Most use of the SAK.

Joined
Oct 2, 2004
Messages
17,501
What do we use our SAK's the most for?

I guess it all depends on who we are, what we are, and were we live. Climate, environment, and employment can make a big difference in what we need of our SAK's. I now that now, I need much less than when I was a young stud full of vinegar and out in the world while serving in the U.S. Army Combat Engineers. And it made a huge difference from the dark pine forests of Germany to the soaked rice paddies of Vietnam. Or from the wilds of the streets of my native D.C. to the florescent lights of the machine shop that I earned a living in.

For the most part, my SAK was mostly a pocket knife. I think most times I reached for it, it was to cut something. A package that needed opening, or mail, a UPS box, jute twine in the garden, a perfect hot dog stick for the kids while camping, and much later, the grandkids. For me, the two layer SAK's were the ideal, with two blades and a few basic tools. I had a tinker for a very long time, and it was good. My old Wenger SI was a standby for a few decades, and watching my wife torture a little classic was highly instructive as to how much a little 58mm was capable of.

Aside from a knife and cutting tool, I think nowadays some kind of small screw driver is needed for all the small Phillips screws that our society uses to hold the universe together. It seems like small electronics from battery operated pencil sharpeners to little flashlights like the Photons all use tiny Phillips screws. The aluminum drawer guides on IKEA furniture use them, as does kitchen and bathroom cabinetry.

Then theres scissors. They were not important to me when I was younger, but for some reason now as an old fogy, scissors have become much more important. So important in fact, that I find that I'd rather sacrifice the second blade for scissors. Blade and scissors are a must. Theres just sooooo much that is easier to snip than slice. :eek:

Tweezers. I've got to have tweezers. Looking back on it all, theres been too many times that the little tweezers were so handy to have. Splinters, stickers between the paw pads of a beloved canine companion. Even a roach clip in my younger day with a certain young lady from NYC long before I met the great love of my life.

So, for me the SAK is a pocket knife with a few basic tools on the side.
 
Aside from a knife and cutting tool, I think nowadays some kind of small screw driver is needed for all the small Phillips screws that our society uses to hold the universe together. It seems like small electronics from battery operated pencil sharpeners to little flashlights like the Photons all use tiny Phillips screws. The aluminum drawer guides on IKEA furniture use them, as does kitchen and bathroom cabinetry.

Then theres scissors. They were not important to me when I was younger, but for some reason now as an old fogy, scissors have become much more important. So important in fact, that I find that I'd rather sacrifice the second blade for scissors. Blade and scissors are a must. Theres just sooooo much that is easier to snip than slice. :eek:
The Rambler has a #0 Phillips that works up to #2 screw heads, and can access many recessed screws. I've found it indispensable at times. Highly recommended.

I find 58mm scissors enough for just about all scissors tasks. Used them yesterday to cut tape ties from staked small trees. The job was too fiddly for a blade.
 
The blade , followed by the small s/d on the end of the can opener to turn screws in all kinds of things. That said, I generally end up using every tool on the knife at least once every couple of days. I usually carry the Pioneer for grunty jobs and the ability to abuse , and the Tinker for everything else(that small blade is the cats pyjamas :D )
 
As Ive gotten older it’s been the small SD tip and scissors. Having 4 kids and a house, there’s always loose screws to tighten, toys to assemble, and shirt tags to cut off. The two blades on my Executive pretty much handle any knife cutting task required. Box tear down, garden pruning, twine cutting, and cutting up my kids steak.
 
What do we use our SAK's the most for?
<snip>
So, for me the SAK is a pocket knife with a few basic tools on the side.
My regular carry SAK is still a knife with a few basic tools that I use fairly often. I have a scissors on my LM Squirt but I have only used it once in years. My latest use that I now consider indispensable is to use the flat head screw driver to tighten the camera attachment screw on my tripod (quick release plates) beyond finger tight. Makes a world of difference. Funny I never thought of it sooner?? The phillips head gets used less.

I might add that a scissors is the RIGHT tool to remove the plastic tag fasteners that stores use now. Using a knife on clothing purchases can sometimes be dangerous to your purchase.
 
