Model 14 Test/Review

Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
1,383
Reposted from over at BCUSA.

Today I got up early and went out in the woods with the sole purpose of testing my new Randall 14.

Here's a comparison pic with a Becker BK7, both knives are very similar.
randall14bk7.jpg


First up, chopping. The knife chops fine, bites deep and all that but the handle isn't very comfortable while chopping. It's not bad, but it's not great either.
randall14chopping.jpg


Simple carving tasks. The blade is very sharp with a hollow grind, makes carving tasks easy. The top guard does rub the base of my thumb the wrong way. Going to remedy this by knocking down the edges with a dremel, buffing wheel and compound.
randall14carving.jpg


Next up is the fishing spear. It's the lousiest one I ever made. It's made out of twisted and knotted holly. Gotta work with what ya got. The knife did fine, even though I did bumble up pretty bad once, see the second pic for that.
randall14spear.jpg


One of these days my simple mistakes I apparently love making so much are gonna cost me. I need to work on being more careful.
knucklecut.jpg


Patched myself up and finished the spear, then onto batonning. Yep, it does fine.
randall14baton.jpg


Last but not least the most important task, :39: stick time. His name Cousin Ed, he's special. :p
randall14stickchicken.jpg


Knife after all is said and done, damn, dirty knives look great. :D
randall14finished.jpg


Overall the blade is a joy to use. I do have a couple minor issues with it but one will be remedied and the other worked around. Like I said in the other thread this is the first high end knife I've ever bought myself, so it's definetly a keeper.
 
Ouch!

Nice post, I ordered my #14 from the shop with a Border Patrol Handle shape. I thought that might be more universally comfortable for all-around use.
 
Ouch is right bud. If I look in the wound and move my finger I can see stuff moving in there...

I do like that border patrol handle shape. Maybe one day I'll send my knife to Randall to get the top guard removed and maybe a border patrol handle put on. If they do that kinda thing.
 
Ouch is right bud. If I look in the wound and move my finger I can see stuff moving in there...

I do like that border patrol handle shape. Maybe one day I'll send my knife to Randall to get the top guard removed and maybe a border patrol handle put on. If they do that kinda thing.


Go to the ER and get antibiotics. If an infection sets into your tendon sheath, the stuff you see moving around, and you dont get care you may lose some of your limb. Ask me how i know? I still have my finger but it was a little more than a year in and out of the hospital to save one stupid finger.

Do not play with deep cuts to the back of your hand.

I would also like to say that like you my first RMK was. Similar #14. It isn't a bushcraft knife, dont hack up the guard get a better model for your use. I hope my advice was welcome.

-Ron
 
I appreciate the reply, Ron. No worries buddy, I was a medic, I've got the wound under control now and if any complications arise I will be visiting the ER or Doc.

I disagree with what ya said about being a bushcraft knife though, it works pretty good and I've used alot stranger before. :p

Any specific tests ya'll would like to see with this knife? I'm more than happy to do anything within reason.

Also, don't feel shy about posting your own pics if yall want to. :)
 
Awesome pics. Thanks for sharing.

Try and be a bit more careful next time, huh? We don't need you choppin' off your hand so you don't have one to take pics with when using your Randall. C'mon, man.

:D
 
Btw, as I remember... the 14 with a squared half-hilt and BPH is considered the "Camp" version.

:thumbup:
 
Awesome pics. Thanks for sharing.

Try and be a bit more careful next time, huh? We don't need you choppin' off your hand so you don't have one to take pics with when using your Randall. C'mon, man.

:D

Yeah man if I do much worse next time I'll have to buy a Randall Made prosthetic. :p
 
I carry a 17 in the woods if im not carrying a Reeve. nice looking 14 good to see it being used
 
I carry a 17 in the woods if im not carrying a Reeve. nice looking 14 good to see it being used

Nice, don't think I've heard of someone actually using an Astro. By Reeve I assume you mean, CRK, which models do you normall carry? Feel free to share pics, bud.
 
Btw, as I remember... the 14 with a squared half-hilt and BPH is considered the "Camp" version.

:thumbup:

I think that is a #5 to be a "camp". Pretty much the same thing. I was thinking Machine26 would like a #5 with green micarta finger grip handle, and brass double hilt guard on at 8" of blade.

Mine are in my profile but I took a family shot the other day let me go fetch that.........
 
Most of them are users. The right most #14 I did the handle on. The #14 on the left with the green micarta was the one that reminded of your blade. It was a double hilt when I recieved it, but i cut it off for more utility, I have since found that the #14 is not my favorite for bushcrafting and camping and often wish to have my guard back the way it was for that #14.
 
Huuummmmm. I just had an idea. If you really want a squared off top hilt, we could likely help each other. Our knives are identical except for my blades discoloration, and the modified hilt. If you really want to cut yours off, you might consider this first.
 
I appreciate the offer bud but I'm not gonna cut the top guard off. I just knocked the hard edge down and now it doesn't dig into my hand. I used my fine sharpmaker stones, can't even tell I modified it when ya look at it.

ETA: Was just brainstorming earlier about removing the top guard. I thought about the same thing with my 18, but in all honesty I don't think I could bring myself to change em. Double guard isn't all that bad once ya get accustomed to it.
 
Ron, is the bottom one in your pic a 4-6 fighter? I really like it.
 
Ron, is the bottom one in your pic a 4-6 fighter? I really like it.

Yes sir. I love it too. I had it for a week or two when I ordered a second exactly the same from the shop. It is a very keen gride on the blade to boot.
 
Yes sir. I love it too. I had it for a week or two when I ordered a second exactly the same from the shop. It is a very keen gride on the blade to boot.

Nice. There are a few blades that just scream COOL when you see them. That is one that also screams practical. Hard to beat that combo.
 
Back
Top