More flashlight reviews for the poor and the cheap (long, sorry)

Joined
Sep 25, 2002
Messages
3,179
First up is the River Rock LED keychain light. $5.99 at the local Target. It's similar to the Streamlight Keymate. The head's a little thinner and it uses three button cells instead of four. It's also lacking the Keymate's stout clip. It feels a hair lighter than the Keymate but the postal scale at work says they're both .9 oz. I expect the green anodized finish will show scrathces soon enough. Under the flat lens is a dome like lens giving the light a strange pattern. It's like looking at Saturn. A perfectly circular spot with rings instead of a gradual spill. Not that big a deal on a light this size. It's a "find the keyhole" light, not a "find the trail light". It's brighter than my Keymate but my baby Streamlight isn't running of the freshest batteries. I suspect the Keymate would be brighter if it had fresh cells. I think this one will go on my work keys. For a six dollar torch the finish is uniform and the knurling on the head and body is good. For a dollar more the Inova Microlight is probably a better buy but my wife has one of those and I wanted to try something different. I would rate it behind the Keymate and Microlight but ahead of Princeton-Tek's Photon clone (pass on the PulsarII) and the Mag-Lite Solitare.

Next up is the River Rock .5 Watt LED that runs on 2AAA ($10). This does not look like it rolled out of the same factory. Satin black finish, no knurling, pocket clip (none too strong), no Rings of Saturn dome lens, 4.5" x .75". The insert says it's regulated. Of course the insert also says it weighs 4.5oz while the postal scale says it's 2.1oz (the real weight). I actually forgot it was in my shirt pocket until the wife brought me lunch and asked how many flashlights I needed. "Uh, three?" The tailcap turns for continuous light and the button is momentary. It won't knock your socks off but I don't think you'll throw it out of a moving car in disgust. It would make a good stocking stuffer for a kid or one for the desk drawer.

Also at the $10 mark I picked up the Nite-Ize LED conversion for my ancient Mini-Mag. It was easy to put in, only took me a few minutes (and I hadn't even had my first cup of coffee). Works just fine. Really need some fresh batteries in there, though (It's been sitting in my desk drawer for a year and a half. Even with the old batteries it's still bright enough to find your way out of a dark room. The tail cap switch is a big improvement. It's not recessed and the the spring isn't that strong but the kit it still better than the spotty/twisty beam the stock bulb puts out. The Mini-Mag's not a great light but this one has stood up to 7-8 years of being tossed around and dropped. I guess I got my dollars worth.

Lastly, one more River Rock. This one was $20. A 1.5W, 2AA number. It looks like the grown up version of the keychain light. Not bad looking, really. It's 1.1" x 6.8", 4.7oz. Green anodized, knurled and fluted. Says it's regulated. And we're back to the Rings of Saturn dome (really bright, though). Enough spill you won't run into a wall but this one's really a spot. The on/off switch is on the side behind the head, engages with a positive click. Comes with a wrist lanyard, nice touch, I guess. This is at least as nice as the Metal Gear by Dorcy and about the same price. Pretty nice light for $20. If you're in Target and simply must come home with a goodie this is worth consideration.

I know I could have ordered one good light online but we have at least a couple of power outages every summer and I wanted lights all over the house. They had a couple of Dorcys I might go back for (when I go back for batteries). Maybe I'll put a Fenix on my Christmas list, by all accounts it's an excellent EDC.

Frank
 
SilverFoxKnows said:
Also at the $10 mark I picked up the Nite-Ize LED conversion for my ancient Mini-Mag.

Thanks for your reviews, Frank. I own most of those Target RiverRocks, too. :)

I've decided the AAx2 Maglite with NiteIze LED upgrade is the best, cheapest light I've ever owned. I've owned better (and more expensive) flashlights, as well as cheaper (usually less solidly made) lights, but never a better, cheaper light than the AAx2 Mag + NiteIze LED.

I work in a white-collar environment and I would feel self-conscious carrying a AAx2 Mag on my belt, and it feels too big for pocket carry, so I'll always have a Fenix or similar 'pocket rocket' light. But I've gotten to the point where I've put aside my 'belt carry' size lights (usually xenon or krypton incandescents or large multi-cell LED lights) aside in favor of a Mag + LED.
 
Back
Top