My survival 'heroes'

Joined
Sep 7, 2006
Messages
6,199
Hey all,

I have long been fascinated with stories of survival and have collected a number of them. And I'm always looking for more. Of course, this whole topic has now become very popular on television and that's cool too. Its introduced me to new people like Ray Mears and I very much enjoy his work.

Come to think of it, Ray is definitely one of my heroes. I think he's a really cool guy who knows his stuff but doesn't ham it up for the cameras. He's also a student of survival, beyond the mere skills it takes to survive, and delves into the psychology of it too. I also enjoy him because he's an environmentalist who loves nature. A lot of people scoff at this and think it shows some kind of weakness but I see it as a major strength. Ray obviously loves the wilderness and wants to preserve it like it is. He also knows that he can survive without destroying. He only takes what he needs and he shows respect for his surroundings at all times. That makes a lot of sense to me.

Three more guys I learned a lot from are:

Steven Callahan. Steven survived 76 days at sea aboard a life raft. He told his story in an amazing book called Adrift. I really recommend you check it out. I think what this guy achieved is pretty incredible. It has a lot of lessons for anyone interested in survival. Obviously its specific to the sea (the most hostile environment there is) but you can take a lot from it. The dude is an inspiration. Oddly enough, I was watching Ray Mears' Extreme Survival series, which I have on DVD, and there pops up Steven Callahan in the flesh, many years later! It was great to see him tell his story in an interview. The book is really something though. Totally worth a read.

Aron Ralston. This is a controversial one, no doubt, but Aron is a The Man, in my eyes. His book is a great read. Its also a terrific lesson of what NOT to do when setting out into the wilderness. I think those lessons are just as valuable as the ones where guys do everything right, like Mr Callahan above. Aron made a number of major errors, but the bottom line is he did what it took to survive. I dont think there are many people on this planet who could have done what he did. Yeah, he screwed up, he was reckless, but he paid a very steep price for that. I really enjoy reading his story - Between a Rock and a Hard Place - and always learn from it.

Cody Lundin. He's another controversial guy and funnily enough, I havent gotten around to reading any of his books. I mostly know him from Dual Survival. But again, he's a dude I feel who has the right approach to the whole subject. He just adapts so well to his surroundings, takes only what he needs to survive, does what he needs to do and carries on. I really enjoy his demeanour and his sense of humour, and he clearly has knowledge up the wazoo. I do think the brain is the most powerful tool we have and Cody uses his a lot. I do think he should invest in some shoes though. Although he'd probably prefer sandals. :D

Thanks for reading!

Mark
 
I don't consider any of the survival personalities as heros but I enjoy watching Ray Mears. He seems very knowledgeable but humble. The others no so much. Survivor man is ok imo and same for cody lundin.

My least favorite would be dave cantebury. I wouldn't mind dual survival if they replaced dave c with survivorman.
 
Most of what I've seen from Ray Mears is not what I would call 'survival' in a strict sense. I think he did one or two series that were actually focused on survival situations, and they were quite good, not being ego-centric sensationalism like many others. But most of his series are more like anthropology documenteries, exploring the daily skills primitive people lived by. Of course there are plenty of skills he teaches/uses that would be useful in a survival situation. His series are less contrived, more straightforward educational, which I like, and which is probably why they don't air in the US.

Of the contrived survival show guys, I like Les Stroud the best. I think his is the only show that doesn't trivialize the reality of sustaining yourself for even a week without some basic essentials. It shows how much it sucks to only get an hour of sleep every night because you're just too cold, and how depleted you get after not eating anything substantial for a few days. Plus he has a conservative mindset with regards to taking risks. It's a very 'real' show.

I've only watched one episode of the dual survivor show, but it seemed way to contrived and personality-driven for me. I don't think I've seen enough to judge their skills, but it had the feel of one of these new breed of brain dead docu-drama reality shows that History/Discovery are making ("Swamp People"). It was too annoying for me to try to learn anything from it.
 