Last edited:
As Ive gotten older it’s been the small SD tip and scissors. Having 4 kids and a house, there’s always loose screws to tighten, toys to assemble, and shirt tags to cut off. The two blades on my Executive pretty much handle any knife cutting task required. Box tear down, garden pruning, twine cutting, and cutting up my kids steak.

I have lost count of the stuff that I have fixed/finagled/jury rigged with the SD tip of both the classic and later the executive. Toasters, electric trolling motors, rented motor scooters, fishing reels, guns, light switches, toys, electric pencil sharpener, bicycle derailer shift mechanisms, and the load of stuff that comes with the directions of "Some assembly required."

From my days of carrying the Case peanut as a main pocket knife with periods of a classic as my D.C. walk around, I've made the discovery that a small sharp blade is more than capable of breaking down a box or cutting twine or other cordage. It can even cut a chill dog in half to split with the better half. :thumbsup:
 
The following are the features I find myself using the most. I always have my Executive, but I still vary between my Spartan and Pioneer as a companion carry to the Executive.

On my Executive, my most used features are:
1. Small blade
2. Nail file
3. Scissors
4. Tweezers
5. Toothpick (used more for cleaning lint from the knife than picking my teeth)
6. Orange peeler...serrated blade, scraper, plastic seal breaker, and reaches some small recessed screws

Spartan:
1. Can opener/small driver...I’m always opening cans when cooking and as a scraping tool, and the driver also works for some Phillips screws
2. Large driver/bottle opener...mostly use it as a light-duty prybar/box opener Haven’t used it much as a driver or for opening bottles
3. Large blade...besides for cutting, it comes in handy as a makeshift mirror on the nailnick side
4. Small
5. Corkscrew...loosening stubborn knots and holding eyeglass screwdriver
6. Eyeglass driver...I should’ve put this higher on the list, as I use it a lot
7. Toothpick (see above)
8. Tweezers (see above)

Pioneer (if opting it over the Spartan)
1. Large driver/bottle opener (see above)
2. Can opener/small driver (see above)
3. Awl (works great for making holes, but also as a scraper and alternate cutting blade
4. Large blade (see above)

Jim
 
Last edited:
The following are the features I find myself using the most. I always have my Executive, but I still vary between my Spartan and Pioneer as a companion carry to the Executive.
Generally if I want to carry a companion knife, it will not be a SAK. It will be larger more than likely. I have a few modern knives that I like a lot, but not enough to carry every day any more.
 
Generally if I want to carry a companion knife, it will not be a SAK. It will be larger more than likely. I have a few modern knives that I like a lot, but not enough to carry every day any more.
I consider the two SAKs I carry as almost a continuum of each other. I also carry a clip knife most of the time, usually my Spyderco Manix 2. I wear cargo pants, so carrying the two SAKs in separate pockets, plus the Manix 2 clipped, isn’t a chore for me. I use the SAKs more on most given days, both of them. But there are times I’ve been glad I had the Manix 2 (or some other Spyderco) for certain cutting jobs. I always carry the knives in the same pockets, so carrying three knives (or at least the two SAKs) feels natural.

Jim
 
I've been rocking a small tinker since about December when I replaced a Leatherman juice s2 with it and a pair of knipex pliers. The most used tool for me is by far the combo tool for the large screwdriver. I use the can opener to clean out the grooves on chainsaw bars quite often as well. From our chipper or stump grinder to small engine work I use it almost every day, even if it's just to scrape gunk off of something. My companion knife for it is a Douk Douk, so that covers most of my cutting needs, and a belt knife for the really ugly stuff. I just got a pioneer yesterday... I'm trying to convince myself to carry that over the small tinker. That in line awl seems a lot more convenient, but I'm attached to what I carry every day for some reason.

There's also a rambler in my backpack for the scissors...
 
.....I just got a pioneer yesterday... I'm trying to convince myself to carry that over the small tinker. That in line awl seems a lot more convenient, but I'm attached to what I carry every day for some reason.

