Mercharness Alternatives?

Joined
Mar 2, 2010
Messages
128
I like the under-the-arm method of fixed blade carry and I plan to use it when I get my Izula-II. However, I don't really the Mercharness. So, do you guys know of alternatives to the Mercharness that function in a similar manner?
 
Before I ever heard of the Mercharness I was making very similar rigs out of knotted paracord. I have seen pics of rigs from the 1970s made from elastic ribbon. I have also seen custom leather shoulder rigs for knives.

I disagree with George on a lot of things, but I always recommend folks buy and use his Mercharness. Very well designed product. IMHO, nothing is better for carrying a knife in a Kydex sheath concealed under a light shirt. I've seen guys carry KelTecs that way too.
 
Bud Nealy's system is impressive but it's way more complicated and expensive than the Mercharness. I've got 3 or 4 Mercharnesses attached to knives because, although the system is very simple, I find it's not that convenient to transfer from knife to knife. It really doesn't matter though as the Mercharness is so cheap. One thing I will say though, is that for unflexible guy like me it can be a bit of a struggle to get one off or on.
 
Bud Nealy is cool and his knives and gear are top shelf!

The Mercharness is practically unique. Simple and lightweight and inexpensive. Give it a try before you look elsewhere.
 
Bud Nealy's system is impressive but it's way more complicated and expensive than the Mercharness.

Not to take anything away from George's rig, but Bud's system can be obtained somewhat cheaply. That Dual-Lock Velcro-type fastening tape he uses is made by 3m and can be bought at most hardware stores. Last time I bought some I think I paid around $5 for enough to do maybe one or two sheaths. The belt clips are another thing though. I think I saw them at Knifekits for $2. I've used those same clips on my Bianchi gear and they hold very well. So it's possible to rig up a few setups for about the same as George's system.
 
Most people who find the mercharness at all uncomfortable usually have it set up incorrectly. Start off with centering the single rubber bead in the middle of your back (helps to have some help). When mounting it to the sheath ensure that one lead is attached to the the top, and the other lead to a rear hole. This ensures that the knife will not pendulum, my primary issue with neck carry.

I am currently working on new carry and deployment options with Crawford Knives, as well as a redesign on their Ti Credit Card knife.

There are makers out there who make great knives, less make good kydex, even fewer understand the difference between carry and deployment options. This means the customer will be limited in their options. More than one knife has been sold, traded, or given away because the carry option created by the make did not suit the needs of the customer. Most often because of an integrated belt loop or the Tec Loc AKA the enemy of concealment.

Carry option- usually a leather or kydex sheath intended to protect the blade and retain the knife with the use of friction, snaps, buckles or whatever. Primarily to ensure the knife will not fall out. The problem is just like duty holsters is that retention is a principle that works both ways. What keeps the knife from falling out will also need to be defeated for you to draw the knife.

Deployment options- what position are we most likely to be in when we need to draw our knife? Most carry options are based on the used being in standing erect position. We actually spend little time this way. Especially under stress we are likely to be at least crouched down. This makes many carry options uncomfortable and difficult. Then add in the positions of sitting, on your back, on your stomach, and kneeling, you can see where it gets even tougher. Then add in the dynamic movement associated with interpersonal combat what you find in that options that will serve you best are pretty limited.

The first thing is comfort so that you carry it everyday no matter what you wear. This usually means having 1-2 spare sheaths for the knife. Next you want the knife to move as the body moves but at the same time stays in place. When pressure testing this stuff we have found that the best two, and most inexpensive options are the Tactical Tether and mercharness. They were both bred out of necessity.

I hope the above gives a better understanding and what is involved in getting the most out of your fixed blades, especially those for self-defense purposes.- George

MCS Blog
 
Back
Top