I'm sure I flagged up the Callahan book up here some years ago as an example I use to put things in perspective. It goes something along the lines of: Consider a guy inside something not much bigger that than a kiddies inflatable paddling pool for about two and a half months. Not a great deal of stretching the legs going on there unless he jumps over the side for a swim or does a bit of a standing balancing act. Annoying hey. Just for fun let's shut down most of his food and water. Shall we toast the poor sod? Yeah, stick it to him. Lets crank up the heat and give him some sun burn to go with his festering sores. He'll love that, especially since raft has become a salt pit from the constantly evaporated sea spray remnants. That'll do him some good. The constant fear of the state of the weather, and the stuff that is swimming about him has been in part mitigated by the fact that he's catching fish and sucking their juices. Damn him, let's shit him up a bit and see to it that he has to repeatedly improvise methods to keep the thing afloat. And on and on, even before we get to the social deprivation and all that fun stuff. Yeah, perspective! One reads accounts of people on land that just give up and think “but man, you're on land”.…....... The other guys in your list I've read and I am better informed about, but no more. Steven Callahan I'll never tire of applauding for that. A+ for valiant effort.
 
You may want to read Sole Survivor by Ruthanne Lum McCunn. It is the story of a 22-year old man who survived for 133 days adrift at sea after his ship was torpedoed by a U-boat during WWII.

He learned how to survive by making tools from what little he had on his wooden raft (a square pallet), from a knife made out of a can lid, to his fishing gear from a nail and thread from his clothing, to collecting water and surviving from the elements. He was determined not to die.

I first read this 20+ years ago and I still remember the story. It has contributed very heavily towards my philosophy of being heavy on knowledge, not gear.
 
lumps8v23jw2a9pa.jpg
 
I'm sure I flagged up the Callahan book up here some years ago as an example I use to put things in perspective. It goes something along the lines of: Consider a guy inside something not much bigger that than a kiddies inflatable paddling pool for about two and a half months. Not a great deal of stretching the legs going on there unless he jumps over the side for a swim or does a bit of a standing balancing act. Annoying hey. Just for fun let's shut down most of his food and water. Shall we toast the poor sod? Yeah, stick it to him. Lets crank up the heat and give him some sun burn to go with his festering sores. He'll love that, especially since raft has become a salt pit from the constantly evaporated sea spray remnants. That'll do him some good. The constant fear of the state of the weather, and the stuff that is swimming about him has been in part mitigated by the fact that he's catching fish and sucking their juices. Damn him, let's shit him up a bit and see to it that he has to repeatedly improvise methods to keep the thing afloat. And on and on, even before we get to the social deprivation and all that fun stuff. Yeah, perspective! One reads accounts of people on land that just give up and think “but man, you're on land”.…....... The other guys in your list I've read and I am better informed about, but no more. Steven Callahan I'll never tire of applauding for that. A+ for valiant effort.

+1 :thumbup: - I remember the relief I felt when Callahan finally solved the problem of the recurring leak in the bottom tube of the raft.

Doc
 
I don't consider any of the survival personalities as heros but I enjoy watching Ray Mears. He seems very knowledgeable but humble. The others no so much. Survivor man is ok imo and same for cody lundin.

My least favorite would be dave cantebury. I wouldn't mind dual survival if they replaced dave c with survivorman.

You realize that Discovery removed Dave Canterbury last Fall. They are finding a new Dual Survival character (or have found one now) who will be with Cody Lundin in the next videos of Dual Survival.
 
Of the contrived survival show guys...
I'd never thought of it that way. You have perfectly described those shows, especially the "king of contrived stuff" Bear Grylls.

I have to confess that I enjoy watching Bear's shows. He is personable and entertaining and goes to some really beautiful places on the planet. I don't, however, expect to learn a lot of survival skills. On the other hand, he talks a lot about how the most powerful survival tool is a PMA - positive mental attitude - which is very true.
 
Don't forget the Bushtucker man, a great survivalist without all the over dramatic antics !

[youtube]yObpeHD6_X4[/youtube]
 
Well my Survival heroes are Lewis & Clark! now I have favorite Survival instructors which would include Ray Mears and Lofty Wiseman.
 
I got started with Ron Hood videos and his Hoodlums website in 2007. I guess he'd be the one.
 
You realize that Discovery removed Dave Canterbury last Fall. They are finding a new Dual Survival character (or have found one now) who will be with Cody Lundin in the next videos of Dual Survival.

They ought to just rename it Survival... Cody could probably teach a whole lot of survival stuff on his own, without the drama between him and Dave.
 
Back
Top