There's also a rambler in my backpack for the scissors...
I can understand perfectly. I carried the Vic 111mm Adventurer (side lock model that was discontinued) for 15 years or so. It did everything I wanted it to do. Prior to that I carried a regular Tinker or the Soldier.... and I just felt more comfortable going a bit larger for what I thought was versatility. Then J jackknife started the peanut (go small) thread over in the traditional forum. I decided to give a peanut a try. I did for a month or so and ended up going slightly larger with the Small Tinker. But why not the regular Tinker or Pioneer? Well, I own a couple regular Tinkers and one Pioneer that are pretty much unused (and some older used Tinkers and the Soldier). So, why not one of those again?

Why not a one blade traditional that seem so popular? That decision was fairly easy... I liked two blades..... My 111mm Adventurer had only one blade. So, should I change? I always liked the Adventurer and it was so handy with the side lock feature....

Why not a Classic? I tried that and didn't care or it. It felt puny and weak.

I was really taking a hard look at what I actually used a knife for and at the same time what size I was most comfortable carrying.... watch pocket size or slightly larger.... that was the question! Is there a practical difference for me between a regular Tinker or Pioneer versus the 111mm Adventurer? For me no. I didn't carry the Small Tinker for about 9 months after getting it. Then with the peanut experiment, I dug it out and gave it a try along with a small three blade stockman. Over a period of about a month using it, it convinced me that for my normal urban and around the house carry, the Small Tinker was enough, carried so easy, and I felt comfortable carrying a larger knife that I felt was not redundant if I chose to. I don't really like to carry piles of knives in my pockets.... so I made a decision.... Small Tinker. Small, useful, and I have a second little blade should I need it.
 
Last edited:
I can understand perfectly. I carried the Vic 111mm Adventurer (side lock model that was discontinued) for 15 years or so. It did everything I wanted it to do. Prior to that I carried a regular Tinker or the Soldier.... and I just felt more comfortable going a bit larger for what I thought was versatility. Then J jackknife started the peanut (go small) thread over in the traditional forum. I decided to give a peanut a try. I did for a month or so and ended up going slightly larger with the Small Tinker. But why not the regular Tinker or Pioneer? Well, I own a couple regular Tinkers and one Pioneer that are pretty much unused (and some older used Tinkers and the Soldier). So, why not one of those again?

Why not a one blade traditional that seem so popular? That decision was fairly easy... I liked two blades..... My 111mm Adventurer had only one blade. So, should I change? I always liked the Adventurer and it was so handy with the side lock feature....

Why not a Classic? I tried that and didn't care or it. It felt puny and weak.

I was really taking a hard look at what I actually used a knife for and at the same time what size I was most comfortable carrying.... watch pocket size or slightly larger.... that was the question! Is there a practical difference for me between a regular Tinker or Pioneer versus the 111mm Adventurer? For me no. I didn't carry the Small Tinker for about 9 months after getting it. Then with the peanut experiment, I dug it out and gave it a try along with a small three blade stockman. Over a period of about a month using it, it convinced me that for my normal urban and around the house carry, the Small Tinker was enough, carried so easy, and I felt comfortable carrying a larger knife that I felt was not redundant if I chose to. I don't really like to carry piles of knives in my pockets.... so I made a decision.... Small Tinker. Small, useful, and I have a second little blade should I need it.

I have absolutely no doubt that for the most part the small tinker could handle most of my knife needs, I experimented with my son's 91mm tinker for a week or so and didn't like the way it sat in my pocket next to the pliers, I liked the toolset so I went for the smaller version, and haven't been disappointed. I like to have the sheath knife handy pretty much for the little oh no moments that can arise while doing tree work (I once had my shaggy pate get caught up in my friction hitch climbing). My thoughts on the pioneer being that I could take both my main pocket knife and the small tinker out of the pockets and have one do all blade/tool handy. I also really like the more robust combo tool, and since that gets used so much I feel like I might be better served.
 
If you main pocket knife is larger than the Small Tinker, I think it probably serves a different purpose/role for you. One of the things I like about the Small Tinker is that it has full sized tools with a smaller main blade than the larger Tinker. The Electrician is another favorite of mine too.... too much competition for pocket time.
 
Back
Top