. It is a hand winder with a lefty crown in the style of a WWII Luftwaffe "flieger" watch. I did my homework at a watch forum before buying and learned that these are pretty decent for what they are. It loses about a minute a week when used regularly. Not bad for sixty bucks.
 
If you don't mind going east, try a Vostok Amphibia.

V5_1000.jpg


$65 to $70 + $15 postage from Russia. You will want to replace the bracelet, but the Cold War is over and you can wear a Russian watch on a NATO strap. Figure $100 total cost for a 200M divers' watch.

A Vostok Komandirskie is around $40 + $15 postage.

dscf0014edit1024za8.jpg


In case you didn't guess, these are military-style field watches. They come with tanks, submarines, guided missle cruisers, the KGB sword logo (!), or just a red star if you want to be discreet. 100M water resistance and a 17 jewel movement, but they work. You will really want to replace the strap or bracelet.
 
Back
